STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 390 Book Reviews Einleitung in die Sprachwissenschaft. Von V. Porzezinski. Auto- risierte Uebersetzung aus dem Russischen von Dr. Ehrich Boehme. Leipzig: B. G. Teubner, 1910. Pp. 229. M. 3. The author states the purpose of the book in the Preface. He wished to publish the doctrines of his teacher Fortunatov, who was also his predecessor in the chair of the science of language at Moscow. He wished further to prepare for translation into German a book which would serve for the use of beginners in the subject. The two hundred and twenty-nine pages cover all the ground that is of particular interest to European or American beginners. In addition to the chapters that must always appear in such a work, one chapter is devoted to a history of the scientific study of language, two to a classification of the world's chief languages, one to phonetics, and one to the Indo-European Ursprache and Indo-European antiquities. All of this is treated in so few pages by three methods: (1) by condensation of statement, although this is rare, (2) by frequent omission of proof, and sometimes of examples, (3) by treatment of selected topics only. Each chapter has a very brief bibliography, and occasionally references to other books are inserted in the text. It is questionable whether a book bearing this title should include a chapter on phonetics, especially when there is nothing new in it, except a vigorous blow dealt the experimental method. The little work of Finck might well take the place of the forty-two pages given to the classification of languages. With these chapters omitted there would be ample room for a fuller and more satisfactory treatment of changes in language, which should surely occupy half, instead of less than a quarter, of any such treatise. Owing to its size one naturally compares the book with Sweet's History of Language, and the comparison brings out the fact that the chief merit of the new book consists in the interesting manner of approaching topics and the real life that comes from a larger attention to the most important things only, whereas Sweet's extreme condensation is valuable rather than inter- esting. As the book is very readable, it should serve well the purpose stated in the Preface, and its lack of technicalities might give it a still broader range of readers. R. W. Husband Dartmouth College Catulli, Tibulli, Properti, Carmina Quae Extant Omnia, cura Robin- son Ellis, Joannis P. Postgate, Joannis S. Phillimore. London: Warner (Riccardi Press) 1911. Pp. 319. 21s. This de luxe edition of Catullus, Tibullus, and Propertius, limited to 1,000 numbered copies and printed in a special font on special paper, "is the second of a select series of classical texts" of which a Horace was the first. Book Reviews 391 It is a most attractive piece of work; type, paper, and general make-up being admirable. The large initial letters of each poem are a beautiful light blue. As is to be expected, the editions of the Oxford Classical Series are used for the text, though it cannot be said that they are the best available. The critical apparatus and the introductions are of course omitted, as are also the fragments of Catullus and Tibullus. The lines are not numbered. The book being evidently intended for the lay reader, not for the scholar, it seems unwise to have retained the many signs of corruption instead of presenting a readable text — especially in the absence of an apparatus. The prospectus states that "the several editors have kindly consented to read the proofs and are embodying certain recent emendations and correc- tions." Examination hardly bears out this statement. A collation of the first 44 poems of Catullus shows only the change from inpotens to impotens, in 8.9. In the first book of Tibullus the only changes are quot annis to quotannis, in i. 1. 35, and amari to amori (one of Postgate's own emendations suggested in the Classical Quarterly), in i. 9. 45. In vs. 3-7 of the Pan. Mess. the punctuation is changed in accordance with a published suggestion of the editor, but in vs. 71 his suggestion of seno for saevo is not introduced. The poems of books iii and iv are renumbered within the various groups — a confusing innovation. "Incerti auctoris" is the heading for iv. 13 and 14. In the "Vita" Postgate's old emendation ingenue for ^iginem is introduced. Phillimore has been much less conservative. He has apparently intro- duced all of the many (mostly improbable) conjectures of his own that he has published in the Classical Review and elsewhere in the past few years, though some of them were originally made with hesitation. In some cases almost a whole line is changed. In ii. 12. 18 the Oxford edition has si puer est, ammo traice puella tuo; the present one, quod superest, alio tramite pelle sitim, not a single word the same! The new "emendation" agrees with the MSS in only one word, alio. Other changes noted are in i. 2. 7; 8. 13-16; 8. 27 15. 33; 16. 8; 16. 20; 19. 5; 20. 15; 21. 5; 21. 9; 21. 10; 22. 3; ii. 10. 23 24. 8; 25. 17; 34. 31; iii. 6. 9; 7. 49; 7. 60; 9. 44; 14. 7; 18. 19-20; 21. 16 24. 5; 24. 11-12; iv. 5. 21; 11. 24 — practically all published emendations of the editor. There are no other changes in the first book. A new and interesting feature is to be commended: groups of lines closely connected in thought are set off from each other by extra spacing, thus giving an idea of the more or less symmetrical arrangement of thoughts, as well as helping the reader. Of course all will not agree with Phillimore's grouping, for the perplexities are many. Those who wish to possess a beautiful copy of this triad of authors should get this book, but scholars will find the texts of no importance, the Propertius indeed being inferior to Phillimore's earlier edition. However, students of the structure of the Propertian elegy must take it into account. B. L. Ullman University op Pittsburgh