STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 222 Book Reviews as Cicero complains, modesty prevents him from giving due emphasis to his virtues and vanity, from being frank about his faults. A new impulse was given to self -analysis in the Hellenistic period. The solidarity of the city-state was broken up and with the consequent relaxing of the ties that bound the individual to the political organism, his interest turned more and more upon himself. This was accentuated by philosophy. The stoic faith carried Socrates' interpretation of yvwffi (Ttavrov to its logical conclusion by insisting that freedom of the soul comes only through a knowledge of its powers and limitations, and that only through self-examination could a man attain to the divine. The characteristic product of these influences is the book of meditations which Marcus Aurelius addressed to himself. But we do not yet have autobiography in the proper sense. The motive of self -justification and the desire for good fame remain too strong. It is only with the Christian glorification of the divine through the abasement of the human, the confession of weakness as a means of grace, that self -biography assumes a frank attitude toward human experience. "If I needs must glory," said Saint Paul, "I will glory in the things which concern mine infirmities." This new religious ideal entering the ancient world inspired a great number of mystic meditations of which the most significant and typical are the lyrics of Gregory Nazianzen and the Confessions of Saint Augustine. This will indicate in outline the attempt of the author to unify his material. The book deals also with examples of self -portrayal and self- expression not of a formal autobiographical character, but is by no means an exhaustive treatment of the subject. The discussion of individual authors is clear and readable, but a superabundance of ponderous psycho- logical and philosophical generalization produces an effect, as a French reviewer feelingly remarks, terriblement germanique. George Noelin University of Colorado Anthropology and the Classics. Six Lectures delivered before the University of Oxford by Aethue J. Evans, Andeew Lang, Gilbebt Mueeay, F. B. Jevons, J. L. Myees, and W. Waede Fowlee. Edited by R. R. Mabett. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1908. Pp. 191. $2.00. Six experts would be needed to review critically this volume of lectures by six masters. Mr. Arthur Evans prefaces his forthcoming book Scripta Minoa by discoursing with great wealth of illustration on "the European diffusion of pictography and its bearings on the origin of Script." He does not go so far as does M. Piette who discerns actual Book Reviews 223 letters in the markings on the pebbles in the Cave of Mas d' Azil. But the vast array of facts which he marshals prepares us to accept his thesis that the Minoans had already crossed the line which divides pictorial symbolism from syllabary and alphabet. We have moved far indeed from the Wolfian interpretation of 0-17/xara Xvypd. Mr. Andrew Lang finding little anthropology and less "Beastly Devices of Ye Heathen " in the pure and serene poetry of Homer, gives us what is better — a lucid restatement of the main argument of his recent book Homer and His Age. Homer presents a consistent picture of a sub-Minoan civilization that no archaizing poet or committee of poets could have achieved, even if primitive poets archaized — which they didn't. His essential unity is sufficiently demonstrated by the typical truth of his description of loose early feudalism under a Charlemagne — Agamemnon overlord. His disdainful reticences cannot be explained as the result of expurgation. Why was not Hesiod expurgated ? One or two seals found in Crete and depicted on p. 57 free us from the grotesque fancy of naked Minoan warriors, and prove, Mr. Lang thinks, that cuirass, zoster, and mitre' were known before Homer. Mr. Gilbert Murray finds no lack of anthropological material in "The Greek Epic Literature outside Homer." Homer, he repeats in answer to Mr. Lang and in confirmation of his own Rise of the Greek Epic, Homer was expurgated because the Iliad and the Odyssey "were selected at some early time for public recitation at the solemn four-yearly meeting of all Ionians and afterward of all Athenians. But if the "intellect of Greece focused" upon Homer purified the epics of all allusion to sin against nature, for example, how, we ask, did it come to tolerate the recitation of the Myrmidons of Aeschylus in the fierce light that beat upon the Attic stage? After these preliminaries Mr. Murray becomes severely anthropological, and shows that Dionysus was a Dukduk or Egbo or Mumbo-jumbo, that the divine king is the Medicine king, that 0eos originally meant magic or medicine, that Zeus is the thunderstone which Gaia gives to Kronos to swallow in his stead, and that "all through this pre-Hellenic realm of saga and half-history we find ourselves in contact with these god-kings or medicine-chiefs." In his lecture on " Graeco-Italian Magic " Mr. Jevons ably resumes recent literature on incantations, spells, deflxiones, mala carmina, and the like. In "Herodotus and Anthropology" Mr. Myres deals not with the stores of anthropological data collected by the father of history, but with the philosophical and anthropological preconceptions which their collec- tion and form of statement imply. "If Herodotus was not in advance of his age, then his age was abreast of Herodotus." This is the line of inquiry pursued by Dummler in his Prolegomena zu Platon's Staat, to whom Mr. Myres does not refer, and more recently by Nestle in a "Programm " 224 Book Reviews on Herodotus' " Verhaltniss zur Philosophie und Sophistik." Mr. Myres finds already a standard scheme of archaeology in Hesiod's ages of gold, silver, and bronze, and he reads startling anticipations of evolu- tion into the well-known fragments of Anaximander and Archelaus. He sometimes, as is inevitable in a quest of this kind, finds too much, as when he translates yo/etns e| dXX^Xiov (in Archelaus) by "interbreeding," or when he contrasts Herodotus' four criteria, community of descent, language, religion, and customs, with the "less-advanced method of inquiry" pursued in Aeschylus Supplices 287, 288. But as a whole he illustrates in most instructive fashion from Herodotus himself, from the Hippocratean writings, from the drama, and from the fragments of fifth- century literature generally the spirit of rationalistic anthropological curiosity in which the " histories " were composed. An interesting and scholarly study of Lustratio by Mr. W. W. Fowler concludes a volume which no student of the life and thought of antiquity can afford to leave unread. Paul Shokey Adonis, Attis, Osiris: Studies in the History of Oriental Religion. By J. G. Feazee. New York: The Macmillan Co., 1907. 2d ed. Pp. xix+452. Only a year's interval falls between the first and second editions of this book in which Dr. Frazer gives us the first instalment of the third edition of The Golden Bough. Although the studies here contained are in a sense expansions of the corresponding sections in the earlier work, the greater part of the matter is new, and in the second edition of this instalment there have been added a chapter on " Sacred Men and Women," a new section on "Influence of Mother-kin on Religion," and three new appendices : " Moloch the King," " The Widowed Flamen," and Some Cus- toms of the Pelew Islanders." In discussing the worship of Adonis, Attis, and Osiris much more attention has been given than before to the physical environment in which these worships originated and to the effect of that environment on them. To say that this book is interesting to every student of religion would be a weak expression; while the volume contains much that is not new or unknown, and although few readers will be able to go the whole way with the author along the uncertain roads of mother-right and early kingship, or accept many of his conclu- sions, none the less the value of this store of learning is not seriously lessened by these facts, and the present reviewer cannot refrain from expressing his admiration for the varied knowledge, the capacity for unremitting and fruitful toil, and the ability to present his views in lucid and alluring form which the author of The Golden Bough and Pausanias exhibits.