STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 381 told he had put down, or uses again a spear which he is not explicitly said to have recovered. Roemer goes so far in his enthusiasm for Aristarchus as to emend the scholia in order to shift from Aristarchus to his predecessors the responsibility for irrational interpretations. Many of these emendations are plausible, but the frequent resort to this extreme measure will only further confuse a tradition which Roemer frankly confesses is already the despair of the sane and sincere investigator. We shall await with interest his forthcoming work on Aristarchus. For despite the enormous literature of the subject it is still often impossible to answer very simple questions without a search through the scholia, which few have the leisure or the courage to undertake. And distinguished scholars do not scruple to speak of ^ koivi? as if it were a definite extant ancient vulgate manuscript. Paul Shoret Enchiridion patristicum. Locos SS. Patrum Doctorum Scriptorum Ecclesiasticorum in usum scholarum collegit M. J. Rotjet de Joubnel, S.J. Freiburg: B. Herder, 1911. Pp. xxiv+887. $3.15 net. This volume is a collection of excerpts from the patristic writings, compiled for the definite purpose of illustrating the doctrine of the several Fathers and as a source-book and chronological index of the development of the dogmas of the church. The adoption of this plan necessarily narrows the field of the book's usefulness. The editor has not attempted to cover general church history, although certain selections bearing on the subject are included. Moreover the student of the patristic writings from the literary or personal side will require more continuous material than is here given, and the limi- tations of the selections to those illustrating the development of the dogmas of the church seems liable to bring about the exclusion of much material interesting to the student of philosophy and of the relations between ecclesi- astical and pagan thought. M. de Journel states that he has included the passages most often cited in illustration and those that set forth the thought of the authors or their times in such a way that they could hardly be passed by, pruning away to a certain extent mere rhetorical ornament; but he has not attempted to be so liberal in giving space to those who opposed the ortho- dox views. Thus the Gnostics appear in the present volume only through the medium of their opponents; Pelagius has one page, and Arius fares hardly better. Though in a sense the heresies belong rather to church history than to the editor's chosen field, it might have been well to include somewhat more material than he has furnished. If these are defects they are due to the plan adopted for the book rather than to the fault of the editor. The material which he presents seems to be sufficiently ample and well chosen for the purpose, furnishing representative passages from all the important Fathers dealing with practically every point 382 Book Reviews of doctrine raised in the early church, and with the establishment of the canon and the hierarchy. The typography and scheme of the book are excellent. M. de Journel has not been under the necessity of establishing a text, since he has merely reprinted from previous editions, but he has apparently given great care to its editing and has been fortunate in avoiding misprints. The ordinary student, however, may feel the lack of commen- tary and orientating notes, such as those in Ritter and Preller's Historia philosophise Graecae, which was one of the models for this volume. The selections cover the period from the Didache through John of Damascus, and are arranged by authors, in chronological order, the excerpts from each work being kept together, with proper indications of book and subdivision, but without critical or explanatory commentary. There are, however, Latin translations of the Greek selections, and in the interior mar- gins the editor has placed references to his index theologicus, which com- prises 612 topics relating to doctrinal matters, under which are listed the sections in which the topics are treated. This furnishes an easy method of locating parallel passages and of tracing the development of any dogma in its various phases. The text printed is that of the Migne Patrologiae, except in the cases where a better and more recent edition is available. There are besides an index chronologicus at the beginning of the volume and an index scripturisticus and an index alphabeticus scriptorum, operum, rerum at the end. The work as a whole will prove a useful supplement to other man- uals for the student of church history and of the history of theology. Frank Egleston Robbins The University of Chicago I socrates. Cyprian Orations. Evagoras, Ad Nicoclem, Nicocles aut Cyprii. Edited with introduction and notes by Edward S. Forster. Oxford: The Clarendon Press, 1912. Pp. 160. Mr. Forster's edition of the Evagoras, Ad Nicoclem, and Nicocles is intended for use in the upper forms of the English public schools and the pass course at the universities. It could as well serve to introduce the American undergraduate to Isocrates, for the orations are not difficult from either the linguistic or the historical point of view, and are, besides, inter- esting and fairly representative of Isocratean style. Two of them have never before been edited in full for English-speaking undergraduates. The introduction contains sections upon the life, works, and teaching of Isocrates, the historical background of the Cyprian orations, and Isocrates' style, besides text-critical notes, information about the MSS, and bibliog- raphy. The editor does not of course attempt to surpass Blass and Jebb, but he has told in an interesting way the main facts necessary for the under- graduate student concerning the author and his times. In a school text,