STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Keviews 361 The Sources of the First Ten Books of Augustine' 's De civitate Dei. By S. Angus. Princeton dissertation. Princeton University Library, 1906. Pp. 278. $1. The direct quotations from classical authors found in the De civitate Dei have already been pointed out in the edition of Dombart; but the mere collection of them in a conspectus, as has been done by Dr. Angus, serves to give a vivid impression of the extent of the reading of the great leader of the African church. The scope of the dissertation, however, is much wider than this. The aim has been to "search all the extant sources to which Augustine could have had access," and thus to deter- mine his probable authorities. This task has been executed with great thoroughness, and, in the main, the conclusions drawn are convincing. For his survey of Roman history in the early books Augustine is shown to have used Florus and Eutropius, as well as Sallust and Livy. Per- haps the latter has not always received due credit. For example, the words in De civ. Dei iii. 19, qui non tarn narrate bella Romana quam Romanum imperium laudare instituerunt, are just as appropriately used of Livy as of Florus; while the statement thus introduced (in con- nection with the second Punic War), similior victo fuerit ille qui vicit, may be regarded as a reminiscence of Livy xxi. 1. 2, just as the phrase two lines beyond, Alpibus disruptis, may possibly be an allusion to the story found in Livy xxi. 37.' The explanation given of Augustine's failure to make any mention of Tacitus is not satisfactory: "But Tacitus' work was not so well adapted to his purpose, as the gloomy pictures painted by Tacitus belong to times after the introduction of Christianity." For the sketch of Roman religion, the chief sources are Cicero and Varro, and in the case of each of these authors Angus has pointed out a fragment previously unacknowledged. Of special interest is the discussion of Augustine's indebtedness to the Neoplatonists. The commentary is also valuable in its discussion of subjects lying outside the main theme of the dissertation, and to a large extent supplies the place of an annotated edition of the first ten books of the De civitate Dei. Naturally some additional parallels might have been included; e. g., the argument against the astrologers drawn from the case of twins in v. 2 is exactly that of Cicero in De divinatione ii. 43. 90. A few errors also occur. The authorship of the Asclepius, or Dialogus Hermetis (sic) Trismegisti, is incorrectly assigned to Apuleius, and on p. 201 there is a peculiar mis- interpretation of Augustine's comment on the trial of Apuleius. The identification of Labeo, the writer on religious topics, with Labeo, the jurist of the Augustan age, is not at all certain, particularly in view of the use of angelos in the passage attributed to him in De civ. Dei ix. 19. 1 Augustine probably did not use the complete work of Livy, but the lost Epitome. See Sanders in University of Michigan Studies I, pp. 149-260. 362 Book Reviews The latter part of the dissertation discusses the extent of Augustine's knowledge of Greek, a matter of especial importance in connection with his use of the Neoplatonists as a source. By a careful examination of several of Augustine's works it is shown that he had a command of the Septuagint and the New Testament, so far as to distinguish delicate shades of meaning and to venture upon textual emendations. In view of his own conclusions, Angus hardly seems justified in denying the possi- bility of Augustine's having known Homer or Plato in the original so dogmatically as he has done in his study of the sources. Mention should be made of the interesting chapter on the composi- tion of the Be civitate Dei by Professor West, at whose suggestion this study was undertaken and to whose inspiration Dr. Angus evidently owes much. The work is one that will be welcomed by students of Augustine for its abundant collection of material and the light thrown upon many interesting problems. For this reason, it is particularly unfortunate that the proofreading did not receive more careful attention Edward A. Bechtel University op Chicago The Cynegeticus. By Henry Nevill Sandeks. Johns Hopkins dissertation. Baltimore: privately printed, 1906 [1903]. Pp. 32. The aim of Dr. Sanders is to throw light upon the problem of the authorship of the Cynegeticus "by trying to determine more nearly the date of publication from literary allusion and the locality from topographical consideration." In proof of knowledge of the Cynegeticus among writers of the fifth and fourth centuries he compares Simon with Cyn. iv. 1, Plato Bep. ii. 375 with ii. 3, Hypereides v. 18 with ix. 12, Euripides Bacchae 862 ff . with ix, and Demosthenes vi. 14 with xi. 3. As an example of these supposed parallels we may take the last. When Demosthenes spoke of Philip as tw ®eTTa\o>v hrirltov koX to>v Oij/ScuW oirAiraiv iv jneVat \r)4>6ek he had in mind the words used of big game in Cyn. xi. 3: aTroKXeurdeuTa. /jtera iWtov «