STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 477 Aristophane ei les partis d AtMnes. Par Maueice Croiset. Paris: Fontemoing, 1906. Pp. xi + 311. F. 3.50. Auguste Couat in his brilliant study, Aristophane et I'ancienne com6die attique (3. 6d. 1902), maintains that not only Aristophanes, but the whole body of poets of the Old Comedy, were clients of an oligarchi- cal faction at Athens, and that their plays, instead of being an independ- ent criticism of contemporary life and politics, were merely a vehicle for exploiting partisan views and a means of eflPecting partisan ends. It is singular that C!ouat's keen appreciation of the elusive quality of Aris- tophanes' genius (cf . pp. 386 ff.) did not lead him to distrust so extreme a conclusion. M. Croiset, who had already expressed his dissent from Couat's views in the Histoire de la littirature grecque (Vol. Ill, p. 460), here brings together the results of his own investigation of this important question. The passage of time has only strengthened his earlier impres- sion, and he finds little to retract. One feels, perhaps, that he is dis- posed to take the poet a little more seriously than he did in the earlier work — but his seriousness is never the seriousness of Kock. The introduction contains a brief survey of the origins of comedy, the facts of Aristophanes' early life, and a summary of the political situation at the time of his d6but as a comic poet. The rest of the volume is devoted to an analysis of the extant plays and fragments. M. Croiset examines the circumstances under which each play was produced; the poet's purpose in writing it, so far as it can be determined, and his gen- eral attitude toward men and things, as shown in remarks by the way. He compares the poet's attitude as it appears from this analysis with the traditional attitude of the oligarchical party, of whose views he believes Respuhlica Atheniensium, [Xen.] to be a typical expression; and he shows beyond question that, whatever temporary alliances Aristophanes may have made, he was nullius addictus iurare in verba niagistri, and that, however clearly he may have recognized the besetting sins of the Athe- nian democracy, he is nowhere at enmity with the democratic principle. The author's treatment of disputed questions is in such admirable temper that one hesitates to take issue with him in matters of detail. Yet I can hardly agree with him in regarding comedy as the mouthpiece merely of the rural population (p. 11) any more than with Couat, that it was the "porte- parole" of the oligarchs. The humor of Aristophanes refuses to don a party emblem. Indeed, M. Croiset himself notes that in the Acharnians the rustics are exploited for the amusement of the city- folk (p. 88). If it is true that the countryman at the festival loved to see his city-brethren caricatured, it is none the less true that one's enjoyment of a caricature is in exact proportion to his acquaintance with the subject of it; and nobody enjoyed more than the city- folk seeing their neighbors in the pillory, even if few had the urbanity of Socrates, who could see the 478 Book Keviews fun in jokes at his own expense. The Old Comedy, hke its modem descendant, political caricature, busied itself with men and issues in the public eye. And these were naturally city-men and city-customs. Still less convincing is M. Croiset's suggestion that Aristophanes was a country boy (pp. 14 ff .). The poet's minute knowledge of country ways and country things, his vivid and sympathetic presentation of country life, are by no means necessarily the outgrowth of personal experience. It is that very apprehension and realization of feelings and situations beyond the range of personal experience that distinguishes the supreme artist, and is so large an element in the quality we call inspiration. On the vexed question of Aristophanes' citizenship M. Croiset does not speak with assurance (pp. 14 ff.). He rightly concludes that the poet actually enjoyed the privileges of citizenship (pp. 14, 148), both at his d6but and thereafter, but the specter of Cleon's supposed ypa^^ $eviai seems to trouble him ; and the compromise between Cleon and the poet (by which the ypatfyrj was never brought to trial) which he is led to assume on the evidence of Vespae 1284-91 (pp. 145 ff.) seems to him to argue a weakness in Aristophanes' claims. The argument is ingenious — and yet the whole story of the ypa4>r] ^evtas rests on too slender evidence to be taken quite so seriously. The passage in the Vespae, as Starkie remarks, implies rather a brawl — what Professor Gildersleeve calls a "back-yard quarrel" — than a formal lawsuit; and if we are placing dependence on the scholia, we are confronted not only by the confusion which M. Croiset notes of the ypa^rj fevtas with the indictment before the Council, but by three alleged suits, all brought to trial, and all, as we are told, resulting in the poet's vindication ( Vita Diibner xi ; cf . xii). Those charges of base origin which the comic poets flung back and forth have never been better appraised than Browning, who knew his scholia, appraises them in his Aristophanes' Apology. M. Croiset deserves our gratitude for laying to rest the theory that the most Attic of poets passed his life at Athens as an alien, especially since Van Leeuwen, of whom one expects better things, has seen fit to resurrect the charge in his recent edition of the Vespae. But we can hardly hope to write the history of the poet's quarrel with Cleon on the basis of the extant scholia. The analyses of the individual plays every student of Aristophanes will wish to work through for himself. M. Croiset never forgets that he is writing of a poet and a comic poet, and in his hands nothing is hackneyed. For this reason it is the more to be regretted that the book lacks an index. Couat in the preface to his Aristophane et Vancienne com^die remarks that it is always in order for one to voice his opinions about great writers, "pourvu qu'il le fasse avec sinc6rit6 et avec quelque com- petence." There will always be room for so discriminating and sugges- tive a volume as M. Croiset's. Abthue Alexis Bryant Cambridge, Mass.