STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 232 Book Reviews The enterprising publishers of the Prussian Academy's great series have certainly met the public more than half way in offering this volume of 442 pages at M. 4 (M. 4.80 bound). The price of the larger work is M. 33 (M. 38 bound). The Greek text is the same in both. The Latin text of Rufinus, which Mommsen edited for the larger edition, and to which he had put all the finishing touches at the time of his death, has been omitted. The original page and line numbers are, however, pre- served in the margin of the smaller edition. This will permit the use of the volume containing the "Prolegomena" and the "Register" which constituted Bd. I of the set, with either edition. In view of the extraordinary reduction in price already made, it would perhaps be too much to ask that the Register (170 pages) be published separately for users of the smaller work. The text is provided with a critical apparatus that will meet the ordinary demands of the student, while the omission of the less impor- tant readings has the advantage of securing greater clearness. The readings of the Rufinus text and of the Syrian translation are in- cluded when important. The volume is uniform in size and makeup with the larger work. It is to be hoped that the reception accorded this book will encourage the publishers to extend the practice to others of the more important works in this series. Charles H. Beeson The University of Chicago Greek Archaeology. By Harold North Fowler \nd James Rignall Wheeler, with the collaboration of Gorham Phillips Stevens. New York: American Book Co., 1909. Pp. 559; 412 halftone illustrations. This excellent book appears in the "Greek Series for Colleges and Schools," edited by Professor H. W. Smyth. It consists of an Intro- duction on "The Study and Progress of [Greek] Archaeology in Modern Times" and of nine chapters on "Prehellenic Greece," "Architecture," "Sculpture," "Terracottas," "Metal Work," "Coins," "Engraved Gems," "Vases," "Painting and Mosaic," followed by a classified bibliog- raphy and an index. The chapter on "Architecture" is by Mr. Stevens, who has already made himself known to archaeologists by brilliant work upon the Erechtheum. The chapter on "Vases," and that on "Paint- ing and Mosaic" are by Professor Wheeler. The other chapters are by Professor Fowler. "Both authors have read the whole book carefully and accept responsibility for the statements contained in it." This handbook belongs to a class already represented by Murray's Handbook of Greek Archaeology (1892), Walters' The Art of the Greeks (1906), and Collignon's L ' ' arcMologie grecque (2d ed., 1907). In my Book Reviews 233 judgment it is superior, on the whole, to any one of its predecessors, although the English works named, and especially the second, are more sumptuously published, and that of Collignon is perhaps more readable. Its full value can be appreciated only by those who know how difficult it has been heretofore for beginners to find concise and trustworthy information on most of the topics included in the foregoing list of chapters. Chap. I, on "Prehellenic Greece," is particularly valuable, including as it does a summary of the discoveries of the past ten years in Crete. Chap. II, on " Architecture," is better than any other treatment of the subject in English that I am acquainted with; yet it needs more revision than any other portion of the book. For one thing, it would greatly gain in usefulness by the addition of a glossary of technical terms. How is the beginner to know, for example, what is meant by a " Lesbian pat- tern" (pp. 123, 129)? Space for a glossary could easily have been gained by the omission of some irrelevant matter, as on pp. 174, 175, 191, 192. The attempt to compile a glossary would doubtless have prevented one or two infelicities in the use of architectural terms. The apparent identifi- cation of "egg and dart" with "ovolo" on pp. 123, 129, may be due to com- pression; but it is impossible to explain away the misuse, on p. 125, of the word "arris," which is properly applicable to the sharp edge between Doric flutings, but not to the fillet between Ionic flutings. For " fascia " at the top of p. 132, 1 should like to substitute "corona." At the bottom of p. 184 "fascia" may be only a misprint for "fascias." To turn to more substantial matters, it is a mistake to say (pp. Ill, 148) that the crepidoma of the " Theseum " had only two steps; see the excellent article "Theseion"in Baumeister's Denkmaler. For a refutation of the state- ment (p. 135) that " the three-aisled system was almost universally adopted " for the temple cella one has only to look at plates xv, xvi, of Perrot et Chipiez, 'Histoire de I'art dans V antiquite, Tome VII. As for the "very noticeable diminution and entasis" of the columns of the temple at Corinth, Durm says (Baukunst der Griechen, 2 p. 209) that these columns have no entasis and only slight diminution, and this, I believe, is right; at least I am unable to learn that anyone has ever detected an entasis. I have noted in this chapter over a dozen additional points, individually unimportant, which call for correction. Chap. Ill, on "Sculpture," will perhaps be less used than the other chapters, inasmuch as that subject is already well treated in more than one book. It is a conscientious sketch, offering very few points for criticism. That the "Apollo" of Tenea is "carved in Pentelic marble" (p. 200) is contradicted by Furtwangler (Beschreibung der Olyp- tothek, p. 47), who calls the marble Parian. The stele of Aristion was not found at Marathon (p. 207), but at Velanideza. I am sorry to meet on p. 269 the "presumption .... that in the statue of Agias we have a con- 234 Book Reviews temporary copy of a work of Lysippus," but I must own that this expresses the all but universal view. How it can be held by one who has inwardly digested Furtwangler's essay Ueber Statuenkopien I am unable to understand. The remainder of the book deals with the various minor arts. One noteworthy feature is the extent to which the museums of Boston and New York have been drawn upon for illustrations. Thus in the chapter on "Terracottas" all but four of the thirty-three illustrations are of objects in Boston. The chapter on " Vases " is the longest in the book. The subject is an extremely difficult one to treat within moderate limits, but the task has been well performed. It is cause for gratitude to have so much carefully compiled information made easily accessible. That, indeed, is the chief thing to be said about the whole book. F. B. Tarbell Hesiodi Carmina. Recensuit Aloisius Rzach, editio altera. Leipzig: Teubner, 1908. Pp. vi+263. M. 1.80. It is difficult to do justice to a book like this in a brief notice. For it contains, in condensed form, the fruits of a lifetime of earnest and successful study of the Ascraean bard. Alois Rzach published his Hesiodische Untersuchungen in 1876, and his first critical edition (Freytag) of the poet in 1884. For twenty years past, the Bohemian philologist (Ezach is professor in the Czechish University at Prague) has been recognized as the foremost authority upon Hesiod — a reputation which he has well earned by his editions, and by a host of minor publica- tions. His massive (second) critical edition of 1902 is a monumental work of the most solid description, not marked, indeed, by Wilamowitzian brilliancy or originality, but accurate and thorough in the highest degree. It lays a broad and safe foundation for future workers in the same field, as well as for Rzach's own exegetical studies, if he should decide to enrich the world with an explanatory edition of his favorite poet. The present work is Bzach's second editio minor, the former text edition having appeared in 1902. It offers substantially the same text as the great critical edition, but with many slight changes, which reveal the veteran editor's unwearied industry and care. So, in Fr. 196, ■gprjcrdat is corrected to alpija-Oai, on the suggestion of A. Ludwich. In Fr. 243, the manifest error tov . . . . Xvxvov (xpupwowi) gives place to T