STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 212 Book Reviews In handling such a mass of material errors were unavoidable. A few slips may be noted. The cutting in the rock for the base of the " Athena Promachus" is not "thirty feet from the Propylaea" (p. 139) but more than as many meters. That " the eastern wall [of the Acropolis] seems to have been entirely rebuilt on the old foundations in the Middle Ages " (p. 141) is doubtful. The modern marble quarries, not the ancient, are visible from Athens (p. 163). Northtoesi and southeast should of course be read (p. 229, second line from bottom) for northeast and southwest, and Stevens for "Stevenson" (pp. 227 and 282), for the architect who discovered so cleverly the windows in the east front of the Erechtheum. The commentary is almost wholly archaeological and is as full as space permits. One note (p. 40) amounts to a publication of news and deserves quotation: "Dr. Dorpfeld writes me under date of January 19, 1908, that the excavations of the Greeks on the east slope of the Theseum hill have laid bare a building with an apse, possibly the Royal Colon- nade. The building formerly identified by Dorpfeld (A. M. XXI. 102 ff.; XXII. 225 ff .) as the Royal Colonnade he now thinks did not belong to the market, but was the last building before the 'Ceramicus' of Pausanias." The brevity of this book and the complexity of the subject demand that the teacher shall supplement it with an abundance of illustrative material, only a little of which is furnished in the volume. Indeed the comparative unimportance of the topography of Megara and of Attica outside of Athens might have made it seem justifiable to omit these entirely, together with Pausanias' tedious excursuses, and to add more copious illustration — even if this be heterodox. But the publication was worth making and Dr. Carroll has written a useful book. Charles Heald Weller Iowa City, Iowa Der neue Menander. Bemerkungen zur Rekonstruktion der Stftcke nebst dem Text in der Seitenverteilung der Hand- schrift von Carl Robert. Berlin: Weidmannsche Buch- handlung, 1908. Pp. 145. M. 4.50. Szenen cms Menanders Komoedien. Deutsch von Carl Robert. Berlin: Weidmannsche Buchhandlung, 1908. Pp. 130. The new inspection of the papyrus by Korte (Berichte iiber d. Verh. d. s&chsischen Oesellschaft d. Wissensch. zu Leipzig LX [1908] 87-141) and Korte's account of the two new fragments discovered by Zucker (ibid. 145-75), in which are included vss. 71-118 of the HepiKapo/xevr} in a better text, show how mistaken was the attempt to reconstruct the pagination of the Cairo MS, and how ambitious Robert's disentangling Book Reviews 213 of the plots of the newly discovered plays. The edition of the text, to realize the editor's theory (pp. 22-28), exhibits many pages that are blank save for the scene-headings, which Robert supplies in accordance with his theory of the action of the plays. The theory of pagination is demolished by Korte's two reports (loc. cit. 89 ff., 92, 93, 114, 131, 132, 133, 134, 159, and especially 174 ff.). The reconstruction of the plots (pp. 1-21) is the product of a vivid imagination that often refuses to be controlled by facts in the text or in available subsidiary sources. We seek in vain for evidence of a wise conservatism, of a rational discrimination between fact and fancy, obvious truth and dubious hypothesis. In the Im/xia Tryphe is said to be the wife of Nikeratos, Laches is said to be a parasite: but is there any like- lihood that such a name as Tryphe, properly belonging to a meretrix or at best to a slave (cf. Aelian Epist. rust. 11, 12; Anth. Pal. v. 154, 185,.vii. 222: Tpu<^epa), would be applied to the wife of a free citizen? and where in extant Greek or Roman 1 comedy is a parasite ever dubbed Laches ? On the contrary how often it appears as the name of a free citizen (e. g., Arist. Vesp. 240, Lys. 303; Terence Hecyra, passim)\ The decisive question in the IlepiKtipojuei/j;, we are told, is: where did Glykera go when she left Polemon? This question Robert answers by considering the action : in 145 ff. (342 ff.), he says, a band of drunken revelers come to the house from which Glykera is taken; but all that we find, on referring to the text, is that the speaker (whose position on the stage is not dis- coverable) says a company of drunken revelers irpoo-tpxerat, which can only mean "comes toward" the speaker without reference to any house at all; but on this Robert begins to build a theory that it is a house of ill repute from which Glykera is taken. Not even the phrase to (W™x«s otiuoW tovto in 273 (470) supports this theory (which may be true without any evidence to support it!), for it depends on the speaker and his mood whether a 8uoti>x« otiet&ov is a brothel or a marble palace; in this case the speaker is Polemon's slave, and his master's interests may have blurred his vision. Such criticism may seem captious, but when we are dealing with fragments, and fragments that have not been thoroughly edited, a non intellegitur is more helpful to other scholars than an unsupported conjecture. Our author is not altogether culpable if he finds confirmation of a theory (p. 15) in a solitary "C d. i. [CQ]C [tas]" in the margin at 250 (447), although Korte has since reported (loc. cit. 105): "der Schluss der Szene ist durch einen Schnorkel am linken Rande angedeutet, der alien- falls mit Abkiirzungsstrich, aber nicht C sein kdnnte; . . . ." We might forgive the editor for creating a Thraso out of an embryonic . . . o-w in 283 (480) where Korte (loc. cit. 109) has found an or Q before the . . . (no, or even for making Philinos and Sosias the speakers in 257 ff (454 ff.), since he did not know of the TTO in the margin at 256 (453) (Korte loc. cit. 105 ff.). But it is harder to forgive the ascription of 145 ff 214 Book Reviews (342 ff.) to Philinos when kekt^eVjjv 146 (343) and 6 rpd^i/xos 149 (345) point clearly to a slave as the speaker, and that slave apparently Daos. Attempts to fill the larger gaps in the lines of the fragments seldom serve any more valuable purpose than to indicate an editor's understand- ing of the action. Robert's SeVa raXavra in the mutilated passage, Ilept- Ko.pofji€vr] 166 ff. (363 ff .), receives no confirmation from Korte's readings. There is, on the whole, more profitable work to be found in using what we have than in stopping gaps, however ingeniously, with phrases that simply represent presuppositions as to the plot of the play. It is inevitable, however, that this fragmentary literature should tempt the imagination, and here and there the editor's intuition may have led him to the right issue. In matters archaeological Robert is an acknowl- edged authority, and we look forward with interest to the elaboration of his discovery that three plays of the Cairo papyrus are illustrated in three scenes from a frieze of the Casa del centennaio ("Mon. d. Inst. XI, tav. xxx-xxxii"). The translation is of interest to scholars only in so far as it serves to interpret the text. The text, however, represents the editor's later views, and in many respects deviates from the interpretation offered in the translation. These deviations are noted on the last page of the edition of the text. Henbt W. Pbesoott University op California Catulli Veronensis Liber. Erklaert von Gustav Friedrich. Leipzig: Teubner, 1908. Pp. 560. M. 12. This latest addition to Teubner's Sammlung wissenschaftlicher Kommentare contains a text of Catullus as well as a commentary upon it. No apparatus criticus is appended, but many readings are discussed critically in the notes. The principles on which the editor has constituted the text are set forth in a brief preface. He believes, with K. P. Schulze, that O and Gr are both direct copies of the lost Veronensis, and preserve the best tradition of the text ; but the correc- tions of G (g), and the remaining MSS, go back to a third (lost) copy of Veronensis, and yet a fourth is represented by Datanus. The Venice MS published in facsimile by Costantino Nigra is, however, according to Friedrich, of no such marked value as Schulze attributed to it, being, indeed, no better than the common ruck of MSS other than OGD. But even so it is better, declares the editor, than the codex Romanus of Pro- fessor Hale, which furnishes not a thing for the constitution of the text. He even challenges Professor Hale to produce a single passage of Catul- lus bettered einwandsfrei by the aid of codex R. It may be remarked in passing that it appears to be a somewhat curious critical standpoint