STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 328 Book Reviews figxires in nearly all Foerster's prefaces and never with words of praise. She receives no credit for what must have been an unspeakably tedious job, and is scolded at every turn for her incuria, her lack of diligentia and religio, though if ever a woman proved that she possessed the two latter qualities one would say it is the Eeiskia. To her, justly, no doubt, are put down all the faults, to her husband all the merits of his edition — paulo properantius ut facere consueverat she played her part, not know- ing that she was to prove a warning to the wives of philologists. The advantage of Foerster's instalment method is that he can reply to his critics, whose reviews he answers in a critical preface to Vol. III. He has been blamed for making his edition too long and too short, for admitting too many of his own readings into the text and not enough. He devotes fifty-three pages to the discussion of contested readings, making only the slightest concessions to his critics, of whom Herwerden, Asmus, and Croenert are the most important. His defense of a reading is usually grounded on his knowledge of the sermo Libanianus on which he has certainly earned the right to dogmatize. WiLMEE Cave Weight Beyn Mawr College March, 1909 Greek Historical Writing and Apollo. Two lectures delivered before the University of Oxford by Uleioh von Wilamowitz- MoELLENDOEPF. (Translation by Gilbert Murray.) Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1908. Pp. 45. 2s. No summary can do justice to the infinite riches in a little room pre- sented by these lectures. Still less is it possible to criticize the countless philological and historical obiter dicta thrown out by the way. Historical science, the historical imagination, and critical methods of research are hardly a hundred years old, being later even than Gibbon. No Greek conceived of them. Yet the Greeks are the originators of history as of science and philosophy. Athens might have developed a true critical science of history had time been granted. "But the Athe- nian Empire collapsed .... and on the ruins there arose that phantom growth of rhetoric and sophistic which renounced the search after truth and honesty, and which brought to shipwreck first the learning and then the whole civilization of antiquity." Much of later Greek historical writing, however, is good reading if we accept it frankly as historical romance in the manner of Scott — though without his love for local color. Yet after all it seems the difference is not so great. For we too "when once Dryasdust has done his work within us ... . use our free formative imagination." And Science will supersede Mommsen as Tacitus and Book Reviews 329 Gibbon are superseded. But the investigator may find consolation in the thought that though his own work dies and Truth is relative, he hands on the torch — of method. Apollo is neither the heavenly fiddler of Raphael, nor the sun, nor can his essential character be derived from the life of nature. We can only see that he is a non-Hellenic eastern divinity at first conceived by the Greeks as a power of evil to be propitiated. Leto exists in Greece only as coming in his train. His sanctuaries, under his name, Delos, Ptoion, Delphi are comparatively late. At Delphi in the interval from Hesiod to Pindar the Apolline religion glorified by Otfried Muller, Curtius (and Matthew Arnold) was developed. It is the religion of Pindar and of Sophocles, but not of the other great Athenians nor of Homer. It is the religion of conservative and Dorian Hellas, the religion of yvdOi (TavTov and 4>po(Tvvr) and cwo/xia, but not of ecstasy, hope, progress, and democracy. The Athenians must needs transcend it, and to Euripides it was an abomination. But we, after our science has endeavored to trace the many and diverse Apollos of local cult and legend, may and must revive in our hearts and realize in our lives the Apolline religion of Pindar and Sophocles. It is perhaps pedantry to cavil on a detail amid so much truth and suggestiveness. But would Professor Wilamowitz unless dimv SuK^vXar- To)v seriously maintain that Apollo's originally destructive character is proved by Achilles addressing him as "most deadly of the gods?" Achilles' words are {II. xxii. 15) I^Aa^as ;«.' CKaepye dtiav oXouiTaTe TrdvTiav — " thou hast balked me far-darter, most mischievous of the gods." Obviously this is a mere example of the petulant irreverent familiarity on which Kuskin comments so amusingly. Menelaus says the same of Zeus in II. iii. 365, and Asius in II. xii. 164 calls Zeus ^iKoxfiex^'s because of the disappointment of his own expectations. Similarly it may be doubted whether the description of the gods rising up in fear at the approach of Apollo in the beginning of the Delian Hymn is much more than a slight exaggeration of the honorific motive of II. xv. 85 where the gods rise up to do reverence to Hera. Padl Shoeey Briefwechsel zwischen August Bockh und Ludolph Dissen, Pin- dar tind Anderes betreffend. Herausgegeben von Max Hoffmann. Leipzig: Teubner, 1907. Pp. 233. M. 5. This book possesses considerable value for the student of Pindar, but it is particularly interesting for the picture it gives of the golden age of German classical scholarship — the age of BQckh and Hermann and Welcker. The letters of Dissen in the collection far outnumber those of