STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 96 Book Reviews Lexicon Plautinum. Edited by Gonzalez Lodge. Leipzig: Teub- ner, Vol. I, fasc. 7 (Fabula-Hercle), 1914. Pp. 577-672. Each fasc, M. 7.20. A detailed account of the purpose and plan of this lexicon was given in Vol. IV of this journal, so that we may confine our attention here to some of the points of interest in the fascicle before us. The articles which have most interested the reviewer are those on foras, hau (haud), and facio. The extent to which foras and foris are dis- tinguished from each other furnishes vis with a delicate test of the vulgar element in the language of Plautus. Out of a total of about one hundred and forty instances of the use of foras there are only four cases in which foris would have been preferable, while in Petronius (cf. Segebade and Lom- matzsch) foras is used for foris in three out of six cases. Under hau, haud, on p. 668, the collection shows clearly the consonants before which haud is occasionally found. The longest articles are those on facio (42 columns) and on habeo (16 columns). The survey which the editor gives on p. 599 of the use oifaxo with the simple future, the future perfect, and the subjunctive will be especially valuable to Plautine scholars. In contrast to facio it is surprising that fas is found only four times in all the plays of Plautus. Some commentators have taken exception to the use of forma in the epitaph of Scipio Barbatus with the meaning "personal appearance," but the large number of cases in which Plautus has employed the word in this sense (cf. p. 631) shows that it was freely used with this force in the third century B.C. In the notice which appeared in this journal of fascc. 1-5 the reviewer regretted the fact that Professor Lodge had not included prosody in the scope of his plan. He is reminded of this omission now while reading the article pn fio. The number before us shows all those excellencies in the way of completeness and accuracy which have characterized its predecessors. Frank Frost Abbott Princeton University Aus Platos Werdezeit. Philologische Untersuchungen. Von Max Pohlenz. Berlin: Weidmannsche Buchhandlung, 1913. Pp. 427. This is an excellent book. It is not wholly free from the prevailing vice of our philology, the endeavor to prove more than the evidence war- rants, but it rarely if ever misquotes, misconstrues, or grossly misinter- prets particular passages of the Platonic text. An interesting introduction discusses the origin of the related dialogue form as we have it first in the Charmides, and later in the Symposium, Phaedo, Theaetetus, Parmenides, and Republic. It is Plato's modification Book Reviews 97 of the memoir style known to his readers in such works as Ion of Chios' iv&^jxuu. Plato substitutes Socrates or another for himself in this Icher- zahlung, because the dialogues are typically true composite dramatic pictures, not literal historical reproductions of particular conversations. The literary public of Athens understood this, and would not have made Ivo Bran's mis- take of attributing to Socrates the ideas of which Plato makes him the mouthpiece. They were accustomed not only to memoirs but to the debates of tragedy, comedy, history, and the courtroom. The title, IIAaTwos Aax^Sj told them that they were reading a work of art. And they would no more attribute to Socrates the metaphysics of the Phaedo than they would credit him with the favorite Xenophontic notions of Hevo^oWos OIkovo- (uk6$. In this repudiation of Bran's suggestion Professor Pohlenz does not seem to be aware of the extension of Bran's principle to practically the entire Platonic philosophy by Professor Taylor in his Varia Socratica and Professor Burnet in his edition of the Phaedo and his recently published Greek Philosophy from Tholes to Plato. The remainder of the volume discusses in sequence the Apology, Laches, Charmides, Lesser Hippias, Protagoras, Gorgias, Meno, the "first edition of the Republic," the Menexenus, Phaedo, Phaedrus, Lysis, and Symposium. A concluding chapter sums up the results of the investigation with the title of the whole, Aus Platos Werdezeit. The analyses are in the main sound. Space fails here to discuss either the instances of what seem to me overpressure of the evidence by the method, or the coincidences with my Unity of Plato's Thought. Professor Pohlenz does not quote English writers and does not trouble his readers with explicit mention of "was ich Mannern wie Bonitz, Gomperz, Rader, Ritter, ver- danke, oder wo ich von ihnen abweiche." I will merely enumerate some of his results and indicate a few of my doubts. The first group of dialogues includes the Apology, Laches, Charmides, Lesser Hippias, and Protagoras. The Protagoras is conceivable only as a parallel to the Hippias and a continuation of the Laches. None of these dialogues was composed before the death of Socrates, for all discuss his personality and teaching in a way that would be unseemly in his lifetime. The fallacies of the Hippias are intentional, and the correction of one of them in the Protagoras is meant to assure the reader of this and at the same time to compliment Protagoras at the expense of Hippias. With the prob- lem of the second half of the Protagoras and its relation to the Gorgias, Pohlenz deals less successfully. He assumes a great advance in Plato's psychology between the Protagoras and the Republic, and a fundamental change of attitude toward hedonistic utilitarianism between the Protagoras and the Gorgias. This is of course to overlook the Laws, as I have shown in Unity, etc., and repeated in the article on "Plato's Laws" (Classical Phi- lology, IX, 364). Pohlenz pronounces the seventh epistle genuine and the greater Hippias spurious for reasons which I cannot stop to discuss. The 98 Book Reviews Gorgias and the Meno, he thinks, mark a crisis in Plato's spiritual life, due to the renunciation of political action described in the seventh epistle, and to doubts as to the possibility of knowledge, provoked partly perhaps by the realization of his error in the Protagoras. The Gorgias may be dated about 394, or if intended as an answer to Polycrates, about 391. The somewhat later Meno softens the harsh judgment of the Gorgias on Athenian statesmen, and in 95C acknowledges Gorgias' reply to the criticisms of the dialogue that bears his name. This kind of reasoning is, in my opinion, never safe. I will give but one illustration: Pohlenz finds in the statement, 88B, that courage is harmful — el p.ij «rrt p6vr)s." Plato, as he tells us in Laches 197DE and elsewhere, does not care for sophistic or Prodicean nicety in the discrimination of synonym except where it is required by the argument; provided the meaning is clear he is always ready to fall back upon the broad common-sense application of words. In Laches 196E it is regarded as a paradox — /x^Stvos Or/piov airoSe^ta-Oai avBpeoav — and in Laws 963E, Plato does not shrink from saying avev yap \6yov ko!