STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 358 Book Reviews priests. The Roman senators in the first century B.C., through acquiring by gift or purchase vast estates in Asia Minor, threatened to feudalize this region once more, but the confiscatory policy of the Claudian emperors checked this tendency, and from the time of Vespasian to Hadrian the attempt was made here, as in Africa, to create on the public domains a class of Xaoi whose first loyalty would be given to their feudal lord— the emperor himself. A whole series of general enactments was issued (e.g., the lex Manciana and the hx Hadriana de agris rudibus in Africa) to effect this purpose, the net result being, however, to substitute, in the third century a.d. and thereafter, for a senator of the old style an imperial official as feudal lord between the Aaot and the emperor. Rostowzew's Studien zur Geschichte des romischen Kolonates is one of the most illuminating works on ancient history which has appeared in recent years. It is bound to be fundamental for all future studies on the economic history of Hellenistic and Roman times. The Archiv fur Papyrusforschung is to be congratulated on the character, if not on the style, of its first Beiheft. William Scott Ferguson Syntax of Classical Greek from Homer to Demosthenes. Second Part, "The Syntax of the Simple Sentence Continued, Embracing the Doctrine of the Article." By Basil Lannau Gildersleeve with the co-operation of Chables William Emil Miller. — The Doctrine of the Article Elaborated, by Professor Miller. — New York: American Book Co., 1911. In reviewing this volume it is assumed that the reader is familiar with the first part and the remarks made in the preface of that volume concern- ing the arrangement adopted which the author himself hints may not be the best; "but to refashion the book," says he, "would require more time than the speeding years will allow me to presume on." From the preface of this second part we learn that Professor Miller, who aided also in the preparation of Part I, rendered still greater service. Then we read: "The disparate- ness of the two parts was inevitable under the circumstances, and the delay occasioned by the co-operation has been so great that it has seemed best at this point to dissolve the partnership, maintained for so many years, as it would have been dissolved at any rate in the natural course of things. An outline of what remains is in progress, and though it is high time that I cut down long hope to match the brief space of human life, I do not hesi- tate to commit myself to a plan that involves little more than the shaping of material already in hand." To review a work of Gildersleeve, a scholar whose utterance is law, can be little more than simply to state its contents. The first part (which appeared ten years ago) is devoted to the simple sentence. The second Book Reviews 359 part takes up the simple sentence expanded by multiplication and qualifi- cation of both the subject and the predicate. In this volume the multi- plication and qualification only of the subject are treated, with some unavoidable incursions into the territory of the predicate. The multipli- cation of the subject covers eight pages. Then the qualification is taken up and the qualifying attributes are classified into the adjective (including the participle) and its equivalents, and apposition. First are treated the equivalents of the adjective (except relative clauses and pronouns including the article), sixteen pages. Next peculiar forms of the adjective attribute are taken up with the statement: "The demonstrative and other adjective pronouns present important peculiarities. Of these pronouns the most common is the article," and the rest of the book is devoted to the article, one hundred and sixteen pages. In this last subdivision the difficulties attending the arrangement and classification of topics become manifest; for of course it is desirable to discuss the article exhaustively in one con- tinuous treatment, and to do this it is necessary to treat the article in the predicate as well as in the subject, which the author very properly does not hesitate to do. Throughout the work the treatment of each special topic is as follows: first a concise statement of the facts; then a few selected illustrations, in heavy-faced type and translated; finally numerous examples (in small type) running from the Attic orators back to Homer's Iliad. The order usually adopted begins: Dinarchus, Lycurgus, Hyperides, Demosthenes, etc. One cannot, however, quarrel with the author for not calling his work "a Syntax of Classical Greek from Homer to Dinarchus." In rare instances and for special reasons examples are translated, and occasionally a remark is made on an example. A larger number of such remarks would have been most welcome to Greek scholars, but no doubt the size of the book had to be considered. Two or three illustrations of the result of conciseness will here be stated. On the "singular predicate agreeing with nearest or most important subject" (473) are quoted as many as six examples in which the plural verb, if left where the singular verb stands, would lead to the o-^/Mt ' AXk/mvlkov, and some of these are in prose, as 6 8e Ai7/xoo-0ei/rjs Sera-i^ous e^topa *"* to SXX.0 o-Tpdrtv/ja. Here a remark that ixrj, "Eparoo-0ivr)<: ... 6 ravra TrpaTTwv .... have been omitted from the following list." Now this list contains 6 KT^(nn-7ros rjv 6 ravra einw. Hence it is evident that the above statement is intended only for clauses in which the other member of the identification is anarthrous. Even then possibly it would be safer to say "may be regarded" instead of "is to be regarded," since in such cases the participle requires the article; for &m .... trparTum would have been almost unintelligible in the classic age and could only have meant Trparru as in Hellenistic rjv o\Sa.o-Kv, equivalent to iStSaa-Kev. We need here also to discriminate between the adjective and the participle, as the latter after the copula elvai must have the article. Twenty examples, ranging from Demosthenes to Herodotus, are cited illustrating the article with a participle as predicate after etvai. Even 6 airos as predicate is cited eight times. In one of these examples the subject (consisting of a pair of words) is anarthrous, A.eyos dSeA<£ds. These, however, are unimportant matters, and we must welcome this work as giving the most accurate and complete treatment of the article in Greek that has ever been published. Only one or two minor topics escaped the notice of the reviewer, if they are discussed: one is the loose order, 6 vios rov %v 6 ev Tots ovpavois /ore, and <3 yepata. p.rjrtp r) Hepfou v fccvatv. Book Reviews 361 Nee Graecae neque ullius linguae proprium est articulum addere vocativo!" Then he proceeded to mutilate the passage. The book is almost entirely free from misprints — a fact to be wondered at when the vast number of fine-print examples is considered. It may be noted that in this second part substantive o ft.hr, o 8c, etc., have the accent and that o-o>£a> (no iota) and Tpot£i/vtos occur. There is a good Table of Contents. No index can be expected, pre- sumably, until the entire work is complete. The printed pages are uniform with those of Part I, but unfortunately the margins are so much broader that the bound volume' is nearly an inch longer and broader than its predecessor. Moreover, the paper is glazed to such a degree that it is annoying to read the book by artificial light on account of the reflection, and, no doubt because of this glazing, the type in the fine-print examples failed to make a clear impression in very many instances, thus producing the effect of much worn type. It is to be hoped that the faults named will be removed before any more copies are printed. Milton W. Humphreys Varia Socratica. First Series. By A. E. Taylor, St. Andrews University Publications, No. IX. Oxford: Parker, 1911. Professor Taylor, author of an excellent little book on Plato in the series of "Philosophies Ancient and Modern," makes these studies as a part of his preparation for a larger work on the philosophy of Plato on which he is engaged. The central aim that unifies the volume is the attempt to prove that much more of Platonism than is commonly supposed is Socratic, or may be traced back even to the Pythagoreans and other pre-Socratics. One may concede the a-priori historical probability of this thesis and yet distrust it as a working hypothesis either for the philological study or the philosophical interpretation of Plato. In the one case, it will mislead because the evidence needed to verify it is lacking. In the other, it is a dangerous guide because the assumptions of modern scholarship make us more likely to miss the incalculable superiority of Plato to his contemporaries and predecessors than we are to overlook parallels and anticipatory sug- gestions in pre-Platonic literature. In the lack of space to apply these principles to the detail of Professor Taylor's book, I can only give a sum- mary of its content and indicate a few reserves. The first essay on "The Impiety of Socrates" argues that the impiety meant in the indictment was Pythagoreanism — the Socrates of the Gorgias and Phaedo "frequented a foreign conventicle." The conclusion is reached by elimination. The accusation of impiety was not brought merely as a foundation for the charge of corrupting the young. Professor Taylor thinks that the testimony of Isocrates' Antidosis shows that "it would have