STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 360 Book Keviews Der Enoplios. Ein Beitrag zur griechischen Metrik. Von. De. E. Herkeneath. Leipzig: Teubner, 1906. Pp. ix. -f 186. M. 6. The extraordinary industry and ingenuity bestowed upon this book make it, in accordance with the author's hope, a valuable repertory of metrical facts, even for those who cannot accept all of its conclusions. Starting from two forms of the Enoplios — Archilochus' 'Epao/ton'S); XapiXat and Cratinus' 'Epatr/tovt'S); BdOunrt which he proves to be equivalent by col- lecting all cases of their responsion— Dr. Herkenrath analyzes the entire body of extant Greek lyric and choric verse in order to establish two con- clusions : (1) That Greek poetry allowed great freedom of equivalence and responsion, or, as he puts it, that the difference between a dissyllabic and a monosyllabic arsis (Senkung) concerns Bhythmik only, not Metrik. (2) That Greek lyric verses and strophes are largely composed of variations, extensions, curtailments, and combinations of a few favorite clauses or movements such as the Enoplios, the ithyphallic, the dochmiac, the Teles- illeion, the Praxilleion, the Eeizianum. The first conclusion is a priori probable and is apparently confirmed by the unamended (or rightly amended I) tradition of the texts. There is no reason except convention or rjOos for precise syllabic responsion in any poetry. The extent to which it may have been required by the tradition of a particular poetical form or the practice of a particular poet, is a question of special historical philology rather than of pure Metrik. Such freedoms of responsion as occur are as readily explained by the methods of Rossbach or Christ as by the new fashion of scanning by quadrisyl- lable or larger groups. They are no argument for either system. The second proposition is also true in the general statement (p. 167) "dass sich im Strophenbau gewisse Gewohnheiten erkennen lassen." But in the application it is liable to degenerate into a mere metrico-mathe- matical schematism bearing no relation to actual rhythmic utterance. There is obviously no limit to the combinations which may be made if we may assume thirty-two forms of the " Enoplios " (Schroeder), substi- tute dactyls in the ithyphallic, call - - - | - - - a Telesilleion (p, 13), _~~_~~_a dochmiac, and — _ ^ _ ~ _ a Glyconic (pp. 17 ff.). But all metrical analogies and "Gewohnheiten" discovered by these purely schematic methods, must be verified by rhythmical considerations. I do not doubt that some of Dr. Herkenrath's groupings are valid rhythmically, and that he has satisfied his own ear of the validity of them all. But like others of the "New School," he assumes that the mere metrical analysis will be sufficient to convince his readers. It will not. To take a test case: His method leads him (p. 19) to establish an elaborate parallel between Eurip. Herakles 638 ff., and the "ganz ahnliches Lied," Aeschyl. Ag. 681 ff. Now these two odes may be like in terms of "gl. B," "gl. X," Book Reviews 361 "gl. + en B," "en B + Reiz," etc. They are not in the least "like" in actual viva voce rhythmic reading. And there is something wrong in a system that identifies them. Dr. Herkenrath would probably not deny that similar or identical metrical groups may have a totally different rhythmical value in different contexts. But in the interest of working out his system he appears to forget it. The valuable index is at first sight difficult to use owing to a number of arbitrary but ingenious abbreviations which when understood serve to present an enormous amount of information in brief compass. Paul Shobet Grammatik der griechischen Papyri aus der Ptolemderzeit. Mit Einschluss der gleichzeitigen Ostraka und der in Agypten verfassten Inschriften. Laut- und Wortlehre. Von Dr. Edwin Mayseb. Leipzig: Teubner, 1906. M. 14. I undertake to notice briefly this book not as a specialist in the field of papyri literature, but as one of that larger number who have a keen interest in the history of the Greek koivtj, and wish to survey the important facts to be gleaned from the papyri, without attempting to follow in detail the formidable and ever-increasing mass of papyri pub- lications. For all such this grammar of the papyri of the Ptolemaic period must be reckoned a most welcome and invaluable aid. It furnishes an exhaustive and orderly exhibit of the facts so far as they fall under the heads of Lautlehre and Wortlehre, the latter including Flexion and Stammbildung. In the introduction and under Stammbildung are also mentioned many peculiarities of vocabulary, words otherwise poetical or dialectic, new words, and new or unusual meanings. The Syntax is, we assume, reserved for a subsequent volume. The printing and general execution of the work are excellent but for one fault which it shares with too many other, especially German, publications. The numbered sections are long, with numerous subdivisions, sometimes covering a half-dozen pages or more, and the resulting inconvenience in looking up the cross- references is not even mitigated by repeating the section numbers at the top of each page. On the general question of the source of the koivtj, the author's inves- tigation has led him to the same position as that held by Thumb and the majority of the scholars at present, namely that it is a modified Attic. But he thinks Thumb has erred in seeking connection with the most vulgar type of colloquial Attic, as represented in the vase inscriptions. Certainly it was not this, but the Attic of literature and more cultivated speech, which set the standard. With its spread this was more and more affected by colloquial usage, not pre-eminently that of Athens, but by that of various parts of the Greek world. As regards the traces of the