STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 461 'A/3v8jjvov iwKJyoprifm, or for the avaricious man, who sells watered wine to his friends, Alexis Aesop, ov irivere aKparov. ov yap paStov. ircoXovox yap iv rati d/ia£cus evdiw Ke.Kpafi.ivov. Both text and version have profited by the elaborate edition of the Leipzig Philologische Gesellschaft, which was studied by Jebb before his death and has been carefully considered by his editor. For the publication of the Characters Cichorius' date of 319 is accepted in place of 316 adopted in the first edition. In xx. 13 (viii) IIoA.v7r«pxo>v is read for Hvkvo-Tripxmv. In xviii. 10 (iii) jtA.gov is reinstated. In viii. 6 (xxvii) "the festival of a hero" has been altered into "festivals of heroes." In xxviii. 25 (xvi) "convolvulus" has been changed to "smilax." What some choose to call English prudery is still conciliated by the omission of certain details. In xxviii. 30 (xvi) Sandys contributes the emendation kari.mft.cvov for io-rcfji.fi.evmv. In the note on xv. 13 (ix) the inference from Plato Apol. 26E that a drachma was the charge for the best places in the theater is abandoned, in accordance with Jebb's later view. There are few if any points in the translation which I would query. In i. 27 (2) may not w juaAaxSs io-Otas possibly be an expression of solici- tude for the host's health, instead of meaning, "how delicate is your fare? " In v. 15 (i) is not bfwXoyrfo-a is perhaps not "I do not understand it," but rather " that is not my understanding of it." In vi. 7 (xxiii) o-vvoBonr6pov Se diroXawras is, I think, simply "if he finds (enjoys) a companion by the road." The idea that he " loves also to impose upon his companion by the road" may be implied, but is hardly to be read into airo\avo-as. In vi. 19 (xxiii) «ru>v Se irapaKaOrffievtav is not, I think, " and actually, although the persons sitting near him are strangers," Kol .... Se here, as often, merely add another item. In ix. 1 (xii) im- revfe in the definition of aKaxpia can hardly be a " chance meeting." In xxviii. 9 (xvi) a reference is needed to Mr. Andrew Lang's Custom and Myth, p. 223. Paul Shorey PlatorCs ausgewahlte Schriften filr den Schulgebrauch. Erklart von Chbistian Ceon und Julius Deuschle. Gorgias. Funfte Auflage neu bearbeitet von Db. Wilhelm Nestle. Leipzig und Berlin: Teubner, 1909. Pp. 194. M. 2.10. Professor Nestle's familiarity with Euripides, the pre-Socratics and the Sophists especially equips him to edit the Gorgias. While avoiding verbosity and useless erudition, he has not accepted the view that a commentary for school use should be limited to a few aids in transla- tion, but supplies everything required to make the thought and the his- 462 Book Reviews torical significance of the dialogue intelligible to both pupil and teacher Especially helpful are the citations from the fragments of Gorgias in the Introduction and the apt references to the Anonymus Iamblichi in the Commentary. I find very little to query or dissent from. Perhaps in 447 A it is misleading to say that irapex« is to be supplied with the idiomatic oi&iv wpaypa. In 449 D is not eVtcucws tovto wpaTTav "do it fairly well," rather than "in gehoriger, geziemender Weise"? In 455 E on Stot ix&tov Ttixos it is assumed without discussion that there were three walls. In 474 A I think he misses the Socratic irony of yeWra irap&xov Kal ovk 7fwuTTa.fi,Tjv iirul>r)v St) with BTWE and Burnet, instead of St. But iraow S») is rather to be expected in the generalizing conclusion of an induction. Ilaow Be is more appropriate when, as here, a second step in the argument is taken to be followed by a third, erepai M ye. In 465 D the words ev tiS aural are thrown out as a mere interpretation of 6/xov. But in the context they are perhaps needed to bring out the illustration of the preceding vpovrat ev Tip owTtp by the familiar phrase of Anaxagoras which contains no vpovri\oao4>m is "no longer" the love of wisdom, but the idea of science. He does not cite Robin TMorie platonicienne de Vamour, who argues for a late date of the Phaedrus, nor my Unity of Plato's Thought, to the arguments of which on this point I have nothing to add. I am pleased to see that in the note on 463 A he agrees with me in finding intentional parody in Plato's malicious substitution of o-Toxaorwcijs for Isocrates' So&kttoojs. Paul Shore? Pindari carmina cum fragmentis selectis. Edidit Otto Schboe- der. Leipzig: Teubner, 1908. Pp. xii + 360. M 2.41. Otto Schroeder, professor in the Joachimstalsches Gymnasium in Berlin, is probably the foremost living Pindaric scholar. His great edi- tion of 1900, which appeared as the first volume of the fifth edition of Bergk's Poetae lyrici, was no mere revision of Bergk, but a new work, based upon a fresh collation of the MSS, and in every way a monument of learning and insight, combined with minute accuracy. It must long remain the standard critical edition of Pindar. The present book offers in a somewhat revised form the text of the preceding, in a small and beautifully printed volume of the Teubner series, which takes its place at once as the best and most convenient text-edition available. The introductory matter marvelously condensed (like everything of Schroe- der's) includes the necessary information concerning MSS, editions, auxiliary works, chronology, etc., in the space of six pages. The excellent translation of Ernest Myers might well have been mentioned instead of the fragmentary translations of Paton. In the body of the work, the brief critical apparatus at the foot of the page aims not so much at giving a full report of the readings of the best MSS, as at showing the difference between the Ambrosian and Vatican traditions, adding, however, a few other readings and conjectures, " honoris causa." In the matter of dialect, Schroeder takes a middle course, since the Alexandrian authorities can neither be ignored nor blindly followed. But he prefers to be fairly consistent in rejecting the intrusion of Ionic -if-. Schroeder's text, in its most recent form, as before, is decidedly con- servative, the readings of the best MSS being restored in many places where they had been given up by all modern editors. But the reader must not, on account of these restorations, accuse the editor of undue conservatism of temperament. Closer examination soon reveals the fact that the restored readings had in most cases been given up on account of the metrical irregularities which they introduced. But it is well known