STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 121 since Drumann's time have materially altered the views of scholars (cf . e. g., p. 263, n. 4; 264, n. 1; 266, nn. 2, 3). If it had been his purpose to do so, the editor could not have brought out in a more interesting, con- crete way, than his notes bring it out, the progress which has been made in Roman history in the last few decades. We cannot close this review, however, without noticing one defect in his plan of revision which con- cerns this volume particularly. Drumann's harsh estimate of Cicero's character and statesmanship is not commonly accepted by scholars today. That could, of course, be properly revised only by rewriting the text. Frank Fbost Abbott Q. Asconii Pediani orationum Ciceronis quinque enarratio, recognovit brevique adnotatione critica instruxit Albertus Curtis Clark. Oxonii: e typographic Clarendoniano, 1907. Pp. xxxv +104. 3s. 6d Cornelii Taciti Annalium ab excessu divi Augusti libri, recogno- vit brevique adnotatione critica instruxit C. D. Fisher. Ibid. No page numbers. 11.50. The transmission of Asconius is through a manuscript found by Poggio at St. Gall in 1416, which has since disappeared. The problem of the editor is therefore the reconstruction of the text of this lost codex. Poggio was accompanied by two friends, Zomini (Sozomenus) and Bar- tolomaeo di Montepoliciano. All three made copies of the manuscript, and those of the last two (codd. S and M) have come down to us. At the time when the last critical edition of Asconius was made, that of Kiessling and Scholl in 1875, it was believed that the copy made by Poggio was lost, although the MSS of Asconius with the exception of S and M were copied from this codex (known as P). As long ago as 1896 (see Class. Rev. X, p. 301) Mr. Clark expressed the opinion that a manu- script at Madrid (cod. Matritensis x. 81) was the oldest of the Poggio family, and that it was possibly written by Poggio himself. In 1899 (Class. Rev. XIII, p. 119) he still hesitated to assert positively that the Matritensis was the lost P, although this opinion was held by Krohn and others. In his edition, however, he designates it as P=Matritensis x. 81 a Poggio scriptus. This new edition then not only gives us the text of Asconius in a more attractive form than before, but a new rescension of the text. Besides his own collation of P, the editor had the use of one made by Skutsch. An introduction gives an account of the life of Asconius together with a history and an examination of cod. P. The apparatus criticus, though not professing to be complete, is much fuller than is usual in the volumes of this series. No such good fortune has attended the editor of the Annals. He 122 Book Reviews has given a conservative text, following the codd. Medicei in a number of places where the other editors have departed from them. He has intro- duced but three conjectures of his own, including a change in the punctuation of 1. 53. John C. Rolfe On the Social Standing of Freedmen as Indicated in the Latin Writers, preceded by a discussion of the use and meaning of the words libertus and libertinus. By John Jackson Cbumley. Parti. Johns Hopkins Dissertation, Baltimore : privately printed, 1906, Pp. 1-43. The purpose of Dr. Crumley's dissertation is stated by him to be " to collect the materials on which may be founded a historical survey of the social standing of the Roman freedmen." The present part gives the data gathered apparently in full from Plautus to Suetonius and excerpted from the important later writings, including the law-codes. Inscriptions are not taken into account. Although the evidence they might give would very likely have agreed in the main with that drawn from literary sources, it is to be regretted that they were not employed; — in studies of this sort no distinction can be made between literature and inscriptions. Certainly if the study of the social standing of freedmen — the subject announced in the main title, but only touched on in the first half -page — is ever undertaken, it will have to be based primarily on epigraphical sources. After brief discussions of the suffixes -to and -ino which add nothing to our knowledge, Crumley quotes a large number of passages in which libertus and libertinus are used, supplementing his quotations in full by lists of passages in which the words appear, and comes to the conclusion that libertus always means 'one who has been freed from slavery,' and that its use to indicate 'relationship to patron,' given in the lexica, is merely an attendant circumstance; libertinus is always an adjective denoting 'one who is reckoned in the rank, the class, the category of liberti; and that in a single passage of Suetonius which has unduly influenced even modern writers, libertini is restricted to ' the free-born sons of liberti.' This is an interesting lexigraphical result. The study might well have occupied, under its proper title, a dozen pages in a journal. But the question arises whether we may not demand of our candidates for the doctorate results a little more weighty and significant. The writer of the present dissertation has shown great industry in gather- ing his material, but mere industry, commendable as it is, cannot be rated very high. A few significant contributions whereby our knowledge of the social position of the Roman freedman could be made more exact, would be worth many pages of confirmatory references. Clifford Herschel Moore Harvard University