STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 366 Book Reviews last quarter of the fifth century before Christ, however, King Tharyps brought to his own people, the Molossians, benefits derived from an educa- tion received in Athens, and by an enlightened foreign and domestic policy he laid the basis for the future Molossian hegemony. His son Alcetas owed his crown to Dionysius I and Jason of Pherae, and with these and other external supports he made Epirus more than a geographical concept. After his death his kingdom was fought for by his two sons and a domestic feud was thus started which came to an end only in the reign of Pyrrhus. In the meanwhile, through the marriage of Alcetas' granddaughter Olympias with Philip II, Epirus came into the sphere of Macedonian policy. The brother of Olympias, Alexander, and after his death in battle in Lucania, Olympias herself got their cue from Macedon, and this virtual suzerainty of Macedon over Epirus was also exercised by Cassander. On the latter's death, in 297 B.C., Pyrrhus got his opportunity to make Epirus a strong and independent state. He is the central figure in the last half of Dr. Klotzsch's work. That historical training should involve not simply research but also synthesis is a postulate upon which Professor Eduard Meyer has always insisted. Hence the dissertations which issue from his school tend to be books. This condition is illustrated by the important work on the age of Demosthenes recently published by Kahrstedt and also by the one of which we have just sketched the outline. Dr. Klotzsch has tried to make real history out of the meager records of Epirus, and he has succeeded better than might have been thought possible. It was, indeed, worth while to think out the political development of Greece from the Epirote standpoint, and in the process many suggestions are made with which the general his- torian wijl have to reckon. The chief defect of our author is perhaps due as much to the paucity of sources as to youthful enthusiasm — the audacity with which he explains the state of public opinion in Epirus at different epochs and the varying political aims of its rulers. There are some things about ancient countries which we cannot know. The style, too, seems to us needlessly tangled. Professor Beloch does not write German as Dr. Klotzsch does. Occasionally we miss a reference to the modern literature. For example, De Sanctis (Storia dei Romani II, 390, n. 2) might have been cited for the chronology of the Corupedion campaign — with which, by the way, we agree fully. The book as a whole is a very creditable performance. William Scott Ferguson Excavations in the Island of Mochlos. By Richard B. Seager. Boston and New York, 1912. Imp. 8vo, pp. Ill, 11 color plates, 54 figures. This book, recently published by the American School of Classical Studies at Athens, at once takes rank as our best source of information for the begin- nings of Bronze Age culture in Crete. It deals with the author's excavation Book Reviews 367 of twenty-three graves on the small island of Mochlos, which lies off the north shore of Sitia, the easternmost province of Crete. These graves date from the Early Minoan Period, roughly coincident with the third millennium B.C., a time when Crete led Europe in development. While excavating a Minoan settlement in 1908, Mr. Seager was led by surface potsherds to the cemetery site, which lies just outside the ancient town, on a steep slope at the water's edge. Burials were found in six large chamber-tombs, in small inclosures walled by light rubble, in cist-like graves, holes in the rock, and inverted pithoi. There were no signs of cremation, but in every grave the confusion of bones pointed to second burial, after the flesh was decomposed. The pithoi, all containing bones of infants, were scattered on the slope, and evidently bore no relation to the other burials; their decoration is in the well-known style of the Third Middle and First Late Minoan periods. Of the chamber-tombs, standing apart on a narrow ledge of rock, two had been plundered in Middle Minoan times, two contained few but excellent objects, two were veritable treasuries. The princely status of the dead was shown by a profusion of gold diadems, armlets, chains, beads, and pendants, thin strips of gold in many shapes to be sewn on garments, gold hair orna- ments, fine ivory seals, and beautiful stone vases. The total harvest from the cemetery amounted to 265 clay vases, 130 stone vases, 150 gold ornaments, 11 necklaces of various materials, about half a hundred bronze objects, and a number of interesting seals of gold and ivory. None of the "bronze" from Mochlos has been analyzed. Mr. Seager admits the possibility that the Early Minoan specimens may turn out to be almost pure copper, but he wisely refrains from accepting Mosso's postulate of a Copper Age for Crete. From a deposit of the Third Middle Minoan Period Mochlos adds one example of Cretan script — a signet seal of chalcedony bearing three picto- graphic characters, the horned altar, a full-rigged ship, and the trowel sign. Of the same age is a small terra-cotta head, modeled with considerable mastery in the style of the ivory youths and the faience goddess from Knossos, with which it is contemporary. To the subsequent epoch (L. M. I), the flourishing period of Aghia Triadha and Gournia, belongs a remarkable gold signet, which surpasses all Mr. Seager's other finds in general interest. The hoop is so small that the ring cannot have been worn by an adult; on the bezel is carved an elaborate design. Beside a fig-tree, borne in a barge fashioned somewhat like a sea-monster, sits a figure supposed to be the Minoan goddess. On the water's edge stands a pillared shrine. The three symbols in the field are unintelligible; the figure may not be a divinity of either sex, but a mariner. In view of these uncertainties interpretation is at present impossible, but there can be no doubt that the scene is a signifi- cant one. The pictographic seal, the head, and the signet are by-products of the excavations, not associated with the principal burials, whose earlier date is certified by well-known types of pottery. 368 Book Reviews Many pages of Mr. Seager's book can be skimmed by the general reader, but even the detailed lists of finds have been made as attractive as possible by orderliness in arrangement and by constant reference to many excellent illustrations in half-tone (from photographs and pencil drawings), zincograph, and color. The art and culture of Mochlos are summarized in the last twenty pages. The first dwellers in the island were a primitive people. A rapid advance in culture in the Second Early Minoan Period (ca. 2500 b.c.) indicates a sudden widening of horizon. Mochlos gives no positive proof of intercourse with Egypt, not a single importation; but the phenomenal skill acquired in carving hard stone — an achievement for which no preliminary steps have been found in Crete — as well as the forms of at least six stone vases unearthed in his excavations justify Mr. Seager in believing that Egypt had come within the ken of the sea-faring peoples of eastern Crete. Mochlos had a good harbor from which to adventure. Under the new impulse progress was rapid. Mochlos was more pros- perous in the latter half of the Early Minoan Period than in Middle Minoan times, and this is true of eastern Crete in general, in strong contrast to Knossos. Methods of work were simple but effective. The artistic sense was alive. Without help of the wheel, craftsmen carved vases from both marble and alabaster, selecting stone richly veined, and shaping it with careful regard to beauty of color and form. Soldering was unknown but gold was welded to gold, and decorative designs, usually geometric, were beaten out over molds or pricked from the reverse side. Some animal designs, pricked in gold, are very much like the geometric art of the Iron Age. Mr. Seager seems hardly to appreciate the delicate leaf and flower forms, notably the crocus, among the hair ornaments from Mochlos; he reserves his enthusiasm for two exquisitely fine gold chains, equal to late Greek work. Mr. Seager writes with admirable clearness and with the alert under- standing that has made him so fortunate an excavator. His data can be trusted fully. He is guarded in his conclusions, not going beyond the direct evidence of his own diggings, the hardly disputable theory of early inter- course with Egypt, and some interesting views as to the occupation of the coasts of eastern Crete, toward the close of the First Early Minoan Period, by a spread of population from neighboring inland centers of Neolithic culture, or by members of the same race as the Minoans, newly arrived in Crete. His book is not rich in comparison beyond the citation of objects from other Cretan excavations, which are like those found at Mochlos. This limitation narrows our view of the world in which Mochlos played a part. Whence came the copper and gold ? Mr. Seager does not even ask the question. They did not originate in Crete, probably not in Africa. If the copper was from Cyprus, the nearest source, it is the more remarkable that Cretan tools and weapons should be as free from Cypriot as from Book Reviews 369 Egyptian influence. Even before Mochlos was excavated, we knew that in the third millenium B.C. Crete was neither primitive nor merely at school to older lands. Knossos showed obsidian from the Liparian islands. Aghios Onuphrios, Vasiliki, and Gournia opened our eyes to connections with Asia Minor. The Burnt City of Hissarlik had been duly inscribed in the Second Early Minoan Period and Dr. Schliemann's treasure only awaited confirma- tion from the gold ornaments of Mochlos to be accepted as genuine products of the age. The Mochlos gold work is superior to the Hissarlik treasure, refuting the charge that Dr. Schliemann was mistaken in supposing that such objects could have originated in the Aegean at so early a date. It seems probable that Crete had the advantage of trading for raw materials with peoples less advanced than herself, and that this experience was as valuable in giving self-reliance to her native genius as was the intercourse with more civilized nations in awakening new ambitions. But on these points Mr. Seager is silent. Harriet Boyd Hawes "Tertullians Apologeticum." Von Richard Heinze. In Berichte iiber die Verhandlungen der Konigl. Sdchsichen Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Leipzig. Philologisch-historische Klasse 62. Band 1910, pp. 279-490. However fascinating the attempt to reconstruct lost works of ancient literature and place them in their setting, classical philology is in greater need today of exact analyses of extant works, of summaries of their contents, and of comment upon their meaning as a whole. Richard Heinze, who has enabled our generation to read Virgil with fresh understanding, gives in the present volume an admirable interpretation of Tertullian's Apologeticum. After a brief introduction, in which he pays tribute to Geffcken's recent studies of the Christian apologetes, he takes up Tertullian's work in its essen- tial divisions and with a combination of summary and comment follows its line of argument. This treatment brings out in clear relief and with a new emphasis Tertullian's familiar traits and temperamental antinomies — his sturdy historical sense and his reliance upon false history, his hatred of shams and his condescension to sophisms, his tender sympathy for all human souls and his scathing contempt for the pagan philosopher. Heinze shows that the apology as a literary form is, like most literary forms, Greek in its origin, but that Tertullian impresses his own stamp upon it; in general, when appropriating material from his Greek predecessors, he points the argument more sharply and adjusts it more nicely to his needs. Heinze's recent studies in Cicero are applied to good purpose in the present work: he can point time and again to some parallel situation in Cicero, as proof that the methods of the ancient forensics were still in vogue. He takes issue with Mommsen in holding that the proceedings against the Christians, at least as