STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 332 Book Reviews treats in detail the chief phases of family life. Caillemer's articles in Daremberg et Saglio would have proved extremely useful to him. For example, a perusal of Caillemer's articles on "Dower" and "Divorce" would have undoubtedly led him to modify, if not reject, the view that "immoral behavior" on the part of a wife resulted in the forfeiture of her dower (p. 68). This is true of Homeric and post-classical Greece. But there is no evidence for this rule in the period under discussion. Indeed we are told explicitly in the speech against Neaera that the law required the return of the dower. Professor Savage displays familiarity with a wide range of Greek authors, and his citation of their opinions in con- nection with the various phases of family relationships, as well as the constant use of illustrative cases, adds greatly to the interest of the book. Not so commendable, however, is the habit of giving expression to his own opinion regarding customs and conduct by the free use of adjectives. Under the caption " Husbands Give Their Wives to Others " he cites a case of a transfer inter vivos. As a further illustration he mentions the practice, said to be common among Athenian bankers, of inserting pro- visions in wills that widows are to marry certain specified persons. He seems to be under the impression that these are also transfers inter vivos (p. 62). As a " striking illustration of the lightness with which the mar- riage bond was dissolved," he cites the divorce of Phano by her second husband, Theogenes, the king archon, "because he realizes that she is not a free citizen woman of Athens " (p. 61). Apparently he forgets his own earlier statement (p. 46) " that every Athenian was forbidden by law to marry a foreigner." One will search the Attic orators in vain for a more justifiable divorce, whether one adopts ancient or modern standards. Not only was the young woman a foreigner (ievrj), but she had been divorced by a former husband for following in the footsteps of her notori- ous mother, Neaera. Moreover, Theogenes acted under strong pressure from the Areopagus: he was able to escape punishment only by promis- ing to divorce his wife at once. The most effective chapters in the book are those dealing with "Parents and Children" and "Adoption." In other respects, the book seems calculated to appeal rather to the general reader or to the student of sociology. The work is well written and is practically free from typo- graphical errors. K. J. Bonner On the Interpretation of Empedocles. By Claea Elizabeth Milleed. The University of Chicago Press, 1908. Pp. 94. $0.79 postpaid. This dissertation presents a well-documented and competent review of the present state of critical knowledge and opinion respecting Empe- Book Reviews 333 docles, and is as a rule distinguished by an excellent balance of judgment in dealing with conflicting exegetical theories. It has two virtues some- what rare in special monographs — an avoidance of the temptation to read too much meaning into the author treated, and a willingness to leave uncertain points unsettled. These virtues are, if anything, pushed to an extreme; the writer gives us much careful analysis, but no very vivid hypothetical unification and reconstruction of the Empedoclean view of the universe. In maintaining, against Windelband and others, that Empedocles did not clearly and consistently conceive of the elements as qualitatively un- changeable or of ju,i£is as a purely mechanical combination, the writer appears to be justified by the texts cited; though the interpretation makes it necessary to ascribe to Empedocles, even for his period, a high degree of philosophical ineptitude. The most elaborate and valuable part of the study deals with the much-discussed question of the number of phases in the world-cycle and the relation to these of Love and Strife. The view adopted is essentially that of Burnet : there are four distinguish- able stages: (1) The period when each element "flocks by itself," in com- plete freedom from ju.i£is; (2) the period of increasing Love, leading to the genesis of the world through the intermixture of the elements; (3) the "indefinite homogeneity" of the 2<£atpos, when /xtfis culminates in a com- plete interpenetration of the elements; (4) the period of increasing Strife, when a world is again generated through the separation of the elements from this unity. Periods (1) and (3) are, for opposite reasons, "acosmic;" our world belongs to period (4). The evidence for this interpretation Miss Millerd reviews somewhat more fully than previous writers; nothing very material, however, is added to Burnet's convincing argument, except a pertinent citation from Theophrastus, De sens. 20. On the other hand, the author repeats an error of Burnet's in assigning the " whole-natured forms" of Fr. 62 to a different period from that of the hybrid monsters of Fr. 61. These tvttoi oi\ovas seem to be the same as the hermaphro- dites of Fr. 61, 3, 4. The cognate passage of Aetius (Plac. v. 19) is also, I think, wrongly interpreted. Aetius is classifying the types of "births" recognized by Empedocles; the four classes, which evidently represent stages in a single evolutionary sequence, are: (a) detached limbs; (b) limbs united into bodies, but unco-ordinated; (c) coherent organisms, but with- out sexual differentiation; (d) complete organisms, capable of sexual re- production. The third (c) are Empedocles' oiXoviK. One point of primary consequence — the meaning of the term <£wris, especially in the title IIcpi vo-tvo-tva-iv." That passage will need much explaining away — even if there were not many others — before the proposed rendering of 4>wtk can be regarded as justified. One could wish that Miss Millerd, who is evidently well qualified by learning and judg- ment for such work, had gone to the bottom of the question she raises on pp. 18-20, and given us a thorough semasiological survey of the usage, both technical and literary, of the term in question. Nothing is more greatly needed at the present stage of the study of the pre-Socratics. Arthur O. Lovejoy University op Missouri La metrica di Orazio comparata con la Greca e illustrata su liriche scelte del poeta. Con una Appendice di Carmi di Catullo studiati nei loro diversi metri. Nuova trattazione di Ettoke Stampini. Torino: E. Loescher, 1908. Pp. xlviii + 104. The comparative study of Greek and Latin meter is of course not new. It goes back to the Roman metricians. But seldom since their day has Latin meter been so rigorously made to conform with the Greek as in Stampini's work. The author holds that our views about Latin meter should be changed to meet the advances made in the study of Greek meter, especially as exemplified in Masqueray's treatise (TraiU de mAtrique grecque, Paris, 1899). The long introduction, besides the usual infor- mation, gives all the Latin and Greek technical terms, as well as the musical equivalents. While Stampini has thus made use of all the latest ideas about Greek meter, he has ignored the one great advance that has been made in the study of Latin meter — the recognition of a relation between metrical ictus and word-accent. He knows of it, for he says that the frequent coincidence of word-accent and metrical ictus is due to the laws of word-accent in Latin — in other words, that it is entirely accidental, not intentional. He goes so far as to say that the Latin poets produced this coincidence unwillingly (indipendentemente dalla volonta stessa).