STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 390 Book Reviews Isaac, now rehabilitated. All this material is minutely examined and the history and composition of the various parts discussed in an interest- ing and valuable introduction of 64 pages. The ancient scholia have come down in full in two manuscripts: Marcianus 476, which Scheer designates as s; and Neapolitanus II D 4, which he calls s 3 . Two manuscripts con- sulted by Tzetzes, s* and s 5 , belong to the same class. In addition there are the occasional notes added by Nicetas (s 2 ); and s 6 used by the unknown grammarian of the fifteenth century in editing Tzetzes; besides Vaticanus 1307 (V), which is a copy of s. One manuscript of Isaac Tzetzes is cited and four of his brother John, whose library Scheer attempts to recon- struct. He accepts Eeitzenstein's conclusion that the older paraphrase was based in great part upon the mutilated scholia of Sextio, and not upon the version which now exists; and Sextio, he thinks, drew from Philogenes, to whom we are indebted for whatever learning of the ancient grammarians is still to be found in the scholia. Philogenes thus becomes something more than a name. So, too, he attempts to drag Orus from his obscurity. Theon has been somewhat better known for a long time. The resemblances to various passages in the scholia to the Aeneid are also examined. There still remain, however, many points to settle. Of the actual editing of the volume little can be said by way of criticism. The text of the different manuscripts is given, with the ap- paratus criticus at the foot of the page. It is a thorough and careful piece of work done by a man entirely familiar with his subject. His wide reading is shown by the numerous references, noted in the margin, which include not only the Greek authors, but very often scholia- References to the scholia of three or four different writers may be found cited for a single passage. The one thing which may be missed is an index rerum. Such an index would make the volume more accessible to other than Lycophron scholars ; and its absence is only partially made up for by the index of the writers mentioned in the text. But this is a mere trifle. We are fortunate in having so excellent an edition of the scholia to Lycophron, and it is much to be hoped that other Greek authors may fare as well. William N. Bates Neue Untersuchungen liber Platon. Von Const antin Ritteb. Munchen: Oskar Beck, 1910. Pp. viii+424. This republication of the studies in Plato written since his epoch- making Untersuchungen of 1889 is designed by Professor Ritter to accompany the crowning work for which all the rest have been a prepara- tion — his Platon, which will be reviewed in our next number. The studies included in this volume deal with the Sophist, the Politieus, the Philebus, Book Keviews 391 with Sprachstatistik in application to Plato and Goethe, the meaning of eTSos and JSeu and similar words in Plato, and the letters attributed to Plato and Speusippus. Professor Hitter's mastery of Platonic usage and the sobriety of his judgment preserve him from all the extravagances of fantastic and a priori Platonic interpretation. To much of his analysis of the Sophist and Philebus I heartily assent, and if it were worth while I could quote confirmatory passages from my own papers. He is un- doubtedly right, for example, in maintaining that Plato did not take the "Divisions" of the Sophist so seriously as to require us to emend all seeming imperfections and inconsistencies out of them. It is unques- tionable also that the polemic against the dSmv i\oi is either Plato's rectification of his own former statements or preferably his protest against misinterpretation; that the del A.eyd/xew of the Philebus are simply Satze, sentences, in human speech, and that the introductory metaphysical categories of the Philebus are in the main merely a general statement of the method of logic to be applied in the following discussion. (Cf. "Recent Platonism in England," AJP, IX, 280, 282-85; De Platonis Idearum Doctrina, 12, n. 3.) My differences with him begin at the points where he makes con- cessions to those who discover inconsistencies or fundamental changes of opinion in Plato, and they depend on distinctions so nice and subtle that it is perhaps vain to hope for a complete understanding. He does not seem to me to make sufficient allowance for the idea which I emphasized in my Unity of Plato's Thought that inconsistency, more or less dis- guised by metaphor, is to be expected in relation to ultimate metaphysical problems, and that since we all live in glass houses we are not justified in throwing stones. I mean, to take the most obvious example, that it is unreasonable to complain of inconsistency or poetic vagueness with regard to the problem of evil, or the relation of the Ding-an-Sich to phenomena. All philosophies here take refuge in metaphor which will not bear close logical analysis. The only escape from this sort of self- contradiction is to be found in hard-headed, materialistic positivism, and that too, as the Theaetetus shows, has its own difficulties. Now, the hypostatized ideas are Plato's Ding-an-Sich, deliberately accepted with full perception of the apparent absurdity of the doctrine from the point of view of common sense, as preferable to the alternative of Protagorean relativity. It is quite true, as Professor Ritter says, that mythical, poetic embellishment of the hypostatized idea is confined to a few dialogues. There was no reason why Plato should go on repeating himself forever. It is quite true that nearly everything that Plato says about the eTSos or iSea in the later dialogues admits of a perfectly rational, logical interpretation in terms of conceptualism. But this does not justify the theory that Plato distinctly abandoned in these later dialogues a doctrine of the hypostatized idea, which he maintained in the earlier 392 Book Reviews ones. I am not quite sure that Professor Ritter actually holds this view, but he certainly makes regrettable concessions to it. He is repelled by the sentimentalists who make too much of the poetic amplification of the noumenal idea in the well-known passages of the Symposium, Phaedrus, Phaedo, and Republic, and he desires to reduce that element in Platonism to a minimum. He is entirely right in maintaining that beneath or behind the mythological decoration there is always a firm logical framework of common sense. It is also true that this logical aspect of the ideas pre- dominates in the later dialogues. But there is no good evidence of a positive break or change of opinion at any stage of the continuous devel- opment. The blending of the two tendencies in the Phaedrus and the Timaeus will of itself always be enough to refute any such theory. Plato may have ceased to delight in repeating his poetic and mythical descrip- tions of the noumenal idea. But the metaphysical necessity for such a postulate in the background of his philosophy remained unaltered. (See Unity of Plato's Thought, 29, 37.) And the very dialogues in which the poetic mythology is most prominent hint not obscurely that it is not to be taken too seriously, as Professor Bitter himself repeatedly points out in the case of the Phaedo. The Timaeus is explicit in its reaffirmation of the noumenal idea, and Professor Ritter is no more successful than others have been in the attempt to break the force of this testimony. He says of the question there asked, ap' eon ti irvp avrb «<£' cavrov (51-52), that Plato's and our meaning in giving an affirmative answer is merely that the concept represents some objective reality. 1 "Jedenfalls ist es eben der Gedanke einer objektiven Grundlage, eines in der Natur gegebenen festen Haltes fur das, was wir uns in der Form abstrakter Allgemeinheit denkend vorstellen, dessen Berechtigung untersucht werden soil und schliesslich kurzweg durch die Erinnerung an die Verschiedenheit wis 1 - senschaftlicher Erkenntnis von der unwissenschaftlichen richtigen Vor- stellung (vo£s — 8o£a akyfi-qs) verbiirgt wird." But the same interpretation is equally applicable, as Professor Ritter half admits, to the Phaedrus and the Phaedo, and if so, why not to the Republic and the Symposiumt The theory, then, of a radical change of doctrine falls to the ground. The Platonic hypostatization of all concepts will always be a stum- bling-block to common sense. We need not for that reason endeavor to banish it from Platonism. The true method of interpretation is, first, to point out that the paradox is no greater than that involved in every system of metaphysics when thought out to the end, and then to show (1) that Plato adopted it with his eyes open, and (2) the motives that >Cf. my De Platonis ldearum Doctrina, 22: "et primarie quidem doctrina idea- rum nihil aliud evincere vult quam notiones existere, hoc est verba quibus reddunda in vatione utamur aliquid certi signifleare, quod per definitiones aliquatenus expri- mere possimue et ad perspicue disputandum adhibere debeamus." Book Reviews 393 made it impossible for him to limit the hypostatization to any particular class of ideas. It is true that this demands a deeper insight into the nature and limits of metaphysical and epistemological speculation gen- erally than the majority of Platonic interpreters will ever possess. I have thought it more profitable to discuss this larger problem than to attempt to catalogue the wealth of detail which these essays present. It is enough to add that no student of Plato can afford to neglect this volume. It will take its place beside the earlier volume of Untersuch- ungen as an essential part of every Platonist's working library. Paul Shobet ANTI MIA2. An Essay in Isometry. Vol. I. By R. J. Walker. London: Macmillan, 1910. Pp. vii+507. $6.50. Mr. Walker's thesis is that within the sphere of Dorian lyric, including the choruses of tragedy, the equivalence of two short syllables with one long syllable in responsion is never permissible. He is thus at the oppo- site pole from Herkenrath (see Classical Philology, Vol. Ill, p. 360) and the " new metric," if it may be so called, of Schroeder or Wilamowitz. He finds in the received text of Pindar fifty-six cases of the forbidden equivalence, eighteen in Bacchylides, a hundred and three in Aeschylus, a hundred and seven in Sophocles, and too many to count in Euripides. All of these he removes by emendation. To do this with even the appear- ance of plausibility demands considerable scholarship and appalling labor. But in view of the enormous antecedent improbability we must be permitted to wish that all this toil had been devoted to a better cause. The equivalence of two shorts and a long is a priori acceptable to the most refined rhythmical sense. There is no proof that it is arbitrarily and absolutely rejected by the Greeks. There is nothing to go upon except the fact that it is comparatively rare in the more old-fashioned and severe poetry. This plainly does not justify the wholesale emenda- tion attempted here. Though some of these emendations are ingenious, few, if any, carry conviction. There is space for only two or three speci- mens of Mr. Walker's method. In Pind. 01. 2 the first line of the epode has been corrupted throughout with a view to getting rid of one of three successive short syllables. In the first epode in the line Xmwv 8e irttrpay/icixov the last word is a corruption for jrorepaoy«'vw. The error thence spread throughout the poem. In Pyth 4. 31 for Seinr' «rayyeAAovri or Bergk's £ctx' he restores from Eustathius and Athenaeus the Laconian gloss oLkvov reading Tov. Five hundred pages of this sort of thing will make thought-provoking reading for the few scholars who appreciate and enjoy the game. But the reviewer stands helpless before it. Padl Shorey