STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 357 assemblies of women and the various occasions on which they gathered in public either voluntarily or at the call of a magistrate (cf. Livy xxvii. 37). These meetings, at first exceptional, gradually led to a permanent organiza- tion of women — the conventus matronarum, which under Heliogabalus took the form of a midierum senatus, recognized by the favor of the emperor as a public corporation vested with definite functions and provided with a build- ing of its own. Next (chap, iv) he indicates the steps by which women attained to civil freedom, mainly through changes in the forms of marriage and in the regulation of the dowry and the tutela. All these developments centered in the growth of individualism. In a final chapter the author glances at the tendencies in operation for the political emancipation of women. Though the work is altogether too brief to represent a real contribution to the social history of Rome, it cannot help being useful as a summary, which the author hopes to expand into a larger study. Undoubtedly there is a place for a considerable volume on the subject. G. W. Botsfobd Columbia University The Manuscript Tradition of the Historia Augusta. By Susan H. Ballou, Ph.D. Leipzig and Berlin: Teubner, 1914. M. 2.60, bound 4.80. Six years ago, Miss Ballou promised in this Journal (III, 273 ff.) to take up at greater length the MS problem presented by the Historia Augusta, in the new edition of which she is collaborating. Meanwhile Hohl, in Klio (XIII, 258 ff. and 387 ff.), has to a certain degree anticipated her. But since some of her conclusions differ considerably from Hohl's, she publishes this very detailed and painstaking study, which in general carries admiration and conviction. The Historia Augusta is preserved in a score of MSS; two — P, in the Vatican, and B, at Bamberg — date from the Caroline revival, the others from the Renaissance. A glance at the handsome facsimiles shows that P has the Fulda type of writing; and B, an insular MS, may also have been written at or near Fulda. P has been carefully corrected and emended by a half-dozen scribes, among whom Miss Ballou has recognized Petrarch himself; de Nolhac had already discovered that Paris 5816 is Petrarch's transcript of P. Coluccio. Poggio, Manetti and Bembo were also, she thinks, among the possessors of P. As certain Verona writers of the thir- teenth and early fourteenth centuries quote from the Historia Augusta, P may have been there till it came into Petrarch's hands. Miss Ballou tries to assign the corrections and changes in P to the proper emenders, and then to date the Renaissance copies by determining just which emended form of P they incorporate. She is least successful with 358 Book Reviews Vat. 1899 (pp. 58-59), which has several readings of P 1 which were com- pletely obliterated by a corrector earlier than Vat. 1899. To explain this, she thinks the scribe of Vat. 1899 had before him P (corrected by P 6 ), and in addition two early copies of P. It takes also considerable faith to believe that one and the same hand wrote the various scraps reproduced on the facsimiles as Petrarch's handwriting; but one familiar with Renaissance handwriting will feel only skepticism, not disbelief. In one of the three appendices, Miss Ballou considers the dependence of B upon P, now generally admitted; B has, however, some readings which prove to be independent. Could not B and P be copies of an almost contemporary x, as is the case with MSS V (Fulda) and M (Hersfeld) of Ammianus? M and V reproduce lacunae as conscientiously as do B and P; but it is clear neither is a copy of the other. One feels annoyed that a great house like Teubner should not even sew the sheets of a book appealing to an English-speaking public; we are used to pamphlets whose leaves will not immediately drop out; the long-suffering Teutons still put up with it. There are also too many misprints, even considering the difficulties offered the compositors by the language. C. U. Clark Yale University Historicorum Romanorum Reliquiae. Iteratis curis disposuit recensuit praefatus est Hermannus Peter. Vol.1. Leipzig: B. G. Teub- ner, 1914. Pp. x*+ccclxxx-|-382. M. 22. Forty-four years after the appearance of the first edition of this (first) volume, the veteran editor had completed his revision and had seen part of the book through the press when he was called away from his long labor. It is no small merit on his part that, whatever may have been the reason, he allowed so respectable a period to elapse between editions, a striking con- trast to the ordinary procedure in Germany of late. During this time an enormous amount of toil has been expended upon the microscopic examina- tion of the sources of Roman history and their relation to the later canonical versions. Much of this labor has been fruitless, except in a negative way, and while Peter has sifted its product carefully, he has refrained from burdening the reader conieduris iam oblivione obrutis (vi*), and his prin- cipal conclusions have been changed comparatively little. This in itself is a notable indication of the critical acumen and sanity of judgment of the first edition. The revision is thorough, and at least half the book, aside from the Frag- menta, has been rewritten, even where argument and conclusion are practi- cally the same in content, as in chap, iii of the Prolegomena. On the whole the style has been improved, although it is still far from being impeccable. Compare, if you will, the last sentence on p. cxvi in which seven of the first