STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 344 Book Reviews day. Thus Boll is in essential agreement with the religionsgeschichtliche Schick of interpretation, although he differs from certain well-known repre- sentatives of the school when he connects Revelation genetically with con- temporary Hellenicism instead of looking to distant Babylonia for the sources of the apocalyptist's fanciful pictures. This undoubtedly is a step in the right direction, but the problem needs much more thorough treatment than it receives in this monograph. The syncretism of Revelation is far too complex to be defined in terms of any single factor. Contemporary astral notions certainly did form one of its constituent elements, but it contained much more than these — more indeeed that was of truly Hellenistic origin. For example, its proposed disposal of the persecuting emperor and his followers shows a considerable admixture of Orphic imagery, not to mention numerous Jewish features and certain new ventures of the imagination on the part of Christians. Unless the reader keeps in mind this larger task, this brochure may easily lead to an overestimate of the astrological elements in Revelation. This is a danger which Boll himself has not always succeeded in avoiding. Shirley Jackson Case University op Chicago Bibliotheca di Filologia Classica. Paolo Silenziario. By Alessandro Venieeo. Catania: Francesco Battiato, 1916. Pp. vii+368. The author, prosecuting the eterno lavoro of a translation of the entire anthology, was unable to find a monograph which would satisfy his curiosity about Paulus Silentiarius. He accordingly collected a library (catalogued in his appended bibliography) and made one. It consists of a readable introduction on the life of Paulus, on the age of Justinian in relation to literature, and on the epigrammatists of the sixth century, followed by an Italian translation of all the extant epigrams and the description of St. Sophia, etc., with critical and exegetical notes on the Greek text, which is not reprinted. The translation follows the original closely and is, so far as I have tested it, correct. Its literary quality I do not presume to estimate. The meter is apparently the elegiac of the original. I cannot "scan" it, nor can I scan Carducci's Alcaics. Does this indicate a fundamental differ- ence in the rhythmic sense of the modern Italian classicist, or does he aim only at reproducing the general effect of ancient meters? The apparent impossibility of obtaining an intelligible answer to this simple question is one of many minor obstacles to the cosmopolitanization of culture. It will not worry the "verse libertines." The commentary is a convenient compilation of the notes of Jacobs, Brunck, Dubner, Stadtmuller, Sternbach, Mallet, and Gollnisch, with addi- tions from the author's own reading. There are many parallels from Book Reviews 345 Horace and from Latin elegiac and erotic poetry, which are sometimes treated as conscious imitations. Students of the anthology will welcome this useful, if not definitive, monograph. Paul Shorey University of Chicago Olympiodorus fra Alexandria og Hans Commentar til Platons Phaidon. By William Norvin. Gyldendalske Boghandel: Kobenhavn og Kristiania, 1915. Pp. 345. Dr. Norvin, who edited the new Teubner text of Olympiodorus on the Phaedo, avails himself of the familiarity with his author thus acquired to write a book about him. Three hundred and forty-five pages of twentieth- century prose is a considerable gloss on 244 pages of sixth-century com- mentary on a single dialogue of Plato. But as Dr. Norvin points out, the neo-Platonic commentators in the mass represent an important movement of scholarship and thought. And his comprehensive study of the methods and ideas of Olympiodorus is a contribution to that complete and systematic interpretation of the whole school which is one of the chief tasks yet remain- ing for the historians of Greek philosophy. Dr. Norvin's clear, fluent, and copious exposition makes pleasant and easy reading for anyone at all interested in the subject. An introductory chapter describes the neo-Platonic exegesis generally with discriminating characterization of the schools of Alexandria and Athens. Chaps, ii-ix inclusive follow the commentary step by step, and, though entirely intelli- gible by themselves, could be critically read and estimated only with the text of Olympiodorus in hand. Dr. Norvin's analysis is in the main faithful and exact, and amply sufficient for his purpose — the elucidation of Olympio- dorus. He might perhaps have given a little more aid to the student who consults Olympiodorus only for assistance in the interpretation of the Phaedo. There is space for but one illustration — the well-known harmony passage, 93A f ., which is, I think, rarely if ever quite correctly interpreted. It is in fact a characteristically subtle Platonic argument from hypothesis. The unreality of the hypothesis, as Plato points out in Philebus 42E, does not in such cases invalidate the reasoning. // harmony admits of more or less, the soul as harmony would be more of a harmony when further harmonized by the indwelling harmony of virtue. It would then be more a soul, which is impossible. Therefore it is not a harmony. The hypothesis that the soul is a harmony is refuted by the absurdity of its consequences. The hypothesis or assumption that harmony admits of more or less is merely a means to the end. The impossibility that works the refutation here might, if the argu- ment had been differently turned, have been the impossibility of degrees in harmony, not in the soul. And so it is often taken. But Plato in fact works the argument the other way. Neither Burnet, whom Norvin apparently does