STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 394 Book Reviews Philostratos liber Gymnastik. Von Julius Juthner. Leipzig: Teubner, 1910. Pp. vi+336. M. 10. The ample introduction and full scholarly commentary make of this edition almost a complete history of ancient gymnastic and an indispen- sable supplement to Krause's antiquated Gymnastik und Agonistik der Hellenen. The term yvfivao-Trjs, as opposed to niu8or/>t/?i}$, first appears in Plato, and is there always used with reference to diet and exercise for health and efficiency rather than to the mere technical exercitations of the palaestra. Gymnastics is the counterpart of medicine, the one pre- serving, the other restoring, health. This leads Juthner to conjecture that the term was introduced by Herodikos. Later, when the ordinary trainer dignified himself by the term yu/iwumfc, Erasistratos (ca. 280 b.c.) introduced the words vyiavos and vyiuvrj in its place. Galen, however, does not use them in this way, but prefers to vindicate the office of the ■yv/irao-Tjjs for the physician, leaving to the iraiSoTpt'/fys only the mechanical parts of physical training. These distinctions and the entire controversy might be compared with the distribution of functions in a modern Ameri- can university between the university physician, the director of gymnas- tics and physical culture, and the professional or quasi-professional football or baseball coach. Juthner reviews the history of the literature of gymnastic, of which Ikkos and Herodikos, both mentioned in Plato, and Theon of Alexandria, are the principal names. He emphasizes at first the apparent contradic- tion between Plato's satire of Herodikos in the Republic and his approval of dietetic hygiene in the Timaeus and Laws. The contradiction is, I think, as Juthner himself afterward virtually says, sufficiently explained by the literary context in the Republic. An advocate of the strenuous life depicting a Spartan Utopia may well satirize a regimen that resembles valetudinarianism, and yet elsewhere recognize that dieting is better than drugging. Juthner rejects the conjecture that the Hippokratic ire.pl Siairrj^ is to be attributed to Herodikos. One who had himself been a professional gymnast would never have said of the teachers of gymnastic SiSao-Kovai Trapavofx,itiv Kara vo/mv dSucceiv 8ucaui>s, i^airareav, KAorrav, apxajCfiai '. Our conception of Herodikos' teaching must rest mainly on the excerpts from Menon's Iatrika which Juthner reprints and interprets after Diels. The lost literature of iraiSorpifiir) is now represented only by the Oxyrhynchus fragment (Grenfell and Hunt, III, 466), a part of which Juthner reprints and interprets. He then discusses the literature of medicine and phi- losophy from Plato and Hippokrates to Galen. A fourth division is con- stituted by the lists of Olympic victors, traced back from Sextus Julius Africanus, through Phlegon of Tralles, the Oxyrhynchus fragment (Grenfell and Hunt, II, 222), and Eratosthenes, to Aristotle and Hippias, Book Reviews 395 and the lists of the Eleans ra 'HAeiW, the introductions to which devel- oped into extended historical and antiquarian treatises on the origin and history of the different forms of contest. To complete the sources, we must add (5) the treatises -rrtpl ayu>vo>v of Douris of Samos, Kallimachos, and others, and the periegetic literature. Philostratos himself writes from the point of view of the professional teacher of athletics, for whom, however, he vindicates some of the func- tions of the hygienist, the physician, and the physiognomist. His treatise is based on some lost tlaaywyr), and conforms to the type of that branch of literature, but it is not really a technical introduction, intended to be of practical service for the professional student. It is rather a sophistical, epideictic essay in the form of an tlo-ayutyr). In this respect it resembles Lucian's trtpl 6pxys, or defense of dancing, and may be further com- pared with his Anacharsis. Juthner's text is based on the Monacensis, the fragmentary codex Laurentianus, and a new recension of the recently rediscovered manu- script which the Babrius forger, Mynoldes Mynas, brought to Paris from the library of the Seraglio and published in Greek and French very uncritically in 1852 and again in 1858. Juthner acquits Mynas of bad faith and does ample justice to his occasional good suggestions. He has discussed the entire question of the history of the text in Sitzungsber. d. kais. Akad. d. Wiss. in Wien, Phil.-Hist. Klasse CXL V (1902), 1-79. There is no space for further details here. The translation, which occupies six to eight lines to a page more than the original text, making comparison very inconvenient, is readable and correct. There may be room for slight differences of opinion in a few cases; e.g. 134, 11: tS>v ASr/jXiav a-irTtTai is not quite "sich an unbekanntes heranwagt"; 136, 8: in t5v dKpij8ev 6/wiwv Aesch. Ag. 1423. It means clearly " from the most exact sources," namely tol 'HXeiW. In 142, 2, Kara ttjv 3>pav tov how; is not strictly "in jener Jahreszeit .... wo," but "in the summer, when." In 174,15, c\eyxos dirapam/Tos is, I think, not "eineunwiederlegliche Probe," but rather " unerbittliche," i.e., "an inexorable test." The notes take account of all the literature of the subject, and com- ment instructively both on the subject-matter and on Philostratean usage and idiom. Here, too, there is little if anything to criticize. Is it not possible that in 134, 3, ao-Tpovo/uas, mroo-r) p.r) irtpiTT-q refers rather to over- ingenious mathematical or cosmological hypotheses than to astrology? In 134, 22, xnrip rijs v(retoi aKovownjs KaKu>v av (176, 9) and iv xv tovtov. But further criticism of detail exceeds the scope of this review and perhaps the competence of the reviewer. It remains only to add that the interest of Dr. Jfithner's valuable book goes far beyond the promise of its title. It is not only the definitive authority on the ancient literature of gymnastics, but it throws illuminating side lights on the history of philosophy and medicine and on many other aspects of ancient life and literature. Paul Shorby Aristote et VidSalismeplatonicien. By Charles Werner. Paris: Felix Alcan, 1910. Pp. xii + 370. This is an excellent piece of philosophical analysis. Dr. Werner knows the text of his author, and is acquainted with the recent French and German literature of the subject. In a series of chapters with such titles as " Being qua Being," " Form and Matter," " Essence," " Nature and Chance," "The Soul and the Body," " Thought," " Desire," " Virtue," " Pleasure," " The Prime Mover," he gives a compact and closely reasoned account of the metaphysical side of the Aristotelian philosophy. His method is perhaps too abstract and systematic to do justice to the individual Aristotle, the man, the teacher, the writer. He has nothing to say of the Politics, the Poetics, the scientific writings, and the detail of the Ethics and Logic. As his title implies, he holds that Aristotle, despite his destructive criticism of Plato, remains essentially a Platonist. Idealism is an equivocal and unfortunate word to express this Platonic philosophy, for in the one definite and scientific use of the term Plato- nism is not idealism at all. Dr. Werner believes with Zeller that there is a fundamental contradiction at the center of the Aristotelian system, but thinks Zeller has stated the contradiction wrongly. He perhaps ex- aggerates the difference. The precise definition and location of the contradiction involved in any and every absolute system of metaphysics is largely a matter of opinion or order of exposition. The chief novelty of Dr. Werner's book is his affirmation that Aristotle's God is identical with the soul of the world. A natural movement, he argues somewhat sophistically (p. 324), is a movement communicated by an internal prin- ciple; and since God produces the natural movement of the heavens, God is an internal principle of motion. But this is to confound the desire of the lover with the attractive power of the beloved. Aristotle explicitly says kivu s epco/xow. The parodox is attenuated, however, by the subsequent statement that God is also the ideal world of Plato, and the sum total of the ideas. The fact is, we are dealing with notions too vague and equivocal for precise determination. The idea of God, except in its most naive and anthropomorphic form, is always developing toward pantheism. A pantheistic god is virtually identical with the soul of the