STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 479 Symbolarum ad comicorum Graecorum historiam criticam capita quattuor. Scripsit Eeinh. Joh. Theodoeus Wagnek. Leip- zig: privately printed, 1905. Pp. 71. Diphilus was a contemporary of Menander (Anon. w. Kwp. ii Kaib.) ; his first city victory followed close upon that of Menander (cf. the order of names ibid.: Menander, Diphilus, Philippides); his first Lenaean vic- tory is to be dated about seven years after that of Menander (IG. II 977 g : Menander, Philemon, Apollodorus, Diphilus). He was still active, as Kaibel has shown, in 288, the year of Philemon's Phasma (Plaut. Mostel. 1149). With these facts to begin with Wagner attempts in his first chap- ter to define more closely the chronology of the life of Diphilus, especially the date of his birth. The poet's liaison with Gnathaena gives the prin- cipal clue, which Wagner follows up with subtle and, for the most part, convincing reasoning. Plays in which this woman is mentioned along with Pythonice, who followed Harpalus to Babylon in 330, must be anterior to that date, and among these plays the Orestautocleides of Timocles must be placed as near as possible to 345, when the hero was already notorious (Aesch. Tim. i. 52) for the vice for which the harlot- furies of Timocles are about to wreak vengeance upon him. Wagner thinks that this play must be dated as late as 335-330, however, in order that Diphilus may not be too much younger than his mistress, and the mistress not too old, at the time of their amour. Properly assuming that Gnathaena was not less than sixteen in the year of the Orestautocleides, he assumes further that Diphilus was only 55-60 in the year of the Phasma and was therefore born a few years before 310. But there is no indication of age whatever in the context of Mostel. 1149, and the date of the Orestautocleides should manifestly be kept as near as possible to the oration against Timarchus. Further, it is inherently probable that Diphilus did not begin his dramatic career at so early an age as Menan- der, who, as Clark has recently shown (Class. Phil. I, pp. 313 ff.), brought out his first play under Anticles in 325/4, at the age of eighteen. These considerations make it more reasonable to conclude that Diphilus was 60-65 in 288, was born ca. 348-353, and that the Orestautocleides was produced ca. 340. Gnathaena would thus have been at least 36 and Diphilus 28-33 in 320, at about which time the intimacy may have been established. And even this calculation is conservative, for it must be admitted, with KOrte (Berl. phil. Woch. 1906, 900 ff.), that Diphilus may have been born a few years earlier still. His first play was very likely brought out before Menander's first. 1 Korte, in the valuable review just cited, has shown how the error in 1 That the Orge was not Menander's first play, but the play with which he was first victorious at the Dionysia, as Wagner also thinks, seems to me more probable than ever. The allusion in it to Ctesippus would be more appropriate to 315 than to 324. 480 Book Reviews Wagner's reasoning runs through his second chapter, in which he attempts to date other plays by reference to other hetaerae. Attention may be called here to one item of especial interest. Wagner dates ca. 342 Philemon's Lithoglyphus, a new fragment of which has come to light in the commentary of Didymus to Demosthenes. This is by far the earliest date ever assigned to a play by Philemon, but that it is essen- tially correct (though 340 would be safer) can hardly be doubted. Con- firmation for almost as early a date may be derived from Philemon's gibe at Astydamas the younger, o-avTr/v eiraivew, aWep 'AorvSayuas, yvvcu. The allusion to the boastful epigram composed by the poet himself for the statue to be erected to him for his victory with the Parthenopaeus, brought out in 340 (IG. II 973), must have been made soon after 340 (Am. Jour. Phil. XXI, p. 44). Wagner's most valuable contribution is contained in his third chapter, " De poetarum comicorum apud Suidam biographicis." In approaching the complex and difficult problem as to the nature, authorship, and authority of these biographical notices, he first divides the 108 notices into four classes : In Class I, lives that are of Hesychian origin (64, of which 8 contain additions derived from Athenaeus), and Class II, frag- ments of genuine Hesychian lives (6), sometimes reduced by the epitomi- zer to bare lemmata like 'A/mi/oas 'A$rjvatos koi/ukos, the Hesychian origin is indicated by the presence of one or more of the seven elements peculiar to the Hesychian life; Class III, lives which contain lists of plays derived from Athenaeus (34), and Class IV, other glosses (4), present the greatest difficulties, and here the author's accurate observation and close reasoning lead him to new and important results. It has long been known that the lists of titles that are in alphabetical order go back to Hesychius, while most of the other lists are derived from Athenaeus, the order being that in which the plays chance to be cited by that author. Wagner proves that the majority (26) of the lemmata of these notices are drawn from the epitome of Hesychius and not from Athenaeus, e. g., Aajuofcvos 'AOrjvatos KwfUKos, because of the ethnicon, AtoSwpos kw. avrbv eis A' tc'Xos tov yi, apxfj tov St'. Book Reviews 481 A new criterion for distinguishing betwen Hesychian and Athenaean lists of titles is found in the formulae by which they are introduced: Spd/MiTa avrov is always the mark of the epitome of Hesychius, tu>v Spa/juxTwv avrov io-nv of the interpolator of Suidas who drew upon Athe- naeus. It is made reasonably clear also that neither Hesychius nor Suidas themselves made use of Athenaeus in writing the lives of the comic poets. The last chapter proves that the tragic poet Timocles is not to be identified with the comic poet of the same name and period. The two lemmata in Suidas are both of Hesychian origin, though the second, Ti,u.okA->?s erepos, xa.1 airos k