STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 481 A new criterion for distinguishing betwen Hesychian and Athenaean lists of titles is found in the formulae by which they are introduced: Spd/MiTa avTov is always the mark of the epitome of Hesychius, tSv Spa/juxTiav avTov itrriv of the interpolator of Suidas who drew upon Athe- naeus. It is made reasonably clear also that neither Hesychius nor Suidas themselves made use of Athenaeus in writing the lives of the comic poets. The last chapter proves that the tragic poet Timocles is not to be identified with the comic poet of the same name and period. The two lemmata in Suidas are both of Hesychian origin, though the second, Ti/xokX^s erepos, xai avTos KoifUKo^, has been corrupted, first by the substitu- tion of KtofUKo^ for TpayiKos, and then by the addition of koX ovtos. Lives which contain erepos are generally right in distinguishing homonymns. The lemmata originally were T. 'A^. Koifx.. and T. htpo^ rpayiKo^. Finally Wagner shows clearly that the Ikarioi of Timocles was not a satyr-drama, as Wilamowitz maintained, but a comedy, Sarvpoi being a part of the title. Few errors of statement have been noted. The source of confusion in Suidas on the Astydamantes (p. 58) was pointed out by the reviewer Am. Jour. Phil. XXI (1900), p. 44; the Hiereia was assigned to Apollo- dorus Gelous ibid., p. 50, and Apollodorus proved to be distinct from A. Gelous ibid., pp. 45 £f . It may be added that Krause, to whom credit is given for these observations, produced very little that was original in his dissertation (cf . Jacoby Woch. Mass. Phil. 1903, 1089). The author's belief in the wide first-hand acquaintance of Athenaeus with Greek com- edies would be shaken by reading Hendrickson Am. Jour. Phil. XXVII (1906), p. 197 : the assertion of Athenaeus himself 336 d is in conformity with the technique of citation in the learned dialogue. Edward Capps Sur les attrihuts des Saliens. Par M. W. Helbig. Extrait des M6moires de I'Acad^mie des Inscriptions et Belles-lettres XXXVII, pp. 205-76 (1-72). Paris: Klienksieck, 1905. Fr. 3.20. More than thirty years ago Helbig pointed out the resemblance between certain small breastplates of sheet bronze found in Italian graves of the pre-Hellenic period and the breastplates worn by the Salii. In the present article he takes up the whole question of the equipmer^t of these ancient colleges, and endeavors to prove that it was identical with that of the Koman patrician warrior down to the seventh century B. 0., and further that it was essentially similar to that of the Mycenaean age. The evidence clearly shows that the two colleges of the Salii ante- 482 Book Eeviews date the <7wotKto-/ios of the Palatine and Quirinal settlements, and makes it very probable that in historic times, with the conservatism inherent in religious customs, they still used the dress and arms of the prehistoric period. We know from good sources that the Salian dress was distinctly that of a warrior. The innermost garment was a tunica picta bound by a metal girdle (/xiVpa); over this was worn a trabea, bordered and striped with purple; the defensive armor was a metal pectoral, apex, and ancile; the offensive arms, a sword and sacred spear. With regard to the ancilia, Helbig points out that literary and monumental evidence shows that they preserved the shape of the long " Mediterranean " shield with the sides cut away, such as was frequently carried by the Mycenaean war- riors as well as by Peiiphetes and Hector in the Iliad. It seems equally clear that this was also the Italian shield well into the last millennium B. 0. The apex likewise exhibits striking analogies to defensive head- coverings shown on Mycenaean remains. The breastplate, an oblong sheet of metal, attached to a leather or cloth doublet, was intended to protect the central portion of the breast only; this continued apparently to be worn by the legionaries even in the second century b. c, according to Polybius. Tombs dating from the seventh and sixth centuries b. c. have yielded four such pectorals, which Helbig is undoubtedly right in identifying with Livy's aeneiim pectoris tegumen. The warrior's jurpa Helbig illustrates by numerous metal girdles found in early Italian tombs; but, unfortunately for the argument, many of these tombs seem to have been the burial-places of women, although this cannot be estab- lished for all; none can be proved to be a warrior's grave. Helbig, how- ever, strengthens his case by citing two early bronze statuettes, one of which is certainly that of a warrior, on which /xtVpat are clearly shown. This Italian cincture closely corresponds to the Homeric /xiTprj, ^coo-T?;p. Space does not allow us to touch on Helbig's arguments by which he seeks to show that the other articles of the Salian equipment reflect Mycenaean culture. One interesting suggestion, however, must be men- tioned. On the basis of arguments which are certainly persuasive, if not in every detail convincing, Helbig maintains that in the early period the Italian kings and nobles employed war chariots similar to those shown on the familiar Mycenaean stelae and described in the Homeric poems; in three terra-cotta chariots (reproduced pp. 69, 70) found in graves he sees small models of such cars. As he suggests pp. 60 f ., it is highly desirable that the remains of weapons from early graves should be sys- tematically studied for the light they may throw on this and many other questions of early Italian warfare. Cliffoed Hekschel Mooee Harvard Univeksity