STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 363 Roman Private Law: Pounded on the Institutes of Gains and Justinian. By R. W. Leage. New York: The Macmillan Co., 1906. Pp. ix + 4:29. $3.25. Since the twelfth century, when Vacarius, the Itahan glossator, was invited by Theobald, the archbishop of Canterbury, to deliver law lectures at Oxford, this university has been the chief seat of the academic study of the Roman civil law in England. It is true that writers of distinction, like Hallifax, Phillimore, Clark, and Roby, have appeared at Cambridge, and valuable contributions have been made to the study by Scottish civilians, like Mackenzie and Muirhead; still, the most important center of the study of the Roman law in Great Britain has remained at Oxford. During the last forty years there has been a marked revival of interest in this study in the English universities; and nowhere has this interest been more manifest than at this ancient seat of learning, as is shown, for ex- ample, in the scholarly commentaries of Poste, Sandars, and Moyle. The author says that his book is an attempt to meet a want which he himself has felt for " some book which is content to give as simply as possible the subject-matter of the Institutes of Gains and Justinian, fol- lowing, in the main, the original order of treatment." The chief distinc- tion of the book, however, consists not so much in following the order of the Institutes as in being a systematic treatise which presents in an un- usually clear and analytical form the subject-matter of the institutional writings. The ordinary method pursued in systematic treatises has been to depart from the order of Gains and Justinian, and to substitute an arrangement more or less in conformity to that adopted by the German writers. The German civilians have a plausible reason for adopting a new system in expoimding the civil law, since their purpose has been (especially in their Pandekten) to explain, not the ancient Roman law of Justinian, but the modern Roman law in force in the German states. But such a reason does not exist in the academic study of the Roman law in the English universities. Mr. Leage is, therefore, entitled to the gratitude of English students for explaining the Roman law as the Roman jurists themselves understood it, without an attempt to recast it in accordance with a modern scheme. The book is introduced by a discussion of the "sources of the law," giving a brief explanation of the nature of custom, statute law, the edicts of the magistrates, and the "responses" of the jurisconsults, closing with a description of the codification of Justinian, and with the plan of the Institutes. This introduction, while clear and in a certain sense compre- hensive, must still be regarded as quite inadequate as a discussion of the historical development of the Roman law from the time of the XII Tables to the time of Justinian; and it, in fact, gives no hint of the historical relations of the Roman law to modern jurisprudence. By thus restrict- 364 Book Reviews ing the historical part to thirty or forty pages, the author seems to lose sight of one of the chief reasons which justify the preservation of the Roman law as a part of a modern educational curriculum. The book is mainly devoted to an explanation of the principles of the law as set forth in the Institutes, supplying the deficiencies of the Institutes by an appeal to the Digest. This exposition shows the author to be a careful student and a faithful follower of the Roman system. The whole body of the law is divided, as Gains divided it, into that which pertains either to persons, or to things, or to actions {vel ad personas vel ad res vel ad actiones). The discussion of these separate divisions is presented in such an analytical form as to make clear the fine distinctions of the law, without confusion or ambiguity. The system of notation which the author has adopted in his subdivisions of the subject will be found a great aid to the student in enabling him to perceive and to fix in his mind the logical relations of the various parts of the law. Although frequent use has evidently been made of the works of standard English writers, such as Sandars, Moyle, Roby, Muirhead, as well as Ledlie's translation of Sohm, there is a certain perspicuity in this book which is due to the author's own peculiar and original method of treatment. The very systematic arrangement of the material, and the frequent illustra- tion of legal principles by concrete examples, give to his discussions an unusual distinctness and reality. While the author has in one or two instances (e. g., in treating of the effect of the " mancipatory " will, or the testamentum per aes et libram) expressed an opinion at variance with the chief authorities, he has usually presented the accepted views of the law; and has also wisely left to more recondite works the discussion of certain mooted questions, such as those which have arisen among commentators in connection with the law of "possession." When considered as a simple and systematic exposition of the elements of the Roman private law, both in their broad outline and in their most important details, this book possesses many valuable features and must be regarded as an acceptable addition to the literature of the subject. William C. Mobey University op Rochestbe Tihulli aliorumque carminum libri tres. Recognovit brevique adnotatione critica instruxit Iohannes Pekcival Postgate. Oxonii: E typographeo Clarendoniano [1906]. $0.50. This convenient little edition will at once take its place as the most useful text of Tibullus in the market. In pursuance of the plan of the Oxford series its tone is distinctly " conservative." Indeed, to those who have applauded the same editor's Propertius (London and Cambridge, 1894), with its flood of daring and often brilliant innovations, his present performance may not improbably suggest the painful comparison of