STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 225 which al] the later MSS are derived, contained valuable material on the political situation in Thessaly at the end of the fifth century b. c, con- siderable attention has been devoted to its study and interpretation. The historians Beloch, Meyer, Pdhlmann, and others — Costanzi and Nestle for example — have been claiming that it is an original pamphlet issued in the form of a speech at the time with which it deals, while the well-known student of Der Attizismus in seinen Hauptvertretern, W. Schmid, has dissented, and tried to show that it really belongs to the brilliant trifler with whom it is traditionally connected. Schmid affirmed that the style of the speech does not reveal the time of its composition; that it may equally well be an old or an archaizing production. This Drerup cannot concede. By a careful study of its style and composition — a complete index verborum is included — the Munich philologue, who has made a name for himself by his work on Isocrates, shows that it is really old; that it has all the expected charac- teristics of the rhetoric of the outgoing fifth century b. o. — the compact, antithetical, abrupt, helpless style of the pseudo-Xenophontine tract on the Constitution of the Athenians, shot through and through with bright colored threads from Gorgias and Thrasymachus; that it has nothing whatever in common with the neo-Attic rhetoric. This, in our judgment a decisive demonstration, is the solid contribution of Drerup's book. In the rest of his work he tries to prove that the author belonged to the circle of Theramenes, and that he sought to make propaganda for the latter's political programme by arguing for its adoption by the city of Larisa. This is simply a far-fetched attempt to explain its spurious title. For the historical and literary interpretation of the pamphlet, and for one of the most brilliant pieces of exegesis of which the reviewer knows, the reader is referred to the second part of Ed. Meyer's Theo- pomps Hellenica. Clearly, the speech belongs to 400-399 b. c, not to 404 b.c; it deals seriously with Larisa, not obscurely with Athens, and its author was a contemporary who knew what he was talking about. W. S. Ferguson Flaws in Classical Research. By J. P. Postgate. (From the Proceedings of the British Academy, Vol. III.) London: Henry Frowde, 1909 Pp. 51. 3s 6 d net. Professor Postgate has written a most entertaining paper "drenched in matter," and full of suggestions from which even dissenters will learn. He probably knows as well as the reviewer that so large and vague a theme can have no unity other than that impressed upon it by the per- sonality of the writer. Classical studies have for many centuries engaged some of the best intellects of Europe. To speak of "flaws in classical research" is like speaking of wrong methods in science, or attempting to 226 Book Eeviews classify fallacies. It is merely a general indictment of human frailty. Still, it is interesting to learn what particular fallacies are the pet aver- sion of an alert and curious mind. The differences between classical and scientific investigation, Pro- fessor Postgate tells us, are two. In classical studies there is more of the personal equation, and yet the classical student makes less allowance for it. This we think hardly goes to the root of the matter. The funda- mental difference is that conflicting scientific hypotheses generally admit of adjudication by crucial experiment, while such questions as the genu- ineness of the Platonic letters, or the origin of the Homeric poems, obviously do not. Up to the stage of final verification, scientific doc- trines are as much affected by personal or patriotic bias as are the hypotheses of philology, and up to this point the leaders of science disagree about the ether, for example, or heredity, or the ultimate con- stitution of matter no less than do the editors of "the Oxford and the Corpus texts of Propertius." What Professor Postgate calls the " idols of textual critics " are simply lapses of attention, or deviations from his own preferred via media. Some systematically emend too much, and some as habitually defend desperate readings of a vulgate. But all intend with Professor Postgate to "act on each occasion as the balance of the evidence .... shall determine." The dissensions of archaeologists, comparative mytholo- gists, and textual or literary critics, which he deplores, are no more surprising than those of geologists, astronomers, and biologists about the age of the world. Specialists inevitably view all things in the light of their specialty ; but in the end if there is evidence enough securus iudicat orbis. The long list of interesting "errors" loosely classified as due to modern proclivities must be judged each on its merits. Some details of ancient life and some linguistic niceties will always escape us. But Professor Postgate underrates the resources of scholarship, unless, as his examples would sometimes imply, his "our" and "we" refer to undergraduates. Whatever the anonymous scholars whom he cites may do in their careless hours, "we" are not really unaware that we cannot reason about classic idiom and syntax in English translation, or that the Latin roots in English have deviated from their original meanings, or that some of these earlier meanings show more clearly in eighteenth century or Elizabethan English than in the idiom of today. And though we may not resort to explanation by hyperbaton so freely as Professor Postgate does, we find nothing startling in the statement that " order in modern sentences is syntactically essential and in ancient sentences syntactically indifferent." We are not baffled by Pindar's " Spartan bevy of girls," or his "dun herd of cattle," and as for Cerberus' "three-tongued mouth " (Hor. Car. ii. 19. 31), I find in my notes ad loc. the comment Book Reviews 227 "Triple-headed and triple-tongued is all one reckoning 'save the phrase is a little variations,' " with the substance of which Professor Postgate will probably concur, though he may deplore the " Americanism " of the phrasing. The next point of difference noted between classical and modern languages is, I think a false one. Speaking of such phrases as Cicero's fontium gelidae perennitates and Phaedrus' corvi deceptus stupor, he says "The greater ease of what might be called the intertransience of two ideas in the circular group (that is, in inflected languages) .... strikes us as particularly strange in a language with such a love for the concrete." But surely this usage is a matter of rhetoric, rather than of the idiom or genius of the language. It appears with euphuism and stilo culto in any language, ancient or modern. Not to speak of Swin- burne's " purblind scrutiny of prepossession and squint-eyed inspection of malignity," it can be found in English without looking further than Byron's "blue rushing of the arrowy Khone." It is a marked character- istic of modern French prose. Mr. Howells constantly employs it, in such phrases as "the girl's belted slenderness." It can be found on nearly every page of Mrs. Wharton, and is imitated by all young writers who are ambitious to have a style. Like everything else, it is Greek in origin, appearing in the Attic drama, if not earlier, and in Plato's later style. (Cf. Eurip. fr. 205: iir&v 8kKfj, etc. To conclude, much as I have enjoyed this paper, I ntark these reserves to guard against the impression which it will make upon the student or the hostile layman. In his impatience of human frailty, Professor Post- gate makes too many concessions to opponents of the classics. He seems to agree with the scientific friend who remarked to him " on the classical man's inattention to details." He says severely " studies in which are so many pitfalls as ours must allow no openings to error." And again, p. 14, "there is small excuse for this blundering." But in his less cen- 228 Book Reviews sorious moods he must be aware that, though habitual blundering may be unpardonable, there is no single lapse that a great scholar may not excusably be guilty of, whether his name be Wilamowitz, Gildersleeve, Jebb, Butcher — or Postgate. 1 am tempted to cite examples from my marginalia. But we can all do it, and I forbear. " Scimus et hanc veniam petimusque damusque vicissim." Paul Shorey Geschichte des griechischen Vereinswesens. Von Feanz Poland. Priesschriften gekrdnt und hrsg. von der ftirstlich Jablo- nowskischen Gesellsehaft zu Leipzig. Nr. XXIII der his- torisch-nationaldkonomischen Sektion. Leipzig: Teubner, 1909. Pp. 655. M. 24. This imposing work, which may be regarded as an enlargement and completion of Ziebarth's Das griechische Vereinswesen, has nine main divisions: (1) "Namen und Arten," pp. 5-172; (2) " Gotterverehrung," pp. 173-270; (3) " Personenstand," pp. 271-329; (4) "Organisation," pp. 330^52; (5) "Finanzen," pp. 453-98; (6) " Sittlichkeit," pp. 499-513; (7) " Geschichtlichen Ueberblick," pp. 514-34; (8) " Listen der benutzten Inschriften und Papyri," pp. 548-630; (9) "Register," pp. 630-55. The remainder is made up of a few pages of introduction, and thirteen pages of additions and corrections which were made necessary by the fact that the printing began in 1905. The author was ill advised in calling his book a history. It has indeed made a history of the Greek private associations possible, but it is itself simply a collection of the materials for such a work. We hasten to add, however, that it is a complete collection; that the materials are well mastered and admirably analyzed, and that so many new, important observations are made that the whole represents a substantial scientific advance. The term thiasos in Attic use meant technically, Poland remarks, a subdivision of a phratry. Hence it could not be the abstractum of orgeones or of thiasotai. Hence too, we may add, lists of members of thiasoi were normally published without the demotica, which arose from the relatively late, concurrent registration of citizens in the demes. Elsewhere, however, in our judgment, the lack of demotica signifies the presence of foreigners; so that the distinction drawn by Poland between orgeones and thiasotai is not complete. The former were all Athenians, the latter all foreigners — at least till, in the second century B.C., Athens abandoned her inveterate social exclusiveness. The associations desig- nated by titles compounded of the names of deities and the suffix — stai, and especially the eranistai, were composed according to circumstances