STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 309 the present writer confesses that each time he reads the poems anew, he is more struck by their essential harmony than by the inconsistencies in the action and the other indications of different authorship of different parts. 2 Roman Historical Sources and Institutions. University of Mich- igan Studies, Humanistic Series, Vol. I. New York: The Macmillan Co. 1904. Pp. vi + 402. $2.50. An increasing interest in inscriptions and in the history of the Later Roman Empire, a period hitherto generally neglected in our universities, may perhaps be inferred from the title-page of this volume; for of the six authors five use epigraphical material and four deal chiefly with institu- tions and events of the third century a. d. The book as a whole forms an auspicious beginning for a new series. The editor, Professor Henry A. Sanders, contributes two interesting studies in sources. In "The Myth about Tarpeia" he shows that, although in point of fact the Tarpeian Rock was named from a family which once lived in the vicinity, the custom of punishing traitors by hurling them from the cliff gave rise to an aetiological story of the treason and execution of a Tarpeius (Festus, p. 343 M; Prop. iv. 1. 93, etc.). Another member of this branch of the gens Tarpeia was one of the first Vestal virgins; at her grave on the Capitoline the pontifex and the chief Vestal made annual libation on February 15, the beginning of the public Parentalia (see Hor. Carm. iii. 30. 9). In time, however, the desire to account for the presence of this grave within the city walls produced the later and commoner form of the myth, which substituted for Tarpeius the maiden Tarpeia as the traitor (Fabius in Dion. Hal. ii. 38 ff.; Anti- gonus in Plut. Romul. 17). A misinterpretation of the adjacent Porta Pandana was responsible for some details of the story, while the fact that the Sabines figure in it merely points to a belief in Sabine settlers on the Capitoline. One slight logical inconsistency in the above explanation may be noted: since the name of the Tarpeian Rock was derived from the family dwelling there (p. 44, cf. p. 33), that name can not be used as a proof of their residence (p. 16, 1. 15). In "The Lost Epitome of Livy" Sanders presents an exhaustive treatment of an extremely complicated subject. After reviewing recent articles by Reinhold, Wdlfflin, and Drescher, he discusses variant forms of the Periochae and the Epitome, and the relation to the latter work of some of its descendants, particularly Auct. De vir. ill., Appian, Lucan. Ampelius, Dio, and Suetonius. Passages are cited in full and used sanely, though occasionally one feels that the possibility of purely acci- dental resemblances is not sufficiently regarded, e. g., in two cases (p. 195, No. 7, end; p. 196, 11. 11 ff.), the theory of an interpolation rests upon the 310 Book Reviews presence or absence of a single word. In the latter part of the paper Sanders concludes an analysis of the epitomator's use of non-Livian sources with the suggestion that this nameless historian may have been Livy's son, and finds confirmation for his conjecture in the agreement of Plin. N. H. v. 148, for which Livius Alius is a possible source, with a frag- ment of the Epitome (Eutrop. iv. 5. 2; De vir. ill. 12. 6). Walter Dennison, " The Movements of the Chorus Chanting the Car- men saeculare of Horace," rejects Mommsen's theory of a processional. His brief summary of the evidence on both sides will be convenient to all students of Horace. Mary Gilmore Williams continues her admirable "Studies in the Lives of Roman Empresses" from Am. Jour. Arch. VI (1902), pp. 259 ff. This chapter describes Julia Mamaea, the mother of Alexander Severus. " The Attitude of Dio Cassius toward Epigraphic Sources " by Duane Reed Stuart proves that Dio did not consult the Monumentum Ancyra- num, the Fasti Capitolini, or other accessible monuments. At the most, four unimportant references reveal a possible knowledge of inscriptions. Incidentally, Stuart defends at some length the Augustan authorship of the Monumentum Ancyranum. The greater part of Joseph A. Drake's paper on the " Principales of the Early Empire" seems of doubtful value, chiefly because it is based on Cauer's lists (Eph. Ep. IV, pp. 355 ff.), which were published in 1881, and even then were far from complete. An epigraphist can not ignore the discoveries of the last quarter-century, especially if his results are negative. To give but one example, the list of beneflciarii under Ha- drian (p. 287) could be more than doubled by first-hand work with the Corpus. We are not surprised, therefore, that the conclusion (p. 328) that "principales as military subalterns disappear about the time of Diocletian" is disproved by cases like CIL. III. 1803; IX. 4787; VI. 3637, from the army of but one province. Moreover, many inscriptions whose date could not be determined were discarded (p. 263), and more than two hundred others only approximately dated as before 337 are con- tained in the table on p. 311. May not some part of these two classes belong after Diocletian? We must remember that for the Late Empire few chronological tests are available. If, then, the tituli of principales do not disappear, but only diminish in number, they are on exactly the same plane as civil inscriptions; the "general barbarization of the state" certainly did not operate on the army alone (p. 328, bottom). Of chrono- logical errors, the two following affect a large number of examples: (1) The author's tests L and Ma (pp. 269 f.) wrongly assume that the absence of an epithet implies its non-existence in the period in question; but see CIL. III. 3126, 5119; VIII. 2529, 2586. (2) Antoniniana and Severiana do not always indicate the reigns of Caracalla and Septimius (pp. 281 ff.), but often refer to Elagabalus and Alexander Severus respec- Book Reviews 311 tively. The defects in method which have been enumerated happily do not vitiate the entire article; the statements (pp. 317 ff.) about the use in legal Latin of military titles for civil officials, and (pp. 272 ff.) on the meaning of vexillarius, are apparently sound and useful. George H. Allen, in his dissertation entitled " Centurions as Substi- tute Commanders of Auxiliary Corps," tries to show that in each auxili- ary camp was stationed a legionary centurion, who in an emergency sometimes took command with the title curator, and in the case of cer- tain small cohorts, alae and numeri, regularly replaced a prefect or tri- bune as praepositus. The relation between such a curator or praepositus and his troops was also expressed by phrases like sub cura, curam agente, etc., but these same formulas were at other times applied to a centurion who only directed the labor of soldiers not under his command. Unfor- tunately, the existing evidence, scanty at best, has been so perverted in this paper by inaccurate citation and rash inference that the distinctions made between these three functions can not be accepted. A few points only can be given by way of illustration. P. 334, 1. 26: why is not the double title cwra(ra) agente .... curatore mere tautology rather than an indication of two separate offices? P. 336. 4 (cf. pp. 345, 380): the number of the cohort in CIL. III. 5613 is missing and should not be restored [I]. P. 341, n. 1: no other case is known of the centurion of a cohort commanding a cohort or ala. P. 344, 1. 24: this inference contra- dicts the author's conclusion on p. 350; the difference in date of Nos. 5 and 15 is also an argument against his theory. P. 350, 1. 8: if in No. 1, besides curam agente, curator was needed to denote a temporary command (p. 334), then curam agente alone in Nos. 18 and 20 of the same cohort does not indicate another emergency officer, but rather the regular prae- positus. No reason for the inclusion of No. 22 is given. P. 352, 1. 8 begs the question. P. 355, 11. 3 ff . : as these centurions were the titular com- manders, the mention of them here is irrelevant. Pp. 363 f . : both examples from Kaetia are invalidated, No. 1 by a mistake in reporting the location of the stone, No. 2 by the lack of evidence that auxiliaries occupied Lauingen. P. 354: how can the author of p. 345 on substitute officers maintain that a particular corps was never commanded by a centurion solely because three tribunes of it are known ? But if praepositus here {GIL. III. 25) means mere technical oversight {curam agente), while in No. 14 (pp. 345 f.) it was equivalent to curator, then the whole attempt fails to improve on Mommsen's view (p. 333) that the three terms were interchangeable. The book deserves more frequent chapter headings and fuller indices, including one of inscriptions. One hopes, too, that the custom here adopted of citing Greek in translation may not become general. Mary Bradford Peaks Vassar College