STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 106 Book Reviews Cairo Menander is not mentioned, though we are told that Menander's plays have been found at Oxyrhjmchus — which is misleading. Though Sandys gives much information about the fate of MSS and libraries, com- pleteness in this as in other regards was naturally not to be expected in the limitations of this volume. He omits all reference to many adventures of manuscripts no less interesting than those which he records, and there are valuable codices of whose destruction he says nothing. There are scholars who will not assent to the statement that Verrall's work on Euripides "rehabilitated the dramatic reputation" of that poet (p. 404). It is sometimes worth while, when one is trying to get a correct idea as far as possible of the learned men of Alexandria, to turn from a book like this and observe in a history of mathematics, such as Cajori's, how two totally different reconstructions of the intellectual interests of, say, an Eratosthenes, may be made in perfect good faith, when one historian is making up a mathematician, the other a classical scholar. Of the 86 illustrations which appeared in the three-volume edition, 25 have been reproduced here; and the spurious portrait of Hemsterhuys has been superseded by the genuine portrait on p. 278. WiLMEB Cave Wright Bbyn Mawk College L. Annaei Senecae Dialogorum Libri X, XI, XII. Edited by J. D. Dttff, M.A. Pitt Press Series. Cambridge: University Press, 1915. Pp. lix -1-312. It is superfluous to call attention to the well-known merits of Professor Duff's Juvenal, nor is it any more necessary to praise this well-edited volume, containing the Ad Pautinum, the Ad Polybium, and the Ad Helviam of Seneca the philosopher. The latter has helped to fill up a lamentable gap; it adds to a much-needed series of works on the elucidation of a prose writer who has been a great deal discussed by scholars of all ages, and but scantily elucidated. Together with Professor Summers' edition of Selected Letters, it forms an indispensable companion to the biography of Waltz and the Roman Stoicism of E. V. Arnold. The reviewer notices a tendency to ignore, except in the case of the text- lucubrations of Madvig and Gertz and a few such books as Fumeaux's Annals of Tacitus, the existence of such valuable works as that of Waltz, above mentioned, and several others. And in remarking that the Dialogues have had no commentary since Ruhkopf in 1797, Mr. Duff overlooks the partial editions of Hurst and Whiting in 1884 and A. P. Ball in 1908. The former contains a conunentary on the Ad Paulinum and the latter one on the Ad Polybium. Again, he might have used, or acknowledged the existence of, such contributions as the excursus of Summers on the consolatio, which is prefixed to the notes on Ep. 63. But these omissions do not destroy the Book Rkvikws 107 value of the book with which we are concerned, since the editor has made a point of going directly to his sources, and of weighing every word and sen- tence per se with scrupulous care. None of the commentary is second hand. Professor Duff has looked the personal character and philosophic claims of his author squarely in the face (see pp. 17, 26, 32, 46 of the introduction). He does not set Seneca upon a pedestal; at times he is too severe with the prime minister who tried, even though vainly, to reconcile his "substantive" ideas with the "acting" ideas of the age. In discussing the reasons for the banishment to Corsica, he omits the statement of Suetonius that "the charge was vague and the accused was given no opportunity to defend him- self." Dio Cassius is not to be taken too seriously. Theeditor (pp. xxxivff.) is also unjust in comparing the impressions of the jaunty traveler James BosweU regarding the island of Corsica with the gloomy despair of the exiled Seneca. M6rim6e's Colomba furnishes interesting thought along these lines. Seneca is to be pardoned for saying with Touchstone: "Ay, now I am in Arden; the more fool I ; when I was at home, I was in a better place." The editor has thrown new Ught on several important questions. Among them are the exact date of Gallio's governorship of Achaia (pp. xlii f.), the definite proof that Seneca was consvl suffectus in 57 a.d. (p. xlvi), the probable conjecture that the Marcus mentioned in the Ad Helviam is not the yoimg son of Seneca, but the poet Lucan, son of Mela, Seneca's brother. He is happy in his definition of the Ad Polybium as a disguised Ubellus, and in his comparison of chaps. 14 and 15 of the Ad Paulinum with two famous passages of Macaulay and Ruskin on the pleasures of reading. We doubt his 5 B.C. as the correct date of Seneca's birth (most authorities put it a year or two later), and we find stiU some question regarding the praenomen of Seneca the Elder. The reviewer must confess that in his opinion the interpretation of Ep. 46 . 1 (p. xlvii, n. 4) is not at all clear. Does this cast any light on Seneca's physical size? Are the words literal? We feel that the editor could have made more of a comparison with some of the letters along broader lines — for example, the first epistle of Seneca, which condenses in narrow compass much of the matter which one finds in the Ad Paulinum. One thinks at once of the recently published journals of Emerson, and remembers the way in which the thoughts occurring in Emerson's prose essays are adapted and condensed. The text leaves little to be desired, and the conjectures are reasonable. Due regard is paid to the contributions of Teutonic and Scandinavian prede- cessors. There is a misprint a for ac in the passage quoted from Suetonius on p. 109, and an accomodatum on p. xlvii, n. 6. We only wish that the colon were not so prevalent. But these points are all incidental; the book impresses one as an original and thoughtful contribution to an important theme of Roman history and thought. Richard M. Gummese Haverford College