STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 485 syllable in the cadence and divides — [ - ~ ~ - | ~. It must be said, however, that Blass is not seeking for categories and elaborate classifications — possibly a hopeful sign for the next phase of these new rhythmical studies. Unlike Bornecque and Zielinski he has no pigeon- holes in which to file away countless phonographic records of once son- orous cadences. Unlike the followers of Norden he is not interested in deriving a numerous metrical progeny from the patriarchal loins of a single cretic. His aim is to discover the all-essential element of respon- sion — a principle which knows no limitation to set forms of cadence, no necessity of a fixed division into conventional feet. Not that he discards feet entirely, though the identification of precise feet seems to be of secondary importance. Another new feature is the treatment of a rhythm and its catalectic form as practically identical. Thus - ~ - | - w - and its catalectic form - - - | - - may make a rhyme, and it is needless to say that this device is of great service in noting correspondences. In general this is a more flexible theory of rhythm than most of the recent speculations have given us. It refuses to submit itself to the formidable "laws" of Bornecque or Zielinski. Compared with the saner methods of Norden, Blass will surely find favor with all who feel that, however wooden and mechanical rhythm may have become in later and feebler hands, it could not have been restricted by Cicero to a num- ber of forms so suspiciously limited. The remaining writers more briefly considered are the philosopher Seneca, Curtius, and Apuleius. Of these the author finds that Seneca's rhythm is like Cicero's in its essentials, but more conspicuous through repetition of two or three favorite forms ; that Curtius carries such monot- ony of cadence still further; that Apuleius for the first time combines the Roman clausulae, in less-restricted types, with Greek practice, as shown by initial correspondences, or in balanced rhythm of whole KlaXa. Thus to our great Atticist Apuleius appears to have the freest and most pleasing music of all Latin writers, for the very reason that he approaches most closely to the Greeks, with whom, even in the Asian school, rhythm was a thing of life, whereas with the Roman restriction to clausulae, and that in a diminishing range of types, rhythmic lost its very soul. Prank Gardner Moore Dartmouth College Oriechische Denominativa in ihrer geschichtlichen Entwicklung und Verbreitung. Von Ebnst Fbaenkel. Gottingen: Van- derbroeck & Ruprecht, 1906. Pp. vi + 296. M. 8. This is a welcome chapter in the history of Greek word -formation. It contains separate indices arranged in alphabetical order and with full citation of occurrences of the Greek denominatives in -aivuv, -vvav, -ovv, 486 Book Keviews and -eveiv. Derivative nouns, etc., are given in the indices in smaller type. In addition to the indices the author presents for each group a discussion of the facts and an indication of the dialectic distribution. In this dis- cussion he separates those words which have been regularly formed from those that are due to analogy, etc., and also subdivides the latter accord- ing to the stem from which derived. Under each group also he has a short treatment of the derivatives from the verbal denominatives. A short chapter is devoted to the derivatives in -/m. and -ens, and there is an excursus on the origin of the ending -vvuv and the presence in Greek of the reduced grade -un-. Many verbs in -aiveiv come from neuters in -pa (p. 4). A few are from -uen- or iion-stems (p. 5, cf. p. 30). The frequent parallelism of verbs in -euvtiv and -o£«v is explained (p. 13) as due to the fact that many Greek w-stems were originally wi-stems. We should expect (p. 30) verbs in -vvuv to come from stems with the reduced grade -un-, but no instance of this is known. In his excursus (pp. 285 ff.) the author admits as con- tributory factors in the origin of -vvuv the parallelism of primary verbs like Sveiv: Sweiv, and the analogy of -av: -cuvuv, but suggests the possi- bility of the existence of the reduced grade -un- in such stems as -vy£, -vyyos (cf. -iy£, -lyyos). About half the verbs in -vvuv are from tt-stems. The frequency of verbs in -vvuv from neuters in -os is rightly based in part on the close connection between neuters in -os and adjectives in -vs. Cf. Fick B. B. I, pp. 245 ff., Aufrecht K. Z. XXXIX, p. 458. and Etym. Mag. 210, 213, 233, 396, 535. For fwXvvuv (p. 38) cf. Herodian i. 236 and ii. 838. 17, where a form /xoXv; with short final is cited. Verbs in -ovv are mainly factitive or instrumentative (p. 71). An extension of the instrumentative use is that of the separative (pp. 79 ff.). The author rejects the current view that verbs in -ovv owe their origin to adjectives in -wros (pp. 104 ff.), and seeks to show that they are due rather to the analogy of aorists in -aoxu, etc. (p. 172). He does not attempt to set up a theory for verbs in -eveiv except to say that the present formation in -evuv is secondary and due to the influence of other tenses. Clearly the last word about nouns in -evs has not yet been spoken. He divides the verbs in -evuv into those expressing "quality relationship" as apx^vuv, and those expressing "action relationship" as ro^eiuv. Causatives in -evuv are treated pp. 200 ff. There is little adverse criticism to be offered. A few cross references would have been helpful at times, e. g., pp. 5 ond 30 on stems in -uen- etc; and there seems no sufficient reason why the index to verbs in -eveiv should not follow the treatment of that ending instead of being inserted after the chapter on -/m and -o-is- But on the whole the book is well arranged and represents an enormous amount of work well done. Wm. C. Gunnerson Yeatman High School St. Louis