STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Keviews 109 The cavern he places in the orchestra, where the work of rescue is per- formed by the chorus alone under the direction of Hermes and Try- gaeus. The troublesome Boeotians, Argives, etc., as well as Lamachus, were presumably left to the imagination of the audience. By means of the anapiesma the statue of Peace was raised, with Opora and Theoria in her arms, until her head towered aloft close beside Hermes. We are startled for a moment at the apparition of Soxruxs and Eav&as in the place of our old friends OUerrji A and OlKtTrp B; but are relieved upon discovering a preliminary note to the effect that this innovation is made solely in order to avoid confusion. It is Xanthias who addresses the audience in the prologue, and who reappears later. The space at my disposal will not permit of any extended notice of the changes introduced into the text by van Leeuwen. The most serious are the rejection of vss. 417, 831, 1002; the insertion of an entire verse after 1243; the transformation of vss. 299, 300 into trimeters {vvv yap wapovvav. Two changes which have much in their favor are KapSowov for avrkuxv in vs. 18, and v/mTs 'Attikoi in place of the unparalleled 'Attikowkoi of vs. 215; in support of the former might be cited the scholium on Nub. 669, where the phraseology is very similar to the note on this passage. Happily van Leeuwen has not always found it necessary to resort to such heroic measures in removing serious diffi- culties; particularly attractive are the following emendations: 180 /xe omitted, 479 exoirat iv ra> £v\w (suggested by Eichard's ivixovrax r<3 £vAo>), 628 pjov for fwi, 760-63 substitution of third person for first, 1154 !£ trap' Aiaylvov for e£ Aio^ivaSou. In two or three instances a simple mark of punctuation helps not a little; thus in 197 (after yap), and in 329 (after SXXo). It must not be thought, however, that the critical ability of this brilliant editor is directed solely in the direction of emendation; it is a pleasure to emphasize the fact that in a large number of instances he defends the traditional text against the attacks of various critics, occa- sionally against his own earlier suspicions (so notably in vss. 48 and 458). By a singular oversight the reading of BV in vs. 455 is reported as Irj instead of it] Irj pxtvov; in vs. 103 the entry for V should be Suivotl (as B), not Suivocts. Harvard University Earnest Cary Die Uberlieferungsgeschichte der vergleichenden Lebensbe- schreibungen Plutarchs. Von Koneat Ziegleb. Leipzig: B. GL Teubner. Pp. viii+208 and 1 plate. Indications are not lacking that, were conditions more favorable, many scholars would consider Plutarch an attractive field for their investiga- 110 Book Reviews tions. Any tendencies in this direction, however, are almost inevitably nipped in the bud by the wretched condition of the text. Notwithstand- ing the advance which Bernardakis' edition of the Moralia made over its predecessors, Wilamowitz' verdict still remains substantially true, "unum iam nunc constat fundamentum recensionis non esse iactum." And for the Vitae, despite several excellent editions of single pairs, the situation is still worse. Yet Plutarch's writings are so voluminous, the manu- scripts so numerous and scattered, and their interrelationships so com- plicated and obscure as to deter even the most hardy from attempting to solve the puzzle and publish a satisfactory text. Such an undertaking demands a lifetime, leisure, means for travel, and unremitting industry. Amid all this confusion Ziegler's book affords much encouragement. By means of printed material, correspondence, and travel he has attempted no less a task than the classification of practically every known manu- script of Plutarch's Lives. It is highly significant that so fundamental and seemingly simple a matter as the order of the Lives in the extant manuscripts has been almost entirely neglected and never adequately determined. And it is to this that Ziegler first devotes himself. Two arrangements recur with enough frequency to prove that they are not due to chance or to the individual caprice of some copyist — a three-book edition and a two-book edition. In the former the Lives are (for the most part) arranged on the basis of Greek nationality (Athenians, Corinthians, etc.) and chronologi- cally within these subdivisions (Theseus, Solon, Themistocles, etc.). In three pairs — Coriolanus-Alcibiades, Aemilius Paulus-Timoleon, and Ser- torius-Eumenes — the Komans precede. The other arrangement ignores national lines and is (for the most part) founded on the chronological sequence of the Greek worthies, and Ziegler has made it seem plausible that this arrangement was derived from the first. Curiously enough, the extant family of MSS (X) which preserves this later edition contains only its first book, while the order of citations from Plutarch in Photius' Bibliotheca shows that he was acquainted with the second book — in fact, this two-book recension had probably been made only shortly before his time. The practical bearing of all this on several Plutarch questions is, of course, manifest, and Ziegler himself in the rest of his book proceeds to make one very useful application. In brief, the arrangement of Lives becomes a criterion by which can be determined at a glance and almost infallibly to which family (X or Y) any MS belongs. Of course, the matter is sometimes complicated, e. g., by several MSS of different origin having been used jointly to produce a new copy, but such exceptions do not invalidate the general value of the test. In the second chapter Ziegler makes a detailed study of the MS tradition for each pair of Lives in turn, and in the third chapter deals Book Keviews 111 with Plutarch citations in various Greek and Byzantine authors. A supplement contains the results obtained by a special trip of research in Italy. Doubtless there are scores of statements in this book which need correction, but it will no longer be necessary for a scholar interested in the text of the Lives to undertake to edit them all or to examine every Plutarch MS in Christendom. Knowing in advance the MSS that con- tain any Life or group of Lives and at least the general relationship between them (however the details may be modified), anyone can now intelligently choose some task great or small according to his time and inclination. The division of labor thus made possible ought to produce a thoroughgoing edition before many decades. In my opinion, the pres- ent work has hastened that result by a quarter-century. It is regrettable that the results given in the supplement could not have been distributed in their proper places throughout the body of the paper. The arrangement of material is somewhat cumbersome and repetitious also in other respects, though doubtless that was not entirely avoidable. The Prussian Akademie der Wissenschaften did itself the honor of awarding Dr. Ziegler a "Nebenpreis." Kot C. Flickingeb NOBTH WESTERN UNIVERSITY De inventions Iuvenalis capita tria Dissertatio quam .... scripsit Alfeedus Habtmann .... Basileae: F. Keinhardt, 1908. Pp. 93. Stimulated by Richard Heinze's appeal for more attention to the historical development of style and technique, the author of this disserta- tion attempts to discover the nature and the limitations of Juvenal's originality. The results, based on a study of the first, third, and fifth satires (the earlier work of the poet), are summarized as follows: Juvenal shares with earlier satirists an interest in everything that is at variance with the laws of nature, but in his early poems as a result either of inherent taste or of personal experience selects for special criticism the phases of life that illustrate inequality and injustice in the social organ- ism. To illustrate this aspect Juvenal attacks the rich and influential class showing the unfairness of its social eminence, and the disastrous effects upon the poor and honest; the poor are also oppressed by the conditions of life in the city. The satirist vivifies his account of injustice by abundant use of contrast, setting over against each other the different circumstances of the two classes. His zeal and intensity of purpose are manifest, but his themes are the commonplaces of satire and diatribe. His own contribution is found in the abundant use of examples and situations, in his refusal to mass and concentrate his material, and in a