STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 361 Nee Graecae neque ullius linguae proprium est articulum addere vocativo!" Then he proceeded to mutilate the passage. The book is almost entirely free from misprints — a fact to be wondered at when the vast number of fine-print examples is considered. It may be noted that in this second part substantive o ft.hr, o 8c, etc., have the accent and that o-o>£a> (no iota) and Tpot£i/vtos occur. There is a good Table of Contents. No index can be expected, pre- sumably, until the entire work is complete. The printed pages are uniform with those of Part I, but unfortunately the margins are so much broader that the bound volume' is nearly an inch longer and broader than its predecessor. Moreover, the paper is glazed to such a degree that it is annoying to read the book by artificial light on account of the reflection, and, no doubt because of this glazing, the type in the fine-print examples failed to make a clear impression in very many instances, thus producing the effect of much worn type. It is to be hoped that the faults named will be removed before any more copies are printed. Milton W. Humphreys Varia Socratica. First Series. By A. E. Taylor, St. Andrews University Publications, No. IX. Oxford: Parker, 1911. Professor Taylor, author of an excellent little book on Plato in the series of "Philosophies Ancient and Modern," makes these studies as a part of his preparation for a larger work on the philosophy of Plato on which he is engaged. The central aim that unifies the volume is the attempt to prove that much more of Platonism than is commonly supposed is Socratic, or may be traced back even to the Pythagoreans and other pre-Socratics. One may concede the a-priori historical probability of this thesis and yet distrust it as a working hypothesis either for the philological study or the philosophical interpretation of Plato. In the one case, it will mislead because the evidence needed to verify it is lacking. In the other, it is a dangerous guide because the assumptions of modern scholarship make us more likely to miss the incalculable superiority of Plato to his contemporaries and predecessors than we are to overlook parallels and anticipatory sug- gestions in pre-Platonic literature. In the lack of space to apply these principles to the detail of Professor Taylor's book, I can only give a sum- mary of its content and indicate a few reserves. The first essay on "The Impiety of Socrates" argues that the impiety meant in the indictment was Pythagoreanism — the Socrates of the Gorgias and Phaedo "frequented a foreign conventicle." The conclusion is reached by elimination. The accusation of impiety was not brought merely as a foundation for the charge of corrupting the young. Professor Taylor thinks that the testimony of Isocrates' Antidosis shows that "it would have 362 Book Reviews been quite feasible to lay a capital ypar) do-e/Jeuxs on the latter ground alone." It cannot have been atheism or the Sai/toViov, for both Plato and Xenophon show that that was absurd, and Anytus was no fool. The un- popularity of Pythagoreanism is proved from comedy and from the speech in the Hippolytus of that typical Athenian "John Bull," Theseus. It was heresy and it was anti-democratic. I do not propose to contend that the historical Socrates may not have associated with the Pythagoreans, who are represented as holding discourse with him in the Phaedo, or that this fact may not have helped to prejudice the jury that condemned him. By all prevailing canons of philological method, Professor Taylor has done a service in collecting everything that could be said for this view and developing all the consequences of his hypothesis. Yet I cannot help regretting to see so excellent and, to judge by his previous work, so sober a Platonist entering upon this path. It leads him to find the famous o-fyia — tnj/ua doctrine of the world and the crowning proof of Euripides' impiety in Aristophanes' <£a<7Kovcras oi tp\v to tfiv. It beguiles him into interpretations of Aeschy- lus which I should rather expect to find in the writings of Mr. Verrall or Miss Jane Harrison or Mr. Lawson or Mr. Cornford. I also note with regret that he apparently accepts the letters as genuine, dating the Republic by them, before the first Sicilian journey, and that in spite of my protest, now twenty years old, he speaks of "the avra ko.6' avra etSr/" without an accom- panying participle or infinitive — a slight, but symptomatic, touch (see APJ IX, 287). In his second paper, he is, I think, successful in breaking down the alleged distinction in Aristotle between SwKpar^s (the historical Socrates) and 6 SoiKpanjs (the Socrates of the dialogues). He is correct, too, I think, in maintaining that Aristotle's knowledge of Socrates is almost wholly derived from the extant dialogues. But I regret that in his zeal to confute Aristotle he thinks it necessary to condemn the famous statement that one of the two things which we owe to Socrates is inductive discourses i-rraKTiKol Xoyoi. It is perfectly true, as Macaulay says in his essay on Bacon, that the plain man practices induction by the light of Nature, and, as Professor Taylor shows, that the beginnings of the terminology of induction are to be found in the writings of "Hippocrates." But we pay too high a price for these truisms if they lead us to argue away the fact that there is something distinc- tive and epoch-making in the Socratic method of induction practiced in the minor Platonic dialogues, whether it be due to Socrates or to Plato. Chap, iii, the Sio-o-ol Aoyeu is a study of the Aia\t£eis undertaken mainly for the purpose of showing that the eristic type of Sophist sometimes supposed to be characteristic of the later Platonic dialogues goes back to the fifth century. The essay on the Phrontisterion attributes to the his- torical (and Pythagorean) Socrates the main contents of the Clouds and the Phaedo. Despite Xenophon, Socrates was a student of natural philosophy. The burning of the Phrontisterion is an allusion to the burning of the Pytha- Book Reviews 363 gorean owe'Spia, a suggestion not original with Professor Taylor, as he himself observes in a postscript. The valuable concluding study on the words «Sos and I8ta in pre- Platonic literature rests on a complete collection, we are told, of every occurrence of the words down to Aristotle. Here again the object is to show that the philosophic use of these words was familiar not only to Socrates but to Pythagoras and the pre-Socratics. In Timaeus 51C: % pAr-qv tKOXTTOTt uvai tl tpapev cTSos Ikoxttov vorfrov, to 8'ovoev ap' rjv ttXtjv Xoyos; Professor Taylor thinks that Socrates' use of ap.tv includes the Pythagoreans of Magna Graecia among the "we" to whom Plato at- tributes the doctrine. This is to press u v ovtoiv iSeas -rrpocrrjyopevcrav, Pro- fessor Taylor interprets not as a distinction between Socrates and the Platonists, but between the Socrates of the Platonic dialogues and the eiSSv v ptow in its entire context to be a reference either to the Eleatics or to the repre- sentatives of some extreme form of the doctrine of ideas rejected by Plato. The words plainly refer to ot wpwTot i-as iSaxs ^a-avres elvai. They mean simply that x«(TO here, but that they are virtual synonyms in Isocrates as they often are in Plato. p AUL Shorey Jacques de Tourreil, Traducteur de Dhnosthene. These de doctorat presentee a la faculte des lettres de l'universtie de Lyon. Par Georges Duhain. Paris: Champion, 1910. Fr. 6. This excellent dissertation is an example of a type which I could wish were more frequently represented in our own universities. A minor chapter of the history of the national literature and the national tradition of classical scholarship, thoroughly and intelligently studied, is a far more profitable piece of work than are half of the desperate attempts to prove something which isn't so which go by the name of "investigations." But who is Jacques de Tourreil ? And why should anybody turn aside at this date to make a study of him? Jacques de Tourreil was a minor literary celebrity and academician of the latter half of the age of Louis XIV