STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. BOOK REVIEWS Greek Thinkers : A History of Ancient Philosophy. By Theo- dok Gomperz. Authorized Translation by G. G. Berry. Vols. II and III. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1905. Pp. xvi + 397 and xiii + 386. Each $4, net. Professor Gomperz' Greek Thinkers in this excellent translation will probably supersede Zeller for all but professional students. In a review intended for the more general public (cf. Dial August 16, 1901; July 16, 1905) I have already expressed my appreciation of its three chief quali- ties: (1) its readableness; (2) its skilful blending of the history with the discussion of ideas; (3) its consistent adoption of a modern, rational, and scientific point of view. Taking this estimate for granted, I may, without risk of being misunderstood, proceed at once to record my dissent on certain matters of detail that may interest students of the subject, but do not appreciably affect the value of the work as a whole. In his account of the Socratic method (II, p. 55) Professor Gomperz, influenced perhaps by Grote, exaggerates the distinction between the positive and the negative use of induction. The Platonic Socrates rarely, if ever, elaborates a final positive definition by the inductive method. For Plato, as I have elsewhere shown, has no faith in absolute definitions. But rapid positive induction is frequently employed to win acceptance of a generalization needed in the course of the argument. And proposed definitions are often refuted by such generalizations, or by the direct inductive application of a "negative instance." In any case, it is not true that Aristotle uses TrapapoXrj as the technical name of the negative procedure. A negative instance, «Wras XPV <"><£«« te koi apery* iirip.eXi}6rjvai (Euthydem. 278 d). There is no contradiction between the Apology and other dialogues. The Crito is written throughout in a hortatory and edifying style. In Phaedo 115 b i/xS>v airlav imfieXovfieyot, etc., is as horta- tory in its suggestions as imp.e\Co-6ai apery? in Apol. 31 b ; and in iMches 188 a Socrates' r6le of moral gadfly is distinctly indicated in Nicias' words : kcu ovStv olp.ai ko.kov elvai to viro/xip-vyo-Keo-Oai o tl p.rj KaXSs r) iraroty - Kap.ev rj Trotovp.iv. It is, of course, possible to force a purely intellectual meaning upon all such passages. But to do so is to beg the question. The whole controversy is idle. Nor is there any evidence to support Joel's hypothesis that Socrates began as a moralist, and, mistaking the means for the end, finally lost himself in dialectics. At the most it can be said that the historic Socrates was perhaps less edifying and emo- tional than the Platonic. In his treatment of the Sophists and minor Socratics Professor Gom- perz errs, if at all, from an excessive eagerness to rehabilitate them against Plato's criticism. This tendency has two sources: (1) Grate's watchful jealousy to defend modern utilitarian and relativist philos- ophies against Platonic absolutism; (2) the ingenuity of philologians ever seeking something new. From the first Professor Gomperz should have been warned by Mills's defense of the Theaetetus against Grote's championship of Protagoras. The only remedy for the second is to repeat that we have no evidence. It is abstractly possible that Antis- thenes, Euclid, and the unknown thinkers satirized in the Philebus and Theaetetus meant all that the most advanced modern nominalists, asso- ciationists, and positivists could read into the crude formulas attributed to them. But it is not probable, and there is not an iota of evidence to prove it. Professor Gomperz is inclined to find a developed nominalistic logic in every attack on the Platonic ideas. And he even reads it into a corrupt fragment of Antiphon (Diels Vorsokratiker, p. 553. 1), which, so far as its meaning can be made out, plainly deals with another matter. Professer Gomperz' analyses of the Platonic dialogues are always suggestive and sometimes illuminating. He too often, however, conde- scends to the "immature" thinker of an earlier time, and reads the greatest dialectician who ever lived lessons in elementary logic, and in his endeavor to detect fallacies, inconsistencies, and chronological develop- ments in the dialogues he verifies again my thesis that such attempts, however plausible a priori, almost always wrrrep imrrjSes, as if by some fatality, lead to misinterpretation. Thus in II, p. 332, and III, p. 50, he argues that the Gorgias must be earlier than both Rep. I and the Crito, because Plato is " still " far Book Keviews 297 removed from the principle of love toward enemies. The only basis for this statement is the paradox, of which I should have thought it impos- sible to miss the humor, in Gorg. 480 e that the sole use of the Sophistic rhetoric would be to save your enemy from punishment, that he might suffer the heavier penalty of living in sin. Even that is guarded by the qualification el apa Set nva kcikws iroiiiv. But a little thing like apa can not be allowed to mar a point. Similarly, following Grote, he illustrates Plato's aristocratic preju- dices by the passage in the Oorgias 512 b, where a mechanic " who had ( ?) saved his country from destruction by inventing an engine of war, is, nevertheless, spoken of in a tone of contempt, just because he labored with his hands." But Plato does not himself especially disparage the engineer. He places him above the successful general, and affirms that Callicles despises him, but is not logically justified in so doing by his own ethics of "survival" and "salvation." In III, p. 171, after explaining the theory that the /xij 6v = Ircpov, he continues: "The non-existent in the province of beauty is simply the ugly .... The second step of this reduction is logically more assailable than the first." It certainly is. But the second step is taken by Gom- perz, not by Plato, who explicitly says (Sophist. 257 b): oirorav to /u/i? ov Xiyw/xev, po