STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 457 probably the best in the dissertation: the parallels cited are close and definite. A good summary of the results of the dissertation is given on p. 59. Mr. Shear has shown the influence of Plato upon Basil to be consid- erable, though the extent of imitation is by no means so great as in some of the Church Fathers. This is to be accounted for by the fact that in his sermons Basil occupies himself chiefly with practical questions and in such works as that on the Holy Spirit there could be little occasion for Platonic influence. The works which exhibit the greatest amount of Platonic reminiscence are the Hexaemeron and the Xdyos irpos tovs vtovs on the subject of classical literature. The following points of detail may be noticed: On p. 8 the author is wrong in citing Tim. 34B as a parallel to Basil 4. 248D 6 and in supply- ing "tov avdpJnrov" in the former: it is the world, not man, that is here the subject of discussion. On p. 9 better parallels than Tim. 34C can be found for Basil 3. 565D 1 ; cf . Crito 47E. On p. 13 the two passages Basil 3. 344A 9 and Tim. 81E while somewhat similar are hardly close enough to be cited as parallels, phrase for phrase, as our author does. On p. 19, the idea in both Basil 3. 348C 3 and Phaedrus 240C is that similarity causes friendship, not association as our author says. On p. 27 there is absolutely no resemblance in thought between Tim. 32C and Basil 1. 33B 5. The idea of the passage from the Timaeus is that each element is used in its entirety in creation, the idea of Basil that God is creator of the whole universe, not merely of the forms but also of the matter. On pp. 26 and 27 in the discussion of Basil's doctrine of the elements, Mr. Shear makes Tim. 49C his source, saying that the passage of Basil 1. 89C might be viewed as a commentary on the Platonic pas- sage, giving a fuller explanation. Our author has evidently overlooked Aristotle De generatione et corruptione ii. 3, 4, where the same theory which Basil employs is developed in very similar language with the same details of treatment. The theory has nothing Platonic about it. It assumes that fi ;e passes into the other elements and they into fire, a thing which Plato in his completed theory, Tim. 54C, denies is possible. On p. 33, Tim. 76E seems to be a mistake for 80E. Roger Miller Jones The University of Chicago Priester und Tempel im hellenishschen Agypten: Ein Beitrag zur kulturgeschichte des Hellenismus. Von Walter Otto. Zweiter Band. Leipzig und Berlin: B. G. Teubner, 1908. This second volume of Otto's work on the ecclesiastical organization of Egypt in the Greek age maintains the reputation for carefulness and 458 Book Keviews exhaustive presentation already established by the author in his first volume. The rapidly increasing mass of materials available for such a study have of course necessitated a good many addenda and corrections, as might have been expected. The present volume contains four chap- ters, besides "Nachtrfige und Berichtigungen " and a Register of sixty- eight pages which renders the material easily and conveniently accessible. Having already treated the revenues of the temples in the first volume, Otto proceeds in his fifth chapter to the expenses of temple maintenance, in the sixth to the administration of the temple properties, and then takes up a more interesting subject in connection with these materials — the social position of the priests and the relation between state and church. Egypt is the first great nation of the early world in which we may discern a large and comprehensive sacerdotal organization, including all the metropolitan and provincial priesthoods. Such an organization existed as far back as the fifteenth century before Christ. It is the last chapter in the long story of this eccliastical body which is treated by Otto in his book. The mass of the materials now accessible in the papyrus collections of the great museums and libraries of Europe is enormous. It would be impossible in the space here at our disposal to undertake a detailed criticism of Otto's treatment of these materials. If we have any general criticism to make, it is that in the use of his data Otto has seemingly not endeavored to articulate the conditions which he finds in the Hellenistic age with those known to us in earlier Egypt. There is an effort to cite the literature dealing with the earlier periods, but it is strange not to find among this literature adduced, the great Papyrus Harris, which as far back as the twelfth century b. c. gives us a surprising amount of information regarding the economic status of the temples of that age. Evidently the latest results of a study of the Papyrus Harris have been overlooked. The evident cultural value of such a careful study as that of Otto in revealing to us the relations of a great ecclesiastical organization to the life of the time, is but another illustration of the revelations furnished by the papyrus literature now flowing so plentifully from the excavations along the Nile. They only emphasize, however, how little we know of the universal beliefs of folk-religion, which found no expression or per- petuation in literary form. It will probably always remain the case that we shall know only the religion of the scribes and the official temple ecclesiastics, while the beliefs of the people will always elude us. James Henry Breasted The University op Chicago