STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 110 Book Reviews more stupid and useless the reviewer has seldom encountered. He advises the reader to begin with the Historischer tfherblick with which it ends and in which the conclusions of the investigation are stated, so far as this has any. Had the historical review been made into a preface to the documents and the rest of the first volume been suppressed altogether the work as a whole would have been improved. W. S. Feeguson Habvabd Univeksitt Ennius und VergUius, Kriegsbilder aiis Roms grosser Zeit. By Eduabd Norden. Teubner, 1915. Pp. 176. In this book Norden undertakes to rearrange the fragments of the seventh book of Ennius' Annaks and to prove some new instances of Vergil's dependence upon Ennian episodes. In the former task he is on the whole successful. He makes it appear likely that the paluda virago of Ennius (Vahlen, Inc., 521-22) is the same character as Discordia (Vahlen, 266), that Ennius omitted the First Punic War out of deference to Naevius, as Cicero says, and that the famous passage on Servilius (Vahlen, 234^51) should be assigned to book viii (here Cichorius contributes the argument). Accordingly, Ennius, book vii, contains an exordium, a brief history of Carthage, a description of Rome's first fleet, the quarrel with Carthage over Sardinia, the Gallic wars of 225-222, and the beginning of the Second Pimic War. Norden's ready optimism as regards his own hypotheses is contagious, but I have not always yielded to the persuasion of his style. For instance, I am not convinced that the line "dum censent terrere minis" (256) must necessarily refer to Gauls simply because these people are said to gesticulate at times. On "Geminae Belli portae, sic nomine dicunt" (Aen. vii. 607) he affirms: " Wer hat die Jani portae so benannt ? Keiner ausser Ennius!" But keiner is a strong word in view of the fact that most of the republican literature has vanished. Again, on p. 143, Norden assumes without question that Ennius was a Roman citizen when he wrote book vii. As a matter of fact, we do not know, but the probabihties are against this view. And on p. 72 an unfounded hypothesis of Soltau's is all too hastily fitted into one of his own. In fact, mere possibiUties are too often put forth with a note of unquestioned finality. It was Norden, I think, who first proposed that the katabasis of Aeneas (Aen. vi. 232) was copied from some katabasis of Her- cules, since, forsooth, Charon's boat sank under the weight of the passenger. The next chapter, "De Vergilio Ennii imitatore," provides several instances of circuitous reasoning. For instance, Norden chooses some battle scene in Vergil concocted of the usual ingredients of war cries and wounds, gore and groans, then selecting some disjecta membra of kindred subject-matter from the Ennian incerta and fitting them into a picture of Book Reviews 111 similar type, he holds the two up for comparison and draws the obvious conclusion. The essay is useful, but it should have been pruned and con- densed. Tenney Frank Bktn Mawk College Ludan. With an English translation by A. M. Harmon. In seven volumes. Vol. II. London: William Heinemann; New York: Macmillan, 1915. Pp. vii+520. The second volume of Professor Harmon's Ludan in the Loeb Classical Library maintains the high standard set by the first' and exhibits the same sound feeUng for both Greek and English idiom. It includes "The Down- ward Journey, or The Tyrant"; "Zeus Catechized"; "Zeus Rants"; "The Dream, or The Cock"; "Prometheus"; " Icaromenippus, or the Sky-Man"; "Timon, or The Misanthrope"; "Charon, or The Inspectors"; "Philosophies for Sale." The colloquial idiom is spiced with just enough but not too much slang. And there are many neat turns: e.g., p. 126, 'Airaye, ^uvvol&s to ivOvix-qiia, "Avast! a stockfish idea"; p. 499, "for since there are two classes of men, the disbursive and the receptive, I train myself to be receptive [irepicKTixdv] and my pupil to be disbursive [iK)(vrriv\" ; p. 501, MrjSa/iSs oAA' avdXmov (u, etc., "Don't say that! Distribute my middle, for Heaven's sake, and make me a man again." There are few if any oversights of moment: p. 102, "very valuable indeed" seems to miss the special point of irokvrtiMjroi ms dXij^&s (cf. Aris- tophanes Actemions 759) ; p. 110, «<^' oToi (TV Sia/tcAAeis is not quite "because you are delaying"; p. 121, "naturalized aUens" is perhaps a little weak for Momus' jibe wapey-ypaTmav; p. 131, do-^oASs is not, I think, "unconcernedly,'' but, with pregnant force of the adverb, "seeking safety in the equivocation"; p. 281, veavtKiif avTots 17 imxi] is not "a childish dispute," but "a vigor- ous conflict." A few of the philosophic technicalities in the "Sale of Lives" might have been translated or explained in the notes more precisely. P. 489, KaraXjjTr- TtK-^v (JMvracriav is of course not "the faculty of forming concepts." Paul Shorey Mito e poesia nella Greda antica — Saggio sulla Teogonia di Esiodo. A. M. PizzAGALLi della R. Universita di Pisa. Catania: Francesco Battiato Editore, 1913. In this work the author does for the Theogony of Hesiod what he did for the Hindu cosmogony in Mem. B. Istit. Lomb., Vol. XXII, Fasc. IV: "La cosmogonia di Bhrgu — Saggio sulle relazioni del mito cosmogonico coll' 1 See Class. Phil, VIII, 234.