STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Keviews 365 Pegasus harnessed to a dray. Critics of this way of thinking will appre- ciate the pathos of the following excerpt from the preface: De caelo descendisse iam illud volgo videtur: standum codicibus. adi- ciunt prudentiores modo si bonis et in re incerta. ego vero, qui haud paullo audacior sum, etiain pessimis inquam, et vel in re manifesto,. But Professor Postgate has not carried audacity to the pitch of leav- ing the received text quite where he found it, and the compact little appa- ratus contributes a goodly number of suggestions for the guidance of those timid souls who find it easier to stomach the absurdities of the mediaeval scribes when they are seasoned with a dash of scholarly criti- cism. The selection of the conjectures to be printed is marked by the same good taste and penetration which stamp the editor's own contri- butions — characteristics which classical students have long been used to expect in work which comes from Dr. Postgate's pen. B. O. Foster Stanford University Catalogus codicum Graecorum bibliothecae Ambrosianae. Digesse- runt Aemidius Martini et Dominious Bassi. Tomi duo. (Paginae 1161 praeter praefationem et indices locupletissi- mos.) Mediolani: impensis U. Hoepli. MCMVI. L. 50. The catalogues of Greek manuscripts in Italian libraries, made and published by native scholars in recent years, are both numerous and excellent. In the first ten volumes of the Studi Italiani alone, sixteen scholars, following the admirable method of Vitelli and Piccolomini, have given exact descriptions of the Greek manuscripts in twenty libraries in sixteen different Italian towns. This work requires patience and industry as well as paleographical skill and large acquaintance with Greek literature, and it lays learned men everywhere under heavy obligations. One of the accomplished editors of the two volumes now under review had executed single-handed, before the present task was begun and while he was still prefect of the Brera, the greater part of a similar task of such magnitude that it might well have deterred him from future labors of the same kind. 1 But he and his colleague, after twelve years' labor, have happily brought a still more important undertaking to suc- cessful completion, and the learned world now has at easy command a trustworthy account of the contents of the 1,098 Greek manuscripts, com- prehending about 2,500 works, that constitute the chief treasure of the Ambrosian Library. !E. Martini, Catalogo di manoscritti Greci esisUnti nelle biblioteche italiane: opera premiata dalla R. Accademia di Archeologia, Lettere e Belle Arti di Napoli, Vols. I, II, pp. 430, 271 (1893, 1902). 366 Book Reviews This collection is fourth in size among those in Italy, the land of Greek manuscripts; yet it was made very rapidly. Its founder, Cardinal Fede- rigo Borromeo, a pious, learned, and far-sighted man, when he determined to establish this seat of learned studies in Milan, proceeded to the execution of his plan with a directness of purpose that seems modern. In order to increase and complete his collection, he committed the purchase of new manuscripts to three friends in particular. Gratius, who was instrumental in securing the 268 Pinelli manuscripts, thoroughly explored central and southern Italy; Salmatius went to the East, where he denuded mon- astery after monastery of its treasures; Olgiatus, who was subsequently appointed the first prefect of the library, departed into Germany and France. Other books were secured elsewhere, so that, when the library was formally opened in December, 1609, it contained nearly its present number of Greek manuscripts. Among its treasures was — and is — the famous Homer of the third century, that was first described by Mai and has recently been published in facsimile by Mon. Ceriani and Dr. Ratti. For three hundred years there was no printed catalogue of this notable collection. When the good cardinal founded the library, he established also a Collegium Doctorum. Its members were to use the manuscripts and printed books that he had brought together for the promotion of learning, but were not permitted to publish catalogues of them. The purpose of this prohibition is not stated, but it may be inferred. As the editors of the present catalogue happily surmise, Borromeo may have dreamed of founding another Alexandria or Perga- mum in northern Italy. Certainly his college has included famous scholars among its members. The editors, with proper pride, name Muratori and Mai — chalcenteri umbo. In consequence of this pro- hibition, learned men who were not able to resort to the library had only meagre means of ascertaining what it contained, and those that used it — and many came hither from different parts of the world — had at their command only unsatisfactory manuscript catalogues of the books. It seems well to have waited even three centuries in order finally to secure so satisfactory a guide to the Greek treasures of the library as the present catalogue affords. The mode of description of the manuscripts adopted by its editors is a model of concise but complete statement. All library marks are given. The exact contents of each manuscript is recorded in minute detail. (Such a book as the important manuscript numbered 886— C 122 inf. — furnishes an excellent test of the editors' skill and care, — a great composite folio of 363 leaves, written by different hands in the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries, often hard to decipher because of the handwriting and the condition of the book.) No errors of scribes are corrected, but all are scrupulously indicated. Printed books that state the results of previous investigations are fully cited. In describing the external features of the manuscripts, the editors give not Book Reviews 367 only complete information as to material, form, size, condition, and age, but also all facts that contribute to our knowledge of the history of the books — names of former owners, place of purchase, year of acquisition, and the like. Their record of subscriptions is particularly satisfactory, and they are often able to identify with confidence an unnamed scribe. Cardinal Borromeo founded his library in the heart of Milan. This has grown to be a great modern city, but even today one may pass in brief space of time from the gay life of the Piazza or the roar of the Via Torino to the quiet of a cloister and to the serene company of learned men. Here the bustle and tumult of the world are forgotten. Those who have studied here ever remember the charm and interest of the place, and they will hope for the speedy fulfilment of the promise of the editors some day to write the complete history of this great collection. John Williams White Harvard University Studien zum Commentator Cruquianus. Von Johann Endt. Leipzig: Teubner, 1906. Pp. vii + 76. M. 3. The object of these studies, a product, apparently, of the Horatian school of O. Keller, is to prove the worthlessness of the Commentator Cruquianus as a source of ancient tradition. The author shows by many examples that the Commentator in fact represents the interpretative activity of Cruquius himself, drawing from the scholia of various MSS, from other ancient sources, and even from earlier printed editions. This result does not differ from the characterization of the Commentator which is given by Teuffel-Schwabe 240. 3, with this difference: that Endt apparently denies that the Commentator contains even a residuum of valuable material which is not found elsewhere. The author has characterized the method of Cruquius with a thoroughness and wealth of illustration which is admirable and useful, but I do not see that his investigation proves his own contention that the commentary of Cruquius may be ignored by the editor of the Horatian scholia. To do this it would be necessary to point out the origins of all the matter which is apparently peculiar to the Commentator, and I do not see that this has been attempted. It is certain that Cruquius drew interpretative material from a MS or MSS no longer extant. That this material is identical with scholia found in existing MSS is a thesis conceivably demonstrable, but until such demonstration is made Horatian scholars may be pardoned for using, though with great reserve and caution, matter derived from the Commentator Cruquianus. To admonish such reserve, and to illustrate Cruquius' method of work, Endt's studies will be found very serviceable: it is the more to be regretted, therefore, that his presentation is singu- larly obscure and perplexing. G. L. Hendrickson