STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 380 Book Reviews reliefs are to be considered as Roman, and not as due primarily to the Alexandrian art of the Hellenistic age. In another paper dealing with Roman reliefs, Mr. H. Stuart-Jones, formerly the director of the School, gives a "Historical Interpretation of the Reliefs of Trajan's Column," and reaches conclusions differing more or less from those that have been brought forward by Cichorius and Petersen, and especially by von Domaszewski and Weber, whose views he regards as mark- ing a distinct retrogression. It is not possible here to give even an outline of the author's conclusions, but the reader's attention may be called in par- ticular to the itinerary of Trajan's march from the Adriatic to the Black Sea in his second campaign. On the whole it seems to the reviewer that the evidence of these reliefs, even with the help derived from literary sources, is too meager to justify any certainty in many of the details. Mr. C. L. Woolley writes on an ancient site called La Civita, in the valley of the Sabato near Serino, and effectually disposes of the conjectures of Cluver that it might have been the site of the chief town of the Sabatini, and of Orilia that it was that of the capital of the Picentini, by showing that the remains of fortifications are of late date, probably belonging to the early centuries of our era, and perhaps connected with the invasion of Alaric. The shortest paper in this volume consists of a series of drawings and colored plates by Mr. F. G. Newton, a member of the School, and the accom- panying text by Dr. Ashby, illustrating the interesting columbarium of Hylas on the Via Latina. There is one paper that deals exclusively with a philological subject, the text of the Odyssey, by Mr. T. W. Allen, of Oxford, in which the author lists and describes all the known MSS of the Odyssey; divides them into seventeen families, with the exception of six which resist classification; assigns to these families their relative importance; and gives those variants from the papyri that seem deserving of notice. He also discusses the omissions of lines and the extent to which Alexandrian readings have made their way into our MSS, and finally the origin of variants in general, and of Alexandrian variants in particular. The reviewer is not competent to pronounce judgment upon Mr. Allen's conclusions but he may venture to express some doubt as to the validity of "the purely arithmetical system" which is definitely adopted (p. 17) as "the only one by which families of MSS can be made out." This volume is fully up to the high standard of excellence and value that was set by its predecessors. S. B. P. Select Letters of Seneca. Edited, with Introductions and Explana- tory Notes, by Walter C. Summers, M.A. New York: Macmillan, 1911. Pp. cxiv+383. This edition appears very opportunely. We have long needed such a book, both for general literary purposes and for a medium in which the Book Reviews 381 essentials of Seneca's literary moralia may be presented to college men. Macaulay, Landor, and others, when the nineteenth century was young and lusty, gave Seneca such a fillip that he disappeared below the literary hori- zon, in spite of Sainte-Beuve's and Matthew Arnold's commendations; but now that we are renewing our interest in the subjects that Seneca represents, he will come to his own again. A glance at such recent publications as R. Waltz's Vie de Seneque, R. Pichon's "Philosophe ministre sous l'empire Romain" (Revue des deux Mondes, September 15, 1910), A. P. Ball's Essays of Seneca, and the work of Mr. Summers makes for the truth of this statement. The drama has acknowledged the tragedian's influence; we need just now a full account of our debt to the philosopher. The preface shows that this idea is fully present to Mr. Summers; for the third section contains an interesting essay on "Seneca's Prose: Its Critics and Its Debtors." In spite of the fact that no attention is paid to Thomas a Kempis, who undoubtedly reflects Seneca both in admiration and in disapproval (see, for example, De Imitatione Christi, Book I, chap, ii, sec. 1; and Bigg The Imitation 34), and to the newly discovered Centuries of Meditations, by Thomas Trahearne, in spite of this, the fact that there are so few important omissions proves a wide range of reading and culture. We doubt the truth of the statement in this section about the scarcity of Seneca tradition in seventeenth-century England, after finding in John Dennis' Impartial Critic, Dialogue 2 (see Spingarn Critical Essays of the Seventeenth Century iii, 167) such words as these: "Have you forgot since you grew drunk in Hampshire in extolling the dogmas of Seneca? When the company laughed to see the speculative Stoic a practical Epicurean!" This would seem to imply familiarity with the works of the author, if not close study of him. The first section of the introduction, "The Pointed Style in Greek and Roman Literature," rather sends philosophy to the wall in favor of rhetoric. Most of this can be found in Norden's Antike Kunstprosa, as the editor himself remarks. We confess a curiosity to know more en bloc about Roman moralia — for Seneca is primarily a moralist — and such subjects as present themselves so richly in Gellius (see N.A. 9, 8; 12, 5, etc.). Besides, Mr. Summers does not sufficiently emphasize the paradox of Pronto, Atticist as he was, who is just as full of stylistic vagaries as the author whom he criticizes so severely. Section B, on Seneca's style and language, is masterly. The notes are illuminating; although that on Ep. 87, sec. 10, tolu- tariis, hardly squares with the tolutares of Fronto (ad Ant. de Orat. 1), as interpreted on p. 97 of the introduction. And it would be useful to see more made of the authors discussed in Section C, as Petrarch, whose De remediis is adminiculated by Seneca's Letters, Erasmus, Montaigne, and Burton. As far as the selection of letters is concerned, we should have appreciated the inclusion of 2, On Concentration in Reading; 30, an attractive mono- 382 Book Reviews graph on the heroism of Bassus; 41, the almost Christian sacer spiritus; 100, on Fabianus, Seneca's master; 104, Ill-Health, Independence, and Philosophy — somewhat autobiographical, and 115, On Over-Care of Style. Many of the conjectural readings are bold, but they have the merit of at least being reasonable. The volume is well written, and a pleasure to read. Mr. Summers deserves our hearty thanks for the words on p. 9 of his preface: that Seneca's teachings are honorable and valuable, and "the clearness of his style com- pares favorably with that of some philosophers of more recognized stand- ing." If it is still the fashion to ridicule Seneca, that fashion ought to change. R. M. Gummeeb Havebpobd College February 25, 1911 To ©e/xto-To'/cXeioz/. By IAK. X. APAFAT2H2. Athens: 'Pa(f>Tdvi)pyio<;, 1910. Pp. 39. Ap. 2. Among the ancients the most desired boon at the end was to pass away surrounded by one's kith and kin and to find a tomb in one's native land. To Athens' greatest admiral, dying the death of an exiled traitor, this boon was, in part at least, denied. He died and was buried in Magnesia, and yet his tomb was pointed out in Attica. Analyzing the testimony of Thucydides, Plutarch, Diodorus Siculus, Nepos, Pausanias, Aristotle, and Plato Comicus, we are led to the following simple conclusions: (1) Themistocles died and was buried in Magnesia; (2) his bones were later removed to Attica, either (a) by his kinsmen without the knowledge of the Athenians, or (6) with the approval of the people, who repented toward their great commander; (3) they were buried near the entrance to the Piraeus harbor; (4) there his grave was pointed out in after-times; and (5) grave and environment bore the name Themistocleum. Where was this tomb of Themistocles ? Following Diodorus the Perie- gete (ap. Plut. Them. 32: Tltpl rbv fJLeyav \i/xera. tov Ileipaiais cwro tov Kara tov *A\ki/jx>v aKpor-qpiov irpoKeirai ns oiov dyK