STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 304 Book Reviews be taken into consideration. In studying the sources of the Hudson Kiver it is not customary to begin with Spuyten Duyvil, and there are several Spuyten Duyvils in the case-constructions. Secondly, the danger of neglecting the data of cognate languages could hardly be better illustrated than here. Much time is given, for example, to showing how the dative construction of time is indefinite in scope, overlapping other case-meanings, and hard to associate with the ordinary dative conceptions. There is no hint that the Greek datives of time may have to be explained as locatives and instrumentals. Mr. Brown simply holds that it was the " constant presence of a demonstra- tive word with the nouns that gave the case the function of dating pre- cisely." What sweet charms possessed this dative that she must thus sub- mit to the "constant presence of this demonstrative" suitor? We used to believe that the Greek dative of time was largely a locative and in that capacity lent itself readily to expressions of "definite" time with definite modifiers. The Sanskrit and Latin datives do not permanently acquire the " function of dating precisely." Their locatives do. Such facts would seem to have some bearing upon the question. Most readers will admit that the method illustrated by Mr. Brown will prove to be of great service in determining the semantic forces of case and modal constructions; but his work has shown that the method is not universally applicable, and that when applied without regard for the results of other methods its success is but partial. Tenney Frank Bbyn Mawr College The Poetic Element in the Satires and Epistles of Horace. By Philip Howard Edwards. Part I, pp. 47. Johns Hopkins dissertation. Baltimore: privately printed, 1905. The author has collected carefully the passages of Horace's satirical writings which reveal in any way a more manifest poetical treatment. Brought together thus in a single conspectus, they afford opportunity for some general observations of considerable interest, and they may serve to stimulate the reader sufficiently familiar with his Horace to some generalizations of his own. The author protests, perhaps unduly, that the point of view has received too little recognition from the inter- preters of Horace; and this may be true, though it would not be difficult to find more appreciative utterances on the topic than the two or three cited on p. 18, as for example in the brief words, full of critical insight, in Mackail's History of Roman Literature, p. 111. The passages are grouped under the headings: Real poetry, parody, elevated passages, poetic reminiscence. The chief criticism which is to be made on the assignment of material to this classification is the group- Book Eeviews 305 ingof a large number of passages under the head of " real poetry," which belong in fact to the literature of burlesque, of which parody is one type. Like parody it is found much more abundantly in the Sermones than in the Epistulae. A study of this kind does not lend itself readily to severe methods, but more attention should have been given to the development of Horace's taste and technique in the use of thoughts and words which may be designated as poetical. Such a study, freed from conventional standards in determining what is "poetical," would reveal us the real poet, in the subtle emotion of haunting phrases, more often in the Epistles than elsewhere — perhaps more often even than in the Odes. G. L. H. Metaphor and Comparison in the Dialogues of Plato. By Geobge Olaf Berg. Johns Hopkins dissertation. Berlin: Mayer & Mailer, 1904. Pp. viii+57. This monograph deals with its subject in a comprehensive way and will serve as a convenient tabulation of the more important tropes em- ployed by Plato. The author acknowledges his indebtedness to a manu- script dissertation of Dr. E. G. Sihler on the same subject (J. H. U., 1882), and says that he follows in the main the classification of Blumner in his work, tJber Gleichniss und Metapher in der attischen Komodie. The arrangement of the matter is logical, and there is a fairly good English index, though there are many omissions. A Greek index might readily have been added and would have increased the value of the dis- sertation as a book of reference. I have not attempted to verify all the citations, but have found no occasion for criticism in this regard. There are, however, a number of points on which I am inclined to differ from the author. The limits which divide conscious personification from con- ventional phrases are not easy to define; but Dr. Berg appears to dis- cover personification in many doubtful expressions. A few curious blun- ders occur, as where it is said (p. 6) that irdo-^etv is used to introduce a comparison Polit. 303 d. The comparison lies in oju.oi.ov. As Dr. Berg suggests that there are other instances, he may have had in mind such as Crat. 399 b : tovtoiv toCvw ev nal to tu>v avOpuurutv ovo/xa ireirovdev, where it is ko.1 that carries the comparison, as in Aristoph. Nub. 234: irao-^ei 8e ravTo tovto Kal ra KapSa^a. We are here in the sphere, not of formal comparisons, but of the illustrative examples constantly employed by Socrates. A collection of such examples would form a valuable supple- ment to the study of metaphors and comparisons. The author makes occasional references to Plato's use of recurring metaphors, but does not accord them a special treatment. This is to be regretted. In this con- nection the absence of any reference to the work of Dr. G. B. Hussey in this field is somewhat surprising. yy ^ Heidel