STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 227 as it is admirable. Though a considerable number of passages, as was inevitable, are still marked viz sanum, or sensu cassa, yet the scholia, in this new edition, read intelligibly for the most part. And since these scholia form the chief basis of all our knowledge of Pindar, we cannot be too grate- ful to Drachmann for the self-sacrificing labor which he has so devotedly, and at the same time so profitably, spent upon them. Edwaed Bull Clapp University of California The So-called Rule of Three Actors in the Classical Greek Drama. By Kelley Rees. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1908. Pp.86. $0.79. Professor Rees has amplified his dissertation by the following papers: "The Meaning of Parachoregema," CP II, 387 ff.; "The Number of the Dramatic Company in the Period of the Technitae," AJP XXXI, 43 ff.; and "The Three-Actor Rule in Menander," CP V, 291 ff. In the earliest period of tragedy but a single actor appeared upon the scene at a time; Aeschylus was the first to employ a two-actor scene; and Sophocles was the first to see the dramatic possibilities of the three-actor scene and to handle it with facility. This development is outlined in Aristotle's Poetics 1449a 15, and the aesthetic canon resulting therefrom is expressly stated in Horace's dictum: nee quarta loqui laboret (Ars Poet. 192). But the misinterpreta- tion of these passages and of a gloss in Hesychius (s.v. vip-ipis iwo/cpirw, which really refers to the manner of assigning protagonists to poets) has caused modern scholars to formulate the rule that ancient playwrights had only three actors at their disposal. An examination of the extant plays and of the new Menander fragments shows that for a variety of reasons three actors occasionally seem insufficient for presenting certain passages, that frequently r61es must be split (as in the Oed. Col, where, if only three actors were available, the part of Theseus must be carried by all three in turn) and that such splitting results in overloading, "lightning" changes of costume, and incongruous assortment of parts (e.g., the roles of Heracles and Deianeira in the Trachiniae must be performed by the same person). Furthermore, if we except the period of the Peloponnesian War and of the synchoregia in 406/5, there was no excuse for such thrift as all this would imply. On the other hand, it is likely that outside of Athens, in the period of the guilds (third and fourth centuries), such a restriction did obtain, and it would then naturally take its rise from the need of economy by the manager of a traveling troupe. Fortunately, four Soteric inscriptions for the years 272-269 b.c. are extant and in every case the dramatic troupes (twenty-two in all) consist of three actors. The controverted term -rrapaxopriyrnua belongs to the same period and has no connection with the choregic system. It is derived from x°pvyw i n its non-technical sense of "spend" and 228 Book Reviews denotes any "extra expense"; i.e., by special contract the authorities might secure an addition (usually a fourth actor) to what the technitae would normally provide. In the later literature protagonist, deuteragonist, and tritagonist were used in the sense now generally understood, but origi- nally they referred not to the character of the r61es which an actor was to play but to his own histrionic ability — the protagonist was a star; the tritag- onist a "ranter." Thus, three second-rate actors might form a "barn- storming" troupe and in the traditional view one would be the protag- onist, another the deuteragonist, and the last the tritagonist; but properly speaking they would all be Sevrepayiovio-raL Finally, in the case of nine plays the old three-actor distribution of parts is contrasted with a new one of Rees's own devising — allowing from four to seven actors in each cast. In these new arrangements he tries to assign a separate actor to each important part, to avoid the combination of male and female roles and of extremes in age, and in general to form only such groupings as would be likely to escape the spectators' attention. The skill with which Professor Rees urges his views, the neatness with which they reinforce one another, and the flood of light which they shed upon certain dark gaps in our knowledge give his theories considerable weight — in fact, with most of his conclusions the reviewer finds himself in substantial accord. Sometimes, however, an attempt seems to have been made to prove too much; for example, in the statement that "'tritagonist' is a term apparently invented by Demosthenes, was applied only to Aeschines, and was never in any period a recognized title" (p. 34). This is improbable enough in itself, seems inconsistent with the statements made on the very next page, and is expressly disproved by Demos. De Falsa Legatione § 247 : tore yap Srjirov toW oti iv iracri tois opa/iacri rot's rpayiKots iijaiperov iartv oxTirtp yepas tois TptTayeovicrTaTs to roiis rvpavvovi ko.1 roiis to. o~Krj-TTp' «XovTas do-Uvai. This passage is earlier than Demosthenes' use of the term elsewhere (viz., in the De Corona), and, though Aeschines is of course men- tioned in the context, both the sentiment itself in the form of a general statement and the use of the plural TpiTaymvio-raZs and of the phrase iv vatn rots Spdpao-L tois Tpayixois show that this was no word newly coined for the occasion and distinctly imply that tritagonists, whatever their function, were well known to Demosthenes' contemporaries. It is, therefore, hard to believe that in a contemporaneous passage, Arist. Poetics 1449a 16, Aio-xvAos .... to. tov %opov r)\.a.TTO>o~e /cot rbv \6yov -TpuyraytuvicrTrjv ira.peo~Keva.o~tv, -rpu>- Taytuv-o-nqv has no reference to acting (pp. 31 f.). Other possibilities are ex- cluded by the fact that theatrical matters are under discussion, an argument which Rees himself accepts as satisfactory in another instance (p. 32, n. 6). Now if we ask ourselves whether Aristotle considered the dialogue in Aeschy- lus the protagonist because it was first in order of appearance in a play or better than choral parts to perform or as having the chief r61e, we must surely accept the last reason. Yet this conclusion does not invalidate Book Reviews 229 Rees's main thesis, for it is quite possible that the rule of three actors and consequently the traditional meaning of protagonist, etc., go back farther than he supposes and actually antedate this period. Rees is himself of the opinion that the use of dya>vi£o/uu and its compounds with reference to actors began "soon after the introduction of the actors' contest in 449" (p. 35). Before the organization of formal guilds, at Thoricus and elsewhere in the fifth century and in almost every deme in the fourth century dramatic spectacles were celebrated (p. 65); and since it was within the range of possibility for three actors unassisted to present most plays (at least with slight alterations), it is likely that the troupes which visited these festivals were usually no larger. Hence, there may well have arisen in the "prov- inces" an unofficial nomenclature which would obtain no recognition at Athens or, indeed, in official records anywhere. In this. connection it is significant that "wherever Aeschines is spoken of as 'tritagonist' to anyone, it is with reference to performances in the country" (p. 34, n. 6). Again, is not the possibility worth considering that Aeschylus intro- duced the second actor (and consequently the two-actor scene) but had no others at his disposal; that Sophocles added the third actor (and conse- quently the three-actor scene) but had no more than this at his disposal; and that, somewhat later, more actors became available but without further additions to the number appearing together in one scene? There must have been a dearth of actors in the early days (pp. 60 f .) ; and just as the supply would seem about to exceed the demand, a corresponding change in dramatic technique would cause a need of still more. Certainly, the early plays have little fault to find with the two-actor arrangement; and if Aeschy- lus had been amply provided with actors, is it conceivable that a man of such inventive genius and initiative would not once in over thirty years have allowed three of them to appear together ? Other matters may be dismissed more briefly: p. 20, n. 1, 1. 3, for "plays to be given" read "-poets competing"; p. 23, the quotation from the Ars Poetica comes from 1. 192; p. 34, n. 6, irpirayuivurrw (sic); pp. 36 f., another example of ra Sevrepa \eyuv referring to but one r61e occurs in Plutarch Cicero xii; p. 40, n. 1, perhaps "completed the trio" would be a preferable translation; p. 48, n. 1, a better explanation of Alcestis' silence is advanced in Haigh's Tragic Drama 288; p. 54, 11. 18 f ., O'Connor has already pointed out the inapplicability of the reference to Aeschines; p. 58, 1. 5, for "Chrysothemis" read "Hermione"; p. 63, n. 4, add a reference to Plutarch De Gloria Ath., p. 348/-349o; p. 72, "Four men and a boy con- stituted the normal (Elizabethan) traveling troupe." Is there other evidence for this? The play quoted as proof in the footnote seems to point in the other direction: "But one boy? Then, I see there's but few women in the play." As Dr. Rees is fond of Elizabethan parallels, it may be not out of place to cite Brander Matthews' suggestion that Touchstone's disquisition on lies is "put precisely where it is to give Rosalind time to change from 230 Book Reviews the boyish costume of Ganymede into the ampler habiliments of her own sex"; cf. A Study of the Drama 129. This subject has received no independent treatment since Hermann (1840), Richter (1842), and Beer (1844), and such an investigation was badly needed. Every reader of the later plays must feel and resent the artificiality and the absurdities which the current theory involves. Few would find solace in such suggestions as the following by Hermann: "The effect would be heightened still more when the spectator saw the same actor, who earlier in the play had been led forth to the tomb in the character of Antigone, return in the character of a Messenger to relate her death. Though the mask and dress were changed, the same voice and stature were perceptible in both, so that the spectator would feel that the ghost of Antigone was speaking through the mask of the Messenger" (p. 14). If Professor Rees's conclusions are accepted (as they inevitably must be in all essential particulars), we shall rest under no further necessity for such apologies. Finally, I would express the hope that these studies be con- tinued into the field of Roman comedy, which likewise has not for some time been thoroughly examined from this point of view and would certainly yield valuable, though probably less revolutionary, results. Roy C. Flickingee Northwestern University Demetrii et Libanii qui feruntur TTIIOI EIIISTOAIKOI et EniSTOAIMAIOI XAPAKTHPES. Edidit Valentintjs Weichert. Leipzig: Teubner, 1910. The appearance of Foerster's text of Libanius gives the signal for his pupils to produce the dissertations inspired by his life-long work in this field. Weichert's little book is not labeled a dissertation, and in form it appears as an addition to the texts of the Teubner Library. But it has all the earmarks of a dissertation, and on page lxxiv, in an addendum, its author has forgotten to remove the words haec dissertatio. The brief tract which has come down to us under the name of Demetrius of Phalerum discusses 21 types of letters. The writer, allowing for the increasing complexity of life, prophesies that time will give birth to many other such types, but asserts that he has personally met with only those on his list, a pathetic admission, since the love letter is not included. His examples of letters of introduction, condolence, congratulation, and the rest are as frigid as one would expect from an author whose first sentence takes up 13 lines of Teubner text. The most curious type is the allegorical, which corresponds remotely to the modern communication by code or cipher, though its real meaning seems to have been left to the intelligence of the unhappy recipient. Deme- trius offers certain epistolary problems of this sort, with their solutions.