STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 225 show the influence of the Roman development. Such contaminatio, Roden- waldt maintains, is due to the influence of Greek easel pictures, an influence that made itself felt as soon as the simple landscape developed into the landscape with figures and increased in importance as time went on. Having thus expounded his theory, Rodenwaldt next proceeds to an analy- sis of a great number of Pompeian wall paintings, with a view to showing how the Greek and the Roman elements were combined in the second, the third, and the fourth Pompeian styles and for different classes of subjects (chaps, iii-ix). The concluding chapter, "Ein griechisches Kompositions- prinzip," is an excursus on the principle of composition embodied in the Alexander mosaic and other works. Against the theory which is here advanced many objections can be urged. The evidence on which Rodenwaldt relies to determine the character of Hel- lenistic painting is not sufficient to establish his contention that the Greeks never advanced beyond a simple "Ausfullung der Flache" or the production of "einen engen biihnenartigen Raum"; he does not consider the possi- bility of the development in the post-Alexandrian period of an art of wall painting independent of the development of the easel picture; his interpre- tation of Vitruvius vii. 5. 1 f. (pp. 22 ff.) is less satisfactory than the older interpretation of Helbig and Woermann which makes antiqui (i.e., the painters of the Hellenistic period) the subject not only of imitati sunt but also of ingressi sunt; and many will hesitate to accept as Roman compositions the landscapes with scenes from the Odyssey and the paintings from the casa degli epigrammi with their Greek inscriptions. But whatever one may think of Rodenwaldt's theory, there can be no doubt as to the value of his analytical chapters. These are full of interesting comparisons and suggestions, not only in respect to the Pompeian paintings themselves, but also in respect to the Greek originals on which they are based; see, for instance, the remarks on the "Master of the Europa Picture" (pp. 69 ff., 85 ff., 108 ff.) and the proposed attributions to Timomachos or his school (p. 58) and to Nikias (p. 77). In these chapters the author displays a knowledge of his material which is at once comprehensive and intimate, and it is here that he has made his most important contribution to the study of the Pompeian wall paintings. This part of the book, at least, can be heartily recommended to all who desire more than a superficial knowledge of these important monuments of ancient art. George H. Chase Harvard University Scholia Vetera in Pindari Carmina. Recensuit A. B. Drachmann. Vol.11: Scholia in Pythionicas. Leipzig, 1910. Pp. xvi+270. M. 6. The first volume of this work, containing the scholia on the Olympians, was issued in 1903, before Classical Philology had begun publication. The 226 Book Reviews present notice will therefore include some account of the book as a whole, which is to be concluded with a third volume, containing the Nemean and Isthmian scholia. The scholia to Pindar are among the most important which we possess for any classical author, and are not only indispensable for the understanding of Pindar himself, but also are full of information concerning ancient history, myth, and religion. Indeed they have probably been studied quite as much for their bearing upon these more general subjects as for the light they throw upon the meaning of the most difficult, and yet most rewarding, of poets. A new edition of these scholia was very much needed, for the great work of Boeckh (1819) does not separate the scholia according to their manuscript sources, as indeed was scarcely possible with the scanty evidence at Boeckh's disposal. The edition of Abel (1884), and particularly of his successor (1891), is chiefly valuable as showing how such a work ought not to be done. The present work, prepared in close connection with Schroeder's masterly edition of the text of Pindar (1900), must form, with Schroeder's, the basis of all serious study of Pindar for many years to come. Drachmann's first volume has now been before the public so long that it is unnecessary to dwell upon the accuracy and fidelity with which he has performed his duty. The endless labor which he has spent upon the manuscript study of the scholia — the most difficult of all paleographical work — is amply rewarded, and he presents to the philological world, in these modest volumes, a masterpiece of solid but unpretentious scholarship. The Pythian scholia are but little more than half as voluminous, in proportion to the text, as the Olympian. The student will therefore not expect the fulness of explanation, or the variety of alternate interpretations, which was found in Vol. I. Yet even here he may choose between no less than four slightly different views of ktiXov 'A<£po&Tas (P. 2. 31), and similarly of to TrXovreiv 8e rifuai, rjo-lv on, in the note on P. 2. 113. But the emendations which Drachmann has adopted from his keen-sighted friend Schroeder far outnumber his own — evidence of a modesty as rare Book Reviews 227 as it is admirable. Though a considerable number of passages, as was inevitable, are still marked viz sanum, or sensu cassa, yet the scholia, in this new edition, read intelligibly for the most part. And since these scholia form the chief basis of all our knowledge of Pindar, we cannot be too grate- ful to Drachmann for the self-sacrificing labor which he has so devotedly, and at the same time so profitably, spent upon them. Edwaed Bull Clapp University of California The So-called Rule of Three Actors in the Classical Greek Drama. By Kelley Rees. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1908. Pp.86. $0.79. Professor Rees has amplified his dissertation by the following papers: "The Meaning of Parachoregema," CP II, 387 ff.; "The Number of the Dramatic Company in the Period of the Technitae," AJP XXXI, 43 ff.; and "The Three-Actor Rule in Menander," CP V, 291 ff. In the earliest period of tragedy but a single actor appeared upon the scene at a time; Aeschylus was the first to employ a two-actor scene; and Sophocles was the first to see the dramatic possibilities of the three-actor scene and to handle it with facility. This development is outlined in Aristotle's Poetics 1449a 15, and the aesthetic canon resulting therefrom is expressly stated in Horace's dictum: nee quarta loqui laboret (Ars Poet. 192). But the misinterpreta- tion of these passages and of a gloss in Hesychius (s.v. vip-ipis iwo/cpirw, which really refers to the manner of assigning protagonists to poets) has caused modern scholars to formulate the rule that ancient playwrights had only three actors at their disposal. An examination of the extant plays and of the new Menander fragments shows that for a variety of reasons three actors occasionally seem insufficient for presenting certain passages, that frequently r61es must be split (as in the Oed. Col, where, if only three actors were available, the part of Theseus must be carried by all three in turn) and that such splitting results in overloading, "lightning" changes of costume, and incongruous assortment of parts (e.g., the roles of Heracles and Deianeira in the Trachiniae must be performed by the same person). Furthermore, if we except the period of the Peloponnesian War and of the synchoregia in 406/5, there was no excuse for such thrift as all this would imply. On the other hand, it is likely that outside of Athens, in the period of the guilds (third and fourth centuries), such a restriction did obtain, and it would then naturally take its rise from the need of economy by the manager of a traveling troupe. Fortunately, four Soteric inscriptions for the years 272-269 b.c. are extant and in every case the dramatic troupes (twenty-two in all) consist of three actors. The controverted term -rrapaxopriyrnua belongs to the same period and has no connection with the choregic system. It is derived from x°pvyw i n its non-technical sense of "spend" and