STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. BOOK REVIEWS The Acharnians of Aristophanes. Edited from the MSS and Other Original Sources by Richard Thomas Elliott. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1914. Pp. xliv+241. The Acharnians has fared well of late at the hands of British scholars: three editions of the play appeared within the space of five years, beginning with the excellent edition by Dr. Starkie in 1909. Unlike the others, the present work is strictly a critical edition of the text; for it the editor per- sonally examined and collated all the fourteen manuscripts of the Acharnians in their respective libraries. "I may point out," he says, "that this is the only edition of a play of Aristophanes in which an editor has made verbatim collations of so many manuscripts; the largest number fully collated hitherto for a play of Aristophanes has been six by von Velsen for the Equites and six by several scholars for Zacher's edition of the Pax. Of the Acharnians no previous editor has made a full collation of even one manuscript from the original." To show the completeness and superiority of his record of the readings of the manuscripts, he prints side by side for comparison the critical apparatus for twenty lines of the Acharnians from his own edition and from that of Dr. Starkie. Further evidence for the text he has gathered from the abundant quotations from the play that occur in the scholia, Athenaeus, Suidas, and other later writers, many of them antedating our earliest manu- script. These quotations and the papyrus fragments from Hermupolis which are five centuries older than the Ravennas tend to strengthen a belief in the value and trustworthiness of the archetype of the extant manuscripts, which editors and critics, notably von Velsen, have hitherto underrated. Deprecating the multitude of conjectures that have found their way into the text, he offers but twelve of his own, eight of which he adopts in his text. None of these is particularly attractive, and some are poor, e.g., ovk SXai (1093), fier' 8X-qv (1095), and his conjecture in 645 which neglects the diaeresis no less than the reading of the manuscripts does. "But the main object of my present edition," he says, "has not been to make emendations, but to give as accurately as possible, and in a fuller form than has been hitherto available, the evidence of the text of the Acharnians still surviving in the fourteen manuscripts (so far as necessary), the Aldine, the papyrus frag- ments, the scholia, and the numerous quotations and references in other Greek and Latin writers." In his Introduction Mr. Elliott sets forth his opinions as to the relations which the manuscripts in question sustain to one another, his conclusions 342 Book Reviews 343 agreeing in the main with those of Dr. Cary in his article "The Manuscript Tradition of the Acharnenses," 1907. The dates of some of them he puts a century earlier than is customary. He adopts the symbols proposed by Professor J. W. White in the first volume of Classical Philology as desig- nations of the manuscripts of Aristophanes, as did Dr. Starkie also; and from the same article he borrows the statement of the exact contents of each of the fourteen manuscripts. Three excursuses conclude the volume: "Athenaeus' Text of Aristophanes" is a careful study of Athenaeus' quota- tions from Aristophanes with a view to showing their great importance for the establishment of the text of the comic poet; the second excursus is a reprint of the papyrus fragments of the Acharnians found in the excavations at Hermupolis; and the last is a scholarly discussion of the "Greek Dialects in Aristophanes." Repetitions occur often; one that is particularly annoying by reason of its frequency is the statement of the divergent opinions as to the number of manuscripts of Aristophanes in Italian libraries. Despite some crudities here and there, the work is by its very nature exceedingly valuable, and justifies the immense amount of time and labor expended on its production. Charles W. Peppler Trinity College, Durham, N.C. Aus der Offenbarung Johannis. Hellenistische Studien zum WeltbiU der Apokalypse. By Franz Boll. Leipzig und Berlin : Teub- ner, 1914. Pp. viii+151. M. 5. The Book of Revelation has suffered many things of many interpreters. The fantastic imagery of the book invites free speculation regarding both its meaning and the sources which inspired the author's fancy. Boll is concerned with the second of these topics, and proceeds to show that the author derived his imagery in large measure from the astral notions current in his Hellenistic environment. The treatment is selective rather than comprehensive. A detailed study of the Apocalypse as a whole is not attempted, nor are selected passages discussed exhaustively. Attention is centered upon those portions of the book where astrological inheritances are thought to be most in evidence. The method of Hellenistic apocalyptic, the general picture of the world as viewed by the writer of Revelation, and especially his notions about the astral regions are described briefly. Then follows a more thorough exam- ination of selected passages. These are: (1) the vision of the bowls and trumpets (chaps. 8 and 16); (2) the first woe (9:1-12); (3) the apocalyptic horseman (chap. 6); (4) the queen of heaven (chap. 12). In each instance astral mythology of Hellenistic times is found to have furnished the author the chief materials for his composition. He was no mere copyist, or mechani- cal borrower, but a real author who had absorbed the popular notions of the