STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 101 otherwise so complete does not include a chapter on the ornamentation of Beneventan MSS, even though the omission is due to the near approach to publication of a special study of the theme by another writer. A more lamentable defect is the absence of an index of subjects. There is, to be sure, a reasonably analytic table of contents, but this is far from sufficing. The treatise contains much unavoidable repetition and scattering of discus- sion (and some that was doubtless due to the period of time over which the composition was possibly extended), and in the absence of an index the consulting reader will probably miss something that he is searching for. Even the composition of an index would probably have led the author to certain condensation and reconciliation of statements. There is, to be sure, an admirable hand-list of Beneventan MSS, an index of MSS, and a con- densed index of authorities cited. The list of Beneventan MSS, complete as far as the author's knowledge goes, will be hailed with loud acclaim. Traube's life, prematurely shortened, is remarkably prolonged in the excellent work of his devoted pupils, among whom Dr. Loew stands pre- eminent. We heartily wish him length of days and favor of fortune for the continuation of the special studies in which he is so successfully launched. E. T. M. Studies in the Odyssey. By J. A. K. Thompson. Oxford: Claren- don Press, 1914. Pp. xii+250. $2.50. This book, written under the direction and guidance of Miss Jane Harrison and Professor Gilbert Murray, deals with the origin and growth of those traditions which found final expression in the Odyssey. The Min- yans of Boeotia created the character of Odysseus whose maternal grand- father was AvtoXvkos, Very Wolf, a wolf-god of Parnassus. The name of Odysseus was originally 'OAwnrevs, the stem of which is lukos, and so accord- ingly Odysseus and his grandfather were originally one, and the hero of the Odyssey was at one time a wolf. The traits of a wolf are the shifty traits of Odysseus: "So Odysseus the Shifty Lad of Greek mythology is also the Wolf." The cunning attributes of Hermes were those of Odysseus: "Odys- seus was originally a mere double of Autolykos, who again was a double of Hermes." The hero was also the sun-god: "The sojourn with Kalypso may represent the periodic disappearance or obscuration of the god, and thus represents the winter feebleness of the sun." "Herakles is also the Daimon of the Sun-year, hence the substantial identity of Odysseus and Herakles." "The arrows shot by Odysseus are the rays of the sun, and the bow is proper to him in just the same way it is proper to Apollo, because it is the weapon of the sun who shoots his rays from afar." The Odysseus legend, starting from Boeotia, moved to Arcadia, where it took to itself the Penelope legend. Penelope was originally a duck, irrive\o^, the divine Penelops of Arne in Arcadia. "Penelope is in essence the same as 102 Book Reviews Artemis and both alike are at bottom Fertility Spirits." Penelope also represents the moon: "If Odysseus is the Young King and the Sun Bride- groom, Penelope must be the Moon Bride." When the Minyans came into Arcadia they found a new divinity, Penelope, whose marriage with Odysseus is a symbol of the union of the native settlers and the invaders. This Minyan Odyssey was substantially the same as the present 'AXkivov airoXoyoi, to which was added in Arcadia the saga of Penelope and her wooers along with the return and vengeance of her husband. The tradition next moves to Ithaca and "the Odyssey is the saga crystallized at the moment when Odys- seus had become king in Ithaca, and had brought with him Penelope and her Suitors, and all the Boeotian and all the Arcadian myths and traditions of which he is the center." With the movement of the Ionians to the Aegean these traditions passed eastward and became at home in Delos where they were sung by choruses in honor of Apollo. The technical name for their production was u>vrj opripevo-ai, from which came the word o/w/pos, mean- ing a singer or interpreter; then there arose a guild who called themselves 'O/M/pt&w. Homer was the assumed ancestor of this guild. Homer then was the name of the head of the Delian singers, a personification of the tribal dance. As often as there was a new leader or head of these singers there would be a new Homer, hence a different Homer at different times, and so accordingly we have a Homer from Chios, a Homer from Smyrna, a Homer from Colophon, and so with the other assumed birthplaces of the poet. "The God, Poet, and King are derived from one primitive figure, the leader of the tribal magic-making dance. The Delian Apollo and Homer were in origin identical." The Odyssey acquired the broad outlines of its present form at the Delian Festival, then it passed over to Athens where it received its final form, and thereafter recited at the Panathenaea became an especial Athenian possession. The Odyssey is a traditional poem, and the saga which started in Minyan Boeotia, after having lived for many centuries and having journeyed far, took a permanent home in Athens near the place of its birth. Homer is only the ritual name proceeding from the chorus of Delian Maidens who sang the hymn wvrj 6p.jjpd5