STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 254 Book Reviews age of his MSS. But what if he were really expert, as one might have some reason to expect of Cardinal Sforza's librarian? His statement at once becomes damaging evidence against the R theory, and would go to show that Maffei liber was a copy of R rather than the original. F. W. S. Beitrdge zur griechischen Inschriftenkunde. Mit einem Anhange liber die Offentliche Aufzeichnung von Urkunden. Von Adolf WiLHELM. Mit 89 Abbildungen im Texte. Sonderschriften des osterreichischen archaologischen Institutes in Wien, Band VII. Wien: Alfred Holder, 1909. To review a book on Greek epigraphy by Adolf Wilhelm is a task for which practically nobody is competent. That is the penalty for the splendid isolation of his present position. As a historian or litterateur he may be open to criticism; but in the delicate and fascinating art of reading and restoring Greek inscriptions he stands without a peer among the living, and among the dead only Ulrich Kohler deserves mention in the same class. Epigraphy is a Kleinkunst. Its output is not a pedimental group or a Last Judgment, but a series of cameos which may be placed in juxta- position, but which cannot be combined in an organic whole. This fact has been duly recognized in the present book, and, accordingly — apart from an instructive excursus on the publication of records in Greece — it falls into 227 little opera, each centering in the deciphering or restoration of an inscription or name, not all equally valuable, but showing every- where the same mastery of the materials and sureness of touch. It seems to the reviewer regrettable that a heading of some kind, be it ever so slight and approximate, was not put before the great majority of these opera. Even a page title is lacking throughout. On the other hand, the index (pp. 329-77), which the book owes to Dr. Otto Walter, is alto- gether satisfactory, and it is through this that the student who has not the time or interest to read the whole work, or whose memory cannot retain its multitude of facts, will be best able to control its contents. Wilhelm's Beitrdge is a book which no archaeologist, philologue, or historian can afford to ignore. Orthography, word-order, syntax, consti- tutional procedure, political, religious, and economic history, chronology — everything is there. There is hardly a subject in the entire province of Greek antiquity to vphich interesting contributions have not been made. Current epigraphical criteria for the dating of inscriptions fall like leaves in Vallombrosa. There is much in the common publication of new inscriptions to exasperate so exact and conscientious a man as our author; but the schoolmaster's attitude which so many German scholars think fit to Book Reviews 255 assume in similar cases Wilhelm is temperamentally incapable of. Besides, he has met in Greece too many young enthusiasts, whose first adventure in quest of the Holy Grail is often the editing of a Greek inscription, to be harshly critical of their shortcomings. The chances are that he has told many of them where to look and has helped them in their well-meant but unskilled struggles with their finds. That he has gotten something in return, both the spirit of this book and its dedica- tion dem Andenken meiner Eltern und den Freunden die ich Athen verdanke bear witness. W. S. Ferguson Caecilii Calactini fragmenta. Collegit Eenestus Ofenloch. Lipsiae: B. G. Teubner, MCMVII. Pp. xl + 242. M. 6. The two most eminent literary critics and rhetoricians in the time of Augustus were Dionysius of Halicarnassus and Caecilius of Calacte. The extant rhetorical writings of the former are numerous, but of the many important works of the latter we possess, unfortunately, only the most scattered fragments. The titles of these lost works make an impressive list and show Caecilius' many-sided activity. Suidas prefaces the incomplete catalogue which he gives us by the words, ySiySXta 8' airov ■KoXXd and at the end adds, kcH oXXa irXeurTa. The question naturally rises why all these books have been lost, works to which subsequent writers were so profoundly indebted. Ofenloch endeavors to answer this question (p. xii) by quoting Wilamowitz (Die griechische Literatur des Altertums, p. 148): "Caecilius, ein offenbar hochst energischer, kennt- nisreicher und betriebsamer Rhetor, der aber ein allzufanatischer Attiker war, so dass seine Bticher verloren sind." Since the publication by Burckhardt (Basel, 1863) of those fragments in which Caecilius is expressly named, there has been great activity among scholars in this field. The great need which had thus risen, of a new collection, has been satisfied by this timely and useful compilation by Ofenloch. Unlike Burckhardt, Ofenloch includes in his Corpus not only those fragments containing Caecilius' name, but all which have been, with greater or lesser certainty, attributed to him. Those of most doubtful origin are marked by an asterisk. Further, there is presented not only the fragments themselves, but also ancient comments, refuta- tions, etc. In the Prooemium we find, first, a bibliography of the material pub- lished since 1863, of which the collection of Burckhardt and Brzoska's article on Caecilius in Pauly-Wissowa's Real-Enc. Ill, are of the greatest value. In this list I miss Rhys Eoberts' article in A.J.P. XVIII. Next comes a section entitled Historia Caecilii which treats of the life of the critic, his relations with his contemporaries, and the indebtedness of