STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 348 Book Reviews Harvard Studies in Classical Philology. Vol. XVII. 1906. Cambridge: Harvard University. Pp. 185. $1.50. "The articles in the present volume are contributed by instructors in the Department of the Classics as a token of affection and esteem for Clement Lawrence Smith, of the class of 1863, for thirty-four years a valued member of the department, but forced by ill health to resign the Pope Professorship of Latin in this university in 1904." These words from the brief prefatory note explain the purpose of the volume, which contains eleven articles, to wit: "Notes on Vitruvius," Morris H. Morgan; "Catullus and the Augustans," Edward Kennard Eand; "On Five New MSS of the Commentary of Donatus to Terence," Minton Warren; "On the Origin of the Taurobolium," Clifford Herschel Moore; "Aspects of Greek Conservatism," Herbert Weir Smyth; "The Battle of Salamis " William W. Goodwin; "An Unrecognized Actor in Greek Comedy," John Williams White; "The Origin of Plato's Cave," John Henry Wright; "An Amphora with a New KoAos-Name in the Boston Museum of Fine Arts," George Henry Chase; "Sacer Intra Nos Spiritus," Charles Pomeroy Parker; " Valerius Antias and Livy," Albert A. Howard. With such an array of articles, every one deserving particular mention, the reviewer, with but little space at command, is confined to the most general remarks. Professor Morgan's observations on Vitruvius confirm his previous study in the conclusion that the author's language is thoroughly in keeping with the traditional date which makes him an Augustan. The paper by Professor Smyth is, with some additions, his annual address as President of the American Philological Association for 1905. It states in excellent form some interesting observations on the literary principles of the Greeks. Professor Goodwin's study of the battle of Salamis, a revision and enlargement of an article published in 1885, will take rank as a classic, concluding the controversy, if I mistake not. Professor White sees in the leader of the second half-chorus in Greek Comedy an unrecognized actor. There is the same penetration displayed here as in the author's study of the plays of Aristophanes in relation to the question of a raised stage. Professor Wright now publishes the paper which he read before the meeting of the American Philological Association at St. Louis in 1901. It would be interesting to find Plato's cave, but the cave of Vari scarcely meets the requirements. Professor Wright discovers only one discrepancy, namely, that, whereas Plato describes the entrance to the cave as equal in width to the cave itself, the cave of Vari is narrowed at the mouth. This objection was raised, I believe, by Professor Shorey. But there is another which to me seems fatal. Plato speaks of a raised road-way running across the cave, along which men carrying various articles pass, some conv ersing, some in silence. Professor Wright identifies this road- way Book Reviews 349 with a platform in the cave of Vari, situated about two-thirds of the dis- tance from the mouth of the cave, doubtless because Plato in that con- nection alludes to a Punch and Judy show. But Plato clearly had in mind chiefly a road along which ordinary way-farers were passing, though to the prisoners who saw only the shadows above the retaining wall the effect would be that of a stage of a Punch and Judy show. Such a road would naturally cross the mouth of the cave. I find that Professor Shorey casually places the road there ( University of Chicago Studies I, p. 238) without reference to this proposed identification. Professor Wright may, however, cite in his favor the diagram of the cave given by Adam Republic of Plato II, p. 65. Professor Parker gives in his article an interesting study of Sjnritus = TTVivfjia in Seneca, Paul, Philo, and Marcus Aurelius. The view, now quite generally held by scholars, that Livy blindly followed Valerius Antias and embodied much of his predecessor's work in his own, is dis- passionately considered by Professor Howard, who leaves hardly a shred of evidence to support it. The article is valuable even for this result alone, but acquires added significance from the fact that the search for sources has in our day gone far beyond its proper limits. It is time scholars were recalled to sobriety of method and a proper evaluation of evidence. W. A. Heidel Weslkyan Univbksity De epigrammatis Simonideis. Pars prior: commentatio critica de epigrammatum traditione, scripsit M. Boas. Groningae: Wolters, 1905. Pp. xvi + 256. While a student of Ribbeck's in the University of Leipzig, I belonged for eight semesters to the Societas Ribbeckiana, which met every Friday for a two hours' Latin discussion of some critical cruces. Notable among these was the text of Theognis, over which we labored and wrote and wrought throughout one whole semester. Inspired by this experience, I fondled the plan of some day " editing " Theognis — a plan from which I was wisely diverted by a philological veteran, who chilled my youthful enthusiasm with the remark: "Don't do it: much too big a field." Those experiences counted in preparing me for a sympathetic attitude toward just such work as this of Boas', however staggering it be to confront 256 pp. of close reasoning and elaborate research, weighing and consider- ing the Simonideosity of less than 35 pp. of Teubner text: — and the end is not yet ; for this is but the introductory part. How do we come by our collection of poems, which we ascribe to this author? According to Boas it is somehow as follows : The original poem, written by S. and engraved perchance on stone, is copied into literature; from that it is still further