STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 345 Horace and from Latin elegiac and erotic poetry, which are sometimes treated as conscious imitations. Students of the anthology will welcome this useful, if not definitive, monograph. Paul Shorey University of Chicago Olympiodorus fra Alexandria og Hans Commentar til Platons Phaidon. By William Norvin. Gyldendalske Boghandel: Kobenhavn og Kristiania, 1915. Pp. 345. Dr. Norvin, who edited the new Teubner text of Olympiodorus on the Phaedo, avails himself of the familiarity with his author thus acquired to write a book about him. Three hundred and forty-five pages of twentieth- century prose is a considerable gloss on 244 pages of sixth-century com- mentary on a single dialogue of Plato. But as Dr. Norvin points out, the neo-Platonic commentators in the mass represent an important movement of scholarship and thought. And his comprehensive study of the methods and ideas of Olympiodorus is a contribution to that complete and systematic interpretation of the whole school which is one of the chief tasks yet remain- ing for the historians of Greek philosophy. Dr. Norvin's clear, fluent, and copious exposition makes pleasant and easy reading for anyone at all interested in the subject. An introductory chapter describes the neo-Platonic exegesis generally with discriminating characterization of the schools of Alexandria and Athens. Chaps, ii-ix inclusive follow the commentary step by step, and, though entirely intelli- gible by themselves, could be critically read and estimated only with the text of Olympiodorus in hand. Dr. Norvin's analysis is in the main faithful and exact, and amply sufficient for his purpose — the elucidation of Olympio- dorus. He might perhaps have given a little more aid to the student who consults Olympiodorus only for assistance in the interpretation of the Phaedo. There is space for but one illustration — the well-known harmony passage, 93A f ., which is, I think, rarely if ever quite correctly interpreted. It is in fact a characteristically subtle Platonic argument from hypothesis. The unreality of the hypothesis, as Plato points out in Philebus 42E, does not in such cases invalidate the reasoning. // harmony admits of more or less, the soul as harmony would be more of a harmony when further harmonized by the indwelling harmony of virtue. It would then be more a soul, which is impossible. Therefore it is not a harmony. The hypothesis that the soul is a harmony is refuted by the absurdity of its consequences. The hypothesis or assumption that harmony admits of more or less is merely a means to the end. The impossibility that works the refutation here might, if the argu- ment had been differently turned, have been the impossibility of degrees in harmony, not in the soul. And so it is often taken. But Plato in fact works the argument the other way. Neither Burnet, whom Norvin apparently does 346 Book Reviews not know, nor Olympiodorus, nor Norvin quite follows the course of Plato's logic here. The caveat eiirep evSexerai tovto yiyv&rOai is merely Plato's warning to the reader that he is aware that the hypothesis is, from the point of view of strict musical science, impossible. Norvin's statement that Socrates is here taking harmony in the broader and looser sense, is perhaps near enough to the truth. But he seems to misapprehend the force of Olympiodorus' « p.r) apa when he says (p. 143): "Derimod skal der ikke i Sokrates' udtalelse ligge nogen henvisning til Aristoxenos' laere," etc. It is true historically of course that Socrates could not refer to Aristoxenos. But in the words ei jt>? "P a KaT °- T V V aZvOyrw Olympiodorus does not deny but attributes the idea to Plato as one possible explanation of his meaning. Of more general interest are chap, x on the plan and purpose of the com- mentary, chap, xi on its exegetical methods with an interesting sketch of the history of Platonic exegesis in antiquity, chaps, xii-xiv on psychology, metaphysics, and ethics, and the lucid resume 1 of the whole in chap. xv. The neo-Platonic commentators made some real contributions to psy- chology, the consideration of which would exceed the scope of a review. With the majority of historians, Dr. Norvin in my opinion overestimates Stoic influence on the evidence of the occasional employment of Stoic termi- nology. Like everybody else, he is inclined to assign to Aristotle or later writers ideas already distinctly presented by Plato. Thus on pp. 291-92 he makes Aristotle the source of Plotinus' distinction between the kind of phantasia that creates images out of sensation and that which clothes ideas and thoughts and hopes in images. But as I pointed out in Unity of Plato's Thought, n. 348, that distinction is clearly implied in Plato's Philebus 39C, which so surprised Grote. The word phantasia does not occur in 39C, but phantasmata is employed in 40A with reference to the same thought. In Binet, L' Intelligence, p. 73, essentially the same thought appears as the latest result of scientific laboratory experiments on the psychology of young girls. Dr. Norvin also once or twice in my opinion slips into the very common error of pressing the specific technical meaning of Sidvoia in passages where it is probably used only in the broader meaning of mind as opposed to body or sense; cf. Classical Philology, V, 221. On p. 290, for example, in the phrase obs rrjs dA.?j0oSs Suauewrpayuxs iv rrj Siavoia laraftenjs, "i den dis- cursive taenkning" overinterprets Suxvota, which here means only the "mind" or at most the "intention." And on p. 298 the phrase ol Si fiaOv- repot. rjjv Stovoiav should not be pressed to support the statement in the text (true enough in itself), "den discursive taenkning gaar altsaa ud paa at bringe begreberne til bevidsthed i sterst mulig klarhed og renhed." The word bevidsthed again illustrates the delicacy of these inquiries. The modern term "consciousness" is sometimes used to translate a dozen Greek expres- sions, some of which more or less directly connote consciousness, but few of which are free from other suggestions. For this reason the Greek text should always be quoted when "consciousness" is used in its interpretation. Book Reviews 347 But to dwell further on such refinements would give a false impression of an excellent and helpful piece of work for which every student of later Greek philosophy will thank the author. Paul Shorey University op Chicago P. Ovidi Nasonis Tristia, Epistulae ex Ponto, Halieutica, Fragmenta. Recognovit brevique adnotatione critica instruxit S. G. Owen. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1915. 3s.; india paper, 4s. Qd. Users of Mr. Owen's Oxford text of Persius and Juvenal will welcome from his hand the initial volume of Ovid in the series, containing the poems written in exile — Tristia, Ibis (why omitted in the title?), Epistulae ex Ponto, and Halieutica — together with some five pages of fragments. By way of preface Mr. Owen supplements a brief but comprehensive account of the manuscript tradition with some notice of recent monographs. A rather more than usually full and suggestive apparatus supports the care- fully conservative text. The fragmentary Halieutica — the genuineness of which Mr. Owen follows recent criticism in sustaining — is conveniently illustrated by the printing in full of Pliny's detailed notice. The serviceable- ness of the concluding index nominum is increased by inclusion of indirect references as well as of express mentions — a feature especially useful in the case of so allusive an author as Ovid. As regards type work and general makeup, the book sustains fully the standard of the series. Read Pannonia (Frr. fin.). Amherst College H. W. Litchfield Greek Sculpture and Modern Art. By Sib Charles Waldstein. Cambridge: University Press, 1914. Pp. 67; 78 plates. The book consists of two short lectures addressed to technical students of the Royal Academy, one on "The Technique," the other on "The Subject Matter of Art," abundantly illustrated with seventy-eight plates gathered in the second and larger part of the volume, with extenuating explanations in the preface and the appendix. And for such students no better brief introduction to Greek sculpture could well be devised. Even the common- places of criticism with which the book abounds may be justified on the ground that discriminating and emphatic mention of them by an authority of the author's distinction may be of considerable profit to those to whom they are addressed. Most people will find some of it hortatory and negligible, and much of the analysis still too transcendental. Sir Charles Waldstein reads artistic results too frequently from the outside.