STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 384 Book Reviews accusative of specification, bringing all such cases under the former head (cf. notes on E. 71 «', N.C. 2 ra irepl tous fcovs, etc.). A few misprints have crept into the book: p. 13, last line, the reference is of course to note 2; p. 81, first line, "Troy" should be "Tros"; p. 127, note on Ad N. 43, vrro&jicas should be virodrjicav;; and in the note on N.C. 35 Toiavras v7TC/o/3oAas «x«i> cliruv the editor doubtless meant to write "to be able" instead of "can." Frank Egleston Robbins The University op Chicago Q. Horati Flacci Satirae. Satires publics par Paul Lejay. Paris: Librarie Hachette et Cie, 1911. Fr. 15. This volume is the second of a complete edition of Horace, edited by F. Plessis and P. Lejay, which is designed to supply the lack in France of "un travail d6taill6 de critique et d'interpr^tation." It is therefore a critical edition, with a brief though adequate apparatus, in which the impor- tant variants are noted, and with a very full commentary. Questions of orthography are only occasionally treated. There are preliminary essays on "Les origines et la nature de la satire d'Horace" and on the text. Each satire is provided with a very full introduction, which not only gives an out- line of its contents, but also discusses its character and purpose. In these introductions numerous subjects suggested by the contents of each satire are treated, such as Country Life at Rome, Horace and Lucian, La littera- ture culinaire, and the like. There is an index of proper names and a list of "initia satirarum." The text is on the whole conservative, and more weight is given to the readings of the Blandinian manuscripts than by Keller and Holder or Vollmer. Novelties in punctuation are more numerous, and it is pleasant to see the ingenious and convincing suggestion of Samuelsson on ii. 5. 91 adopted by a second standard text. In the introduction the chapter on the relation of the Old Comedy to Satire is particularly interesting and suggestive. The views of "MM. Leo and Hendrickson" are subjected to a careful critique and rejected, but the book was printed before the appearance of Hendrickson's convincing article in Class. Phil. VI, 129 ff. M. Lejay does not, as so many have done, confuse the issue, and rightly declares that attempts to show dramatic elements in the Roman literary satire are beside the mark. No one, so far as I know, denies the existence of an early form of drama among the Romans, although it is difficult to see how any part of it could have been called "satura." The commentary is very full and printed in excessively fine type, in which misprints and broken letters are more common than they ought to be. It is especially strong on the language and the grammar of Horace, which Book Reviews 385 are illustrated by copious examples from Horace himself and from other Latin writers. In the discussion of moot points the editor assumes a didactic tone, which is at times somewhat aggravating, and is not well suited to a critical edition. On ii. 5. 39, for example, he says of rubra, in the sentence "seu rubra Canicula findet Infantis statuas," "elle convient pour indiquer, non la couleur de 1'astre, mais la chaleur de 1'dteV' Against the passages which M. Lejay cites in favor of this view, none of which refers to canicula, and only the first of which is at all pertinent, may be set Sen. N.Q. i. 1. 7, "cum .... acrior sit caniculae rubor, Martis remissior," and Schol. Bern, in Germ. Arat. p. 237 . 6, Breysig; while against the casual reference in Bliim- ner's Farbenbezeichnungen may be placed the detailed investigation of See in Astronomy and Astro-Physics XI (Northfield, Minn., 1902; cf. TAPA. XXXIV, lix). It seems within the range of possibility, to say the least, that Horace called Sirius red because it was red. The edition is on the whole an excellent one, full of value material and suggestions, which must be taken account of by all serious students of the Satires. John C. Rolfe University op Pennsylvania Auli Persii Flacci Saturae. Edidit atque prolegomenis, interpreta- tione Belgica, commentario instruxit Jacobus Van Wageningen. Partes duae. Pars prior, pp. lxiii+48; pars altera, pp. 129. This scholarly edition based upon the text of Leo's recent revision of the standard Jahn-Biicheler text will be welcomed by all students of Persius. In the commentary Van Wageningen invites careful comparison with the well-known edition of Nemethy, Budapest, 1903, while in the prolegomena we have a convenient summary of the most recent studies in the language, philosophy, and literary art of Persius. This prolegomena, which shows the results of careful assimilation, skilful arrangement, and independent judgment and research, is worthy of all praise. After a brief discussion De origins saturae, pp. vi-x, in which far too scant notice is paid to the theories of Leo and Hendrickson, there follows a section De Persii exemplis, pp. xi-xxiv. The two tables of parallels for Horace, and for Catullus, Virgil, and Ovid are useful. A similar table should have been prepared for Lucilius; cf. my paper on "Lucilius and Per- sius," Trans. Am. Phil. S. XL, 121-50. In the table of Horatian reminis- cences Van Wageningen seems to me over-cautious. In an author whose diction is so steeped in Horace it seems better to follow Nemethy's procedure of quoting all possible parallels that the reader may have the evidence to discriminate between direct imitation, free adaptation, and mere coinci- dence. Chap, iii, pp. xxv-xxxvi, De sermone Persiano, on the lexicography, syntax, and diction of Persius is excellent. The growing influence of the