STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 239 the Metaphysics, no student of Aristotle can fail to derive a great deal of instruction and stimulus from his close grappling with the many problems presented by the text as it stands. Especially interesting is the second part, entitled "Die literarische Stellung und Form der Metaphysik," which is elaborated, evidently under the influence of von WUamowitz, into some- thing like a systematic history of the delivery and publication of professional lectures in antiquity. Paul Shorby Sophistik und Rhetorik. Das Bildungsideal des ei5 Xe'yeiv in seinem Verhaltnis zur Philosophie des V. Jahrhunderts. Von H. GoMPEBZ. Leipzig: Teubner, 1912. Pp. vi+292. M. 10. The writer, who must be distinguished from his father, the author of Greek Thinkers, has chosen for his special domain the border-land of philoso- phy, rhetoric, and sophistic in the fifth and fourth centuries. The main thesis of the present volume is that sophistic was in its essence rhetoric — the theory and practice of the art ev \eynv — and that all philosophic, scientific, or other special interests which modem historians of philosophy attribute by tradition to the fifth-century Sophists are to be taken in strict subordination to this dominant end. In confirmation of this presumption, he undertakes a broad and somewhat prolix survey of the extant tradition as conveniently collected in Diels. Gorgias' treatise on Nature or the Non- existent is not a serious exposition of critical skepticism, but the maintenance of a paradoxical thesis in the style and the logical divisions of his Praise of Helen and his Defence of Palamedes, the genuineness of which Gomperz defends at length. Thrasymachus did not teach the ethical nihilism attrib- uted to him by Plato. The famous fragment to the effect that the gods do not concern themselves with human affairs since men obviously make no use of justice must have been a mere jest of one of the uTrcp/SoWovres or exaggerating discourses. The Thrasymachus of the first book of the Republic is merely a dramatic representative of an unknown contemporary attacked by Plato — the author of the Clitophon which Gomperz thinks was written about 390. This unknown writer, after there exposing the negative and unsatisfactory character of all Socratic defiaitions of justice, probably went on in a lost supplement to the Clitophon to develop as his own definition the formula which Plato attributes to Thrasymachus — ^that justice is the advantage of the stronger. Antiphon the Sophist is to be distinguished from the orator. Though a student of Empedocles, he is not properly speaking a philosopher; he is the rhetorician of the elevated commonplace, as Gorgias is the rhetorician of the paradox. The predominance of the merely formal over the substantive interest in Hippias, the Anonymus of lamblichus, and the Dialexeis is easily demonstrated. Prodicus' advanced course in synonyms was not a scientific 240 Book Reviews study of semasiology, but a practical guide to the use of the effective word in oratory and debate. His Choice of Heracles was doubtless an edifying discourse for young men to hear, and to that extent he, like other Sophists, "taught virtue." But this is not enough to constitute him either an ethical philosopher or a moral idealist of the Socratic or Platonic type. Some twelve pages of Diels suflBice for the collection of aU that antiquity has told us about Protagoras. Gomperz' comment fills some hundred and fifty pages of his book. He is not the first and will not be the last to write at inordinate length about Protagoras, and I mention the fact, not by way of censure, but as one more illustration of the paradox that philologists tend to enlarge their treatment of a subject in the inverse ratio to available evidence — rois /ttxpois ixiyeBoi Trepidetvai. We have no means of reconciling the seeming contradiction between the dialectic helplessness of the Protagoras of the dialogue which bears his name and the subtle psy- chology of the apology attributed to him in the Theaetetits. The probabilities can be stated in a paragraph. The systematic exposition of a coherent doctrine of relativity and positivism, or pragmatism as the fashion of the day calls it, is probably a Platonic development of suggestions latent in isolated Protagorean paradoxes and epigrams. On this point Gomperz seems to agree with me against his father, as he does in maintaining that Protagoras would have hardly distinguished between the generic and the individual interpretation of homo mensura, though if option is forced, we must decide for the individual interpretation. But though he believes that the systematic form of the exposition is Platonic, he thinks it possible to prove that the main doctrinal content is Protagorean. In the details of this demonstration I cannot follow him. His conclusion is that Protagoras is the only Sophist who is at the same time an original philosophic thinker. Yet the philosophy even of Protagoras is merely an introduction to, or a by- product of, his rhetoric. The principle of relativity and the universal anthesis of the two logoi are symbols and reflections of the opposing theses and argtmients in rhetorical debate. Into this rhetorical world of beautiful plausibility Socrates enters with the questions: How is the thing really ? What is the truth of the matter ? The development of these questions by Plato and Aristotle opposed a new ideal of scientific education and culture to the purely formal ideal of the Sophists. Yet (p. 290) ' ' so ware Platon nicht Platon geworden, hatte er nicht die erfinderische Vielseitigkeit des Gedankens imd die kiinsterlische Vollen- dung der Sprache von den Sophisten (ibernommen und sie in den Dienst der socratischen Postulate gesteUt." The style is readable and the book is full of interesting suggestions. It is, however, by no means free from the false point-making, straining of evi- dence, forced parallels and perverse ingenuity which are the bane of present- day philology. As I have harped perhaps too often upon this string, I will here confine myself to one example. On page 164 the author argues that Book Reviews 241 the verbal coincidence of the Dialexeis and the pseudo-Platonic Trepl SiKalov in the expressions iv teXf.ia in Rep. 3896 and 3346, and as he could have found in Symp. 181A the entire thought (though not the words) of the argument that no act is good or bad in itself, but only through the manner of its perfonnance. Paul Shoeey Luciani quae feruntur Podagra et Ocypus. Praefatus edidit commen- tatus est Johannes Zimmehmann. Lipsiae: in aedibus B. G. Teubneri, MCMIX. Pp. 82. These two short pieces in verse have led a shifting existence, now accepted by some editors as legitimate Lucianic offspring, now rejected by others as supposititious twins, while by a smaller number of commentators their claims have been differentiated and the Tragopodagra alone admitted to the list of the author's genuine writings. Few, even of seasoned Lucian students, have cared to give them much more than cursory attention. Most readers are well content to reject them as spurious or to accept them apologetically as indicative of the advanced senility of the ex-rhetorician, dropping into verse as he shuffled into his grave. M. Croiset, however, after admitting {La vie et les ceuvres de Lvcien, p. 84) that these two dialogues alone would never have won immortality for the writer, adds: "Mais il y a de I'esprit, du trait, et ce genre d'enjouement ironique et moqueur qui lui dtait propre. Nous n'avons done pas de raison suffisante pour les declarer apocryphes.' ' A verdict based upon such grounds from a writer usually so keen to detect the true Lucianic hall-marks would have greater weight were it not that an attentive reading of the two pieces brings out so clearly the jejune banaUty of the Ocypus, both in matter and manner, that it would seem probable that M. Croiset has transferred the merits, belonging to the Tragopodagra alone, to his estimate of both on the ground that they must stand or fall together. It is just here that Zimmermann's monograph forms a real contribution. He dissociates the two, claiming that the Tragopodagra is genuine and the Ocypus spurious, and proceeds to examine them with somewhat meticulous Teutonic detail and occasional over-emphasis of nonessentials.