STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 251 The collection closes with Gelzer's masterly oration in memory of Grand Duke Carl Alexander, Eector Magnificentissimus of the Univer- sity of Jena — more educational, political, and historical than merely biographical. The book is beautifully printed; contrary to our expectations of Teubner, a few misprints have been allowed to stand, e. g., Leonideion (p. 338), dasz for das (p. 364), Des Vatererbe (p. 396), period dropped (p. 358). Walter Miller Tulane University Testimonium animae; or Greek and Roman before Jesus Christ. By E. G-. Sihlee, Ph.D. New York: G. F. Stechert & Co. Pp. 10+453. One is inevitably attracted by the announcement of a " series of essays and sketches dealing with the spiritual elements in classical civili- zation," to be written by a man who is now a professor of Latin in a thriving university and was formerly fellow in Greek in one of our oldest centers of graduate scholarship. And the book before us, " which has filled the author's soul for nearly seven years " and " is the fruit of a tree which has been growing for nearly six and thirty years," is really a remarkable production. For, after all these years of association with the culture of Greece and Rome, our author finds that it has become Dead Sea apples to his spiritual palate and conscientiously writes a long tome to dissipate for others somewhat of the "forced and false glamor" that has kept so many mortals in the train of strange gods. To him the primary significance of classical paganism is not harmony, or love of truth, or love of beauty, but neglect of the spiritual side of man's nature and sinful indulgence of the flesh, as typified in paiderastia. To him the essential fruit of the Renaissance is not the reawakening of the mind and soul, the discovery of the individual, but the immorality of Boc- caccio's grosser tales and the revels of the Borgias. For him Matthew Arnold's Culture and Anarchy " is permeated with a flippant spirit and pretty shallow wit," and Walter Pater is only "a morbid worshipper of the Beautiful." How Swinburne, the most brilliant representative of neo-paganism escaped similar condemnation is hard to conjecture, unless our author has religiously avoided all contact with the great Victorian's danger-fraught verse. At any rate, these few sentences may serve to give a fair conception of the frame of mind in which Professor Sihler approaches his difficult task "of presenting very largely in the exact words of their most eminent writer, in versions made for this tvork" Greek and Roman "views or aspirations concerning the soul, life and death, God and the world; in the hope of accomplishing this with greater 252 Book Keviews fairness than has hitherto been the case." The exposition of the writer's purpose is followed by two chapters on "Culture and the Human Soul," and "Humanism and the Humanists," after which come sixteen chapters with such captions as " Gods and Men in Homer and Hesiod," " Voices from the Lyrical Poets," "Sophocles of Colonus," and "Roman Spirit and Roman Character." The treatment throughout is exactly what one would expect from the spirit of approach; and one notes involuntarily that our polemical author almost surpasses the patristic writers, to whom recourse must be made to find anything approaching a parallel. For many of those godly men, like Lactantius, dealt with similar questions with a certain dignity of method and elegance of diction; whereas the reaction of our modern Tertullian has extended even to a protest by chaste example against that misleading grace of presentation we so often associate with classical prose. He thus achieves a certain enviable suc- cess : for, if I may be pardoned a classicism, he has been fortunate enough to produce a book wherein the ethos of the form corresponds exactly to the ethos of the content. F. B. R. Hbllems University of Colorado The Identification of the MSS of Catullus cited in Statius' Edi- tion of 1566. A Dissertation submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School of Arts and Literature of the University of Chicago for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy. By Beethold Louis Ullman. University of Chicago, 1908. Pp. 64. 75 cents. In this dissertation Dr. Ullman, who has been one of Professor Hale's collaborators in the task of collating all the known MSS of Catullus, has undertaken, with all Professor Hale's material at his disposal, to discover what manuscripts were used by Statius in his edi- tion of 1566, and to examine the accuracy and critical judgment of that editor of Catullus. In his edition Statius cites under definite designa- tions seven MSS: Patavinus (on 44. 17, etc.), Patavinus alter (on 1. 1, etc.), Maffei liber (on 2. 6, etc.), Meus (on 15. 11, etc.), Vaticanus (on 64. 36, 37), Marcelli Pont. Maximi liber (on 66. 7), Zanchi liber (on 104. 4), and in addition gives many readings without specifically naming the MS or MSS. A comparison of the readings as given in Statius with those of existing MSS, combined with a study of the records of the libraries, particularly those of the Vatican, Padua, and the Bibliotheque Nationale in Paris, has led Dr. Ullman to the following conclusions: Three of the MSS cited- by Statius have disappeared — the Patavinus alter, to which, however, the existing Bononiensis is closely related, the Zanchi liber, and the MS which he calls Meus, though its readings show