STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Keviews 355 Topographie der Stadt Bom in Alterthum. Von H. Jordan. Erster Band, dritte Abtheilung, bearbeitet von Ch. Hlllsen. Berlin: Weidmann, 1907. Pp. xxiv + 709. M. 16. When Jordan died in 1887, the completion of his famous work was intrusted to Htllsen who had just been appointed second secretary of the German Institute at Rome. His briUiant success as an epigraphist and topographer during the twenty years that have since elapsed is familiar to all students, and the long delay in the appearance of this book is easily explained when one considers the manifold duties and activities of the author and the constantly increasing additions to our knowledge of the subject, no small share of which is due to Hlllsen himself. The delay due to the latter cause is shown by the fact that, while the printing began in 1901 and advance sheets of more than two hundred pages were in my hands in 1903, the book has only just appeared. The material left by Jordan was neither suflBcient nor suitable for the completion of his work, and Hulsen therefore determined to pursue his own method independently, so that the present volume is entirely his. It contains the detailed description and discussion of the topography and monuments of Rome except those that had been so treated by Jordan himself, namely the Forum, the imperial fora, the Forum Boarium and the Velabrum, the bridges and the aqueducts. With Lanciani's Forma Urbis Romae, it represents the most important contribution to the sub- ject that has been made for a generation, and presents the views of the most authoritative of Roman topographers, based upon his own investiga- tions. Nothing strikes the reader so forcibly as the fact that nothing has been taken on another's authority. All the sources seem to have been worked over anew, and the amount of labor involved can be appreciated only by those to whom the field is somewhat familiar. Furthermore, the sources are far more extensive than in Jordan's day, for Hulsen and Lan- ciani have been foremost in recognizing the amount and value of the information with regard to the monuments of Rome contained in the material of various sorts which has been left us by the architects and artists of the Renaissance and later centuries. This material has already led to the solution of several problems. It is impossible here to enter into any criticism in detail of the many new and interesting views advanced in this book, and I will content my- self with noting a few of those that have to do with the topography of the southern and central portion of the Campus Martins. In the Notitia is mentioned a Crypta Balbi which was naturally connected with the theatre of Balbus. In the via Calderari, immediately northwest of the theatre, remains of a two-storied structure existed in the sixteenth century which were identified with this Crypta. A few ruins still stand, but from the drawings and descriptions of Serlio and Bellori it appears that the 356 Book Reviews structure was open on all sides and consisted of colonnades and inner walls with niches, and interior rooms apparently without entrances. This seemed to justify the name, and the position close to the stage end of the theatre seemed to suggest its purpose. The building is indi- cated on a fragment of the Marble Plan but without name, and of course there was no certainty that it was the Crypta, although topographers have accepted Bellori's identification without question. Htilsen, however, on the strength of the ordinary use of crypta which means a closed and more or less subterranean structure, refuses to accept the current view, and identifies the ruins with the porticus Minucia vetus, a restoration by Domitian of the porticus Minucia of 110 b. c. This porticus is mentioned in the Begionary Catalogue next to the porticus Philippi, and therefore Hiilsen maintains that its usual location near the piazza Montanara must be given up. Furthermore, the calendars seem to show that games in honor of Hercules Gustos were celebrated near the porticus Minucia, and the transfer of this building necessitates a change in the location of the temple. Heretofore it has been supposed to have stood at the east end of the circus Plaminius, but Hiilsen places it at the west end. Since Ovid speaks of the temple of Bellona as standing on the opposite side of the circus from the temple of Hercules Gustos, the temple of this goddess also must be changed from the position hitherto assigned it at the north end of the circus to the east side. Thus the arrangement of the district about the circus Plaminius is materially altered. A little to the north, the identification of the Hecatostylon with the remains of walls at the south end of the porticus Pompeiana is rejected, and this building is assigned to a location on the north side of the porticus. So, too, the current identification — always doubtful but usually accepted — of the basilica Neptuni with the remains of the great building that is part of the modern Bourse in the piazza di Pietra, is definitely thrown aside and Hiilsen maintains that this structure is without doubt the Hadrianeum, a temple built by Antoninus Pius in 145 a. d. in memory of his father. Instead of the ordinary view that the Gymnasium was a separate building, erected by Nero on the site afterward occupied by the Stadium of Domitian, Hiilsen believes it to have been merely a part of the thermae of Nero. He also maintains stoutly that there was a second cult-center of Mars in the northern part of the Gampus Martins near the river, in addition to the ancient ara Martis near the piazza Venezia. For a criticism of this theory the reader is referred to Vol. Ill, p. 65, of this journal. These illustrations will suffice to indicate how important the results of the author's conclusions often are, and it is evident that our maps of the ancient city must be considerably changed in some regions if these conclusions are valid. It is probable that the attention of topographers will be directed for some time to their careful examination. So far as I Book Keviews 357 have been able to subject them to such an examination, they have in most cases carried conviction — as was of course to be expected. In a work of this sort, where there are so many hundreds of references of the most diverse kinds, it seems to be impossible to avoid errors of citation and there are a number in this book. They are usually of a sort to occasion but little inconvenience, and are relatively of no importance whatever. The exhaustive knowledge and critical acumen of the author arouse continual admiration. S. B. P. Griechische Geschichte bis zur Schlacht bei Chaeronea. Band 3; Teil 2. "Der peloponnesische Krieg." Von Geoeg Busolt. Gotha: Perthes, 1904. Pp. 591-1640. M. 18. This volume which contains over one thousand pages is devoted entirely to the Peloponnesian War. In addition to a detailed table of contents, there are extremely useful chronological tables in which the events are assigned to months or seasons. In some respects there is a lack of uniformity. For example, one may well wonder why the production of Aristophanes' Lysistrata and Thesmophoriazousae is passed over, when such plays as the Birds, Knights, and Peace are included. The plan of relegating to the generous footnotes criticisms and sum- maries of opposing theories may have some justification in the strictly narrative part of the work as a concession to a "wider circle of readers;" but it is certainly distracting in the chapter devoted to a discussion of the sources, where in many cases the notes are more useful than the text, which often merely serves to acquaint the reader with the subjects treated in the copious footnotes. The causes of the war are set forth clearly and due emphasis is placed on the commercial rivalry between Athens and Corinth, and the Athenian policy of coercing Megara so as to protect herself against invasion. Busolt has no theories to champion but contents himself with presenting the facts of the political and military history as brought out by the best modern research. He is sparing and sane in his criticisms of policies and plans of campaign. In regard to the Sicilian expedition he in the main approves of the views of Nicias, adding a few references to other writers who have undertaken to justify Athenian policy in Sicily. His conservative attitude toward conflicting modem theories is well illustrated in his discussion of the "Four Hundred" where he has done more than any of his predecessors to reconcile the opposing views of Koehler and Meyer and their followers. Occasionally his desire to present all the theories leaves the reader in doubt as to his own opinion. This is particularly noticeable in his treatment of Theramenes. He fully recog- nizes the existence of the Moderate party in Athens. The English reader is likely to be confused sometimes by his terminology. As a rule he