STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 103 Greek literature, yet Herodotus and the Attic tragedians are no less conscious than Homer of the Umitations of humanity, and they believe in the divine jealousy." From this he argues that the belief in divine jealousy has been expiu-gated from Homer. Again, while arguing that the Odyssey is a tradi- tional poem, he says that it was the audience rather than the bard that chose the subject and its treatment. "Indeed the bard was more dependent upon his hearers than they were upon him, he had no other public, no appeal to a different tribunal or to posterity. Therefore the poet's matter was given him." His audience which gave him his theme and his matter believed in the envy of the gods; then why did he expurgate it from tradition, a tradition with which the audience was already familiar and in which the audience believed? A sovereign genius might so overtop the mass as to doubt the envy of the gods and to ignore it in his poetry, but a mere purveyor of tradition could only echo the beliefs of his audience, and that audience believed in the envy of the gods, hence the Odyssey cannot be both an expurgated and a traditional poem. Mr. Thompson takes it for an axiom that the chief characters of the Odyssey were originally gods, and it is well known that in later ages some of them were honored with shrines and offerings. We know that Alexander of Macedon was a man who later received divine honors, and we know that the Roman emperors were originally men, and so were the saints and apostles. The fact that there are many shrines and temples named in honor of St. Paul does not prove that he was once a god. The fact that we have such convincing evidence of divine honors paid to historical characters warrants the assumption that a similar thing took place at an earlier age. How flat the promise of Calypso to make Odysseus divine, if the hearers of the poem had already regarded him as a god! With the knowledge of the promise of Calypso and the history of Alexander in mind, I think it far more likely that Odysseus was a human ruler with a human wife than that he was once a divine wolf howUng along the snows of Parnassus and she a divine duck quacking along the waters of Ame. John A. Scott Northwestern Univbbsitt Les prHres danseurs de Rome. Etude sur la Corporation sacerdotale des Saliens. By Ren£ Cibilli. Paris: Geuthner, 1913. Pp. xi+187. Fr. 7.50. The hypothesis which the author of this work undertakes to prove is well summarized in an introductory note by J. Toutain, and is that the Salii were established to guard the taUsman shields {ancilia), the symbols of Mars; that their estabhshment coincides with the introduction of metallurgy into Italy; that their dances are probably derived from the magic ones of Cretan metal-workers (of which a reminiscence is to be seen in the legend of 104 Book Reviews the Curetes) ; and that the essential act of the rite, the sound made by beating upon the shields, was intended to dispel evil and hostile influences. The discussion is introduced by a bibliography (in which one misses any reference to Marquardt's Romische Staatsverwaltung or Wissowa's Religion und Kultiis der Romer) and an account of the sources, literary, epigraphic, iconographic, and numismatic, the first two groups of which are given in full in appendices. Chap, i deals with the fall of the ancih and the institution of the Saiii, Cirilli beUeving that archaeological evidence shows the form of the shield to have originated in the realm of the Aegean civilization. The history of the two Roman colleges of the Salii and their membership, so far as we know it, is treated in a somewhat desultory and unsatisfactory manner. To the priestly prosopographia as here given additions might be made from A. Klose's Romische Priesterfasten and G. Howe's Fasti Sacerdotum P.R. publicorum aetatis imperatoriae. Election to the college, the number of priests, their officers, buildings, and slaves; their garments, head dress (in which Cirilli detects strong likenesses to that of the Aegean civilization), and armor are described in detail. Less satisfactory is the chapter on ritual, and the attempts to connect with the dance of the Salii some hard and ill- explained words in Festus and Varro are unconvincing. From this same defect the section on sacrifices also suffers, and distinction is not carefully drawn between sacrifices in general and those of the Salii in particular. The explanation of the scanty fragments of the Carmina SaMarium adds nothing new, and the few pages devoted to it contrast unfavorably with the ample material of Maurenbrecher, of whose work, though mentioned in the bibliog- raphy, little or no use appears to have been made. In trying to reconstruct the sacred calendar of the college, the writer at times oversteps the evidence, as in his discussion of the word mol'ucrum, and his suggestion (p. 134) that the Salii took part in the ceremony of the Argei. Finally, it was from Crete, according to Cirilli, that the bronze civilization came to Italy, perhaps conveyed thither by guilds of metal-workers who brought with them their ritual dances, which, though rededicated to Italic divinities, still retained their original magic purpose. It is the comparison of the Cretan with the Roman institution which has evidently had chief interest for the author, and it is in this theory, whether right or wrong, rather than in the presentation of more familiar and undisputed facts that the suggestiveness of his book lies. As to his main contention, however, one should perhaps suspend judgment until a connection between early Italian and Cretan (not merely Aegean) civilization has been more strikingly revealed in other instances also, for this is a field in which cumulative rather than isolated evidence is needed. One regrets to notice an abundance of typographical errors and incorrect or incomplete references, and the author's habit of making a separate para- graph of each sentence merits decided protest. Akthur Stanley Pease University of Illinois