STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 252 Book Keviews fairness than has hitherto been the case." The exposition of the writer's purpose is followed by two chapters on "Culture and the Human Soul," and "Humanism and the Humanists," after which come sixteen chapters with such captions as " Gods and Men in Homer and Hesiod," " Voices from the Lyrical Poets," "Sophocles of Colonus," and "Roman Spirit and Roman Character." The treatment throughout is exactly what one would expect from the spirit of approach; and one notes involuntarily that our polemical author almost surpasses the patristic writers, to whom recourse must be made to find anything approaching a parallel. For many of those godly men, like Lactantius, dealt with similar questions with a certain dignity of method and elegance of diction; whereas the reaction of our modern Tertullian has extended even to a protest by chaste example against that misleading grace of presentation we so often associate with classical prose. He thus achieves a certain enviable suc- cess : for, if I may be pardoned a classicism, he has been fortunate enough to produce a book wherein the ethos of the form corresponds exactly to the ethos of the content. F. B. R. Hbllems University of Colorado The Identification of the MSS of Catullus cited in Statius' Edi- tion of 1566. A Dissertation submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School of Arts and Literature of the University of Chicago for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy. By Beethold Louis Ullman. University of Chicago, 1908. Pp. 64. 75 cents. In this dissertation Dr. Ullman, who has been one of Professor Hale's collaborators in the task of collating all the known MSS of Catullus, has undertaken, with all Professor Hale's material at his disposal, to discover what manuscripts were used by Statius in his edi- tion of 1566, and to examine the accuracy and critical judgment of that editor of Catullus. In his edition Statius cites under definite designa- tions seven MSS: Patavinus (on 44. 17, etc.), Patavinus alter (on 1. 1, etc.), Maffei liber (on 2. 6, etc.), Meus (on 15. 11, etc.), Vaticanus (on 64. 36, 37), Marcelli Pont. Maximi liber (on 66. 7), Zanchi liber (on 104. 4), and in addition gives many readings without specifically naming the MS or MSS. A comparison of the readings as given in Statius with those of existing MSS, combined with a study of the records of the libraries, particularly those of the Vatican, Padua, and the Bibliotheque Nationale in Paris, has led Dr. Ullman to the following conclusions: Three of the MSS cited- by Statius have disappeared — the Patavinus alter, to which, however, the existing Bononiensis is closely related, the Zanchi liber, and the MS which he calls Meus, though its readings show Book Reviews 253 some affinity to the fragmentary Harleianus 4094. The remaining four MSS named by Statius are identified with MSS still in existence. Vati- canus is shown to be identical with Vat. 1608, on the basis of two read- ings (on 64. 36, 37). It was copied for Sixtus IV, and has been in the Vatican library since it was written. Marcelli Pont. Maximi liber was a MS of Marcellus II, pope in 1550, and founder of the nucleus of the Ottobonian library. His MS is identified with Ottobonianus 1550. Patavinus corresponds closely with a MS still in Padua, Biblioteca Capi- tolare, MS C. 77, and its identity is certain. Three of the seven MSS were consulted by Statius only for the readings in connection with which they are specifically cited, viz., Vaticanus, Marcelli liber, and Zanchi liber. The remaining four are those on which Statius really based his edition, the two Patavini, Maffei liber and Meus, which are often referred to without designation by the words in uno, in omnibus, etc. Dr. Ullman's conclusions are summarized as follows: (1) Statius used no MSS of Catullus that we do not know, except three which are of no value for the text; (2) he did not realize the superiority of the one good MS (R) which he used; (3) his citations are often inaccurate, mis- leading, or entirely wrong, though in this respect he is better than his contemporaries and not much worse than many editors of more recent days. The dissertation, besides simplifying the work of future editors of Catullus by showing that the critical apparatus of Statius has now no value for the constitution of the text, is an interesting and valuable con- tribution to our estimate of the classical scholarship of the Eenaissance. One of his identifications is not sufficiently convincing, namely that K is surely the Maffei liber of Statius. A careful scrutiny of the numerous citations from the Maffei liber and of the readings of R makes it clear that Maffei liber was either R or a lost descendant of R, but Dr. Ullman has failed to give, in the opinion of the reviewer, sufficient con- sideration to the second possibility. There are in all twenty-seven com- plete coincidences as against sixteen discrepancies (five of them minor ones). These the author is obliged to explain away by ascribing them to "carelessness, incompleteness, and error on Statius' part," which is a partial begging of the question. His conclusion that the MS was an old one because of a number of old variants (e. g., al' arsinoes in 66. 54) is somewhat weakened by the express statement of Statius himself (cited by Ullman in another connection, p. 64) as to the age of his MSS. On 64. 80 he says: in duobus paullo vetustioribus libris pro vexarentur, versarentur. Vexarentur is the reading of the two Paduan MSS, while versarentur is the reading of R. The Paduan MSS (date circ. 1450) are represented as older than the others used by Statius. Ullman uses this to show that Statius was careless in the matter of determining the 254 Book Reviews age of his MSS. But what if he were really expert, as one might have some reason to expect of Cardinal Sforza's librarian? His statement at once becomes damaging evidence against the R theory, and would go to show that Maffei liber was a copy of R rather than the original. F. W. S. Beitrdge zur griechischen Inschriftenkunde. Mit einem Anhange liber die offentliche Aufzeichnung von Urkunden. Von Adolf Wilhelm. Mit 89 Abbildungen im Texte. Sonderschriften des osterreichischen archfiologischen Institutes in Wien, Band VII. Wien: Alfred Holder, 1909. To review a book on Greek epigraphy by Adolf Wilhelm is a task for which practically nobody is competent. That is the penalty for the splendid isolation of his present position. As a historian or litterateur he may be open to criticism; but in the delicate and fascinating art of reading and restoring Greek inscriptions he stands without a peer among the living, and among the dead only Ulrich Kohler deserves mention in the same class. Epigraphy is a Kleinkunst. Its output is not a pedimental group or a Last Judgment, but a series of cameos which may be placed in juxta- position, but which cannot be combined in an organic whole. This fact has been duly recognized in the present book, and, accordingly — apart from an instructive excursus on the publication of records in Greece — it falls into 227 little opera, each centering in the deciphering or restoration of an inscription or name, not all equally valuable, but showing every- where the same mastery of the materials and sureness of touch. It seems to the reviewer regrettable that a heading of some kind, be it ever so slight and approximate, was not put before the great majority of these opera. Even a page title is lacking throughout. On the other hand, the index (pp. 329-77), which the book owes to Dr. Otto Walter, is alto- gether satisfactory, and it is through this that the student who has not the time or interest to read the whole work, or whose memory cannot retain its multitude of facts, will be best able to control its contents. Wilhelm's Beitrdge is a book which no archaeologist, philologue, or historian can afford to ignore. Orthography, word-order, syntax, consti- tutional procedure, political, religious, and economic history, chronology — everything is there. There is hardly a subject in the entire province of Greek antiquity to which interesting contributions have not been made. Current epigraphical criteria for the dating of inscriptions fall like leaves in Vallombrosa. There is much in the common publication of new inscriptions to exasperate so exact and conscientious a man as our author; but the schoolmaster's attitude which so many German scholars think fit to