STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. BOOK REVIEWS M. Fabi Quintiliani Institutionis Oratoriae Libri xii. Edidit Ludovicus Radebmacheb. Pars Prior, libros i-vi continens. Leipzig: Teubner, 1907. Pp. 359. M. 3. Complete editions of Quintilian recur in cycles, it would seem, of about twenty years. Halm's appeared in 1868, Meister's in 1886, and now we have the first volume of a new critical text. The intimation made in 1891 by Ferdinand Becher that he had such a task in hand sufficed to turn away from it others who may then have had inclinations in that direction. But ten years later Becher died and the new editor has fallen heir to his labors. In form and feature Kadermacher's edition is meant to replace Bonnell's well-known text, published in the Teubner series over half a century ago. In the interval the criticism of Quintilian has made conspicuous progress, and with the help of his coadjutors Radermacher has turned to good account, without overloading his appa- ratus, the floating material that lay ready to his hand. Becher had com- pleted only his commentary on the first book, but for the rest he left copious notes, critical and illustrative. As regards the MSS, his chief contribution was a complete collation of the Paris codex (7723) which belonged to Laurentius Valla: for Book x its readings have already been incorporated in the Oxford edition, where see p. lxxiv. Of this codex, which he calls P, the editor has made good use throughout, supporting or correcting it by Par. 7725 (Q), and for the great lacunae also by a fifteenth-century MS in the Vatican (1762=V). No reference is made to any of the MSS in English libraries. And yet in view of the present condition of the Vallensis (Praef ., p. ix), recourse might very well be had to Harl. 4995, which I used for the Oxford edition of Book x. And some reference might have been looked for to Harl. 2662 (H), a tenth- or eleventh-century codex, which ranks as the oldest complete MS of Quin- tilian in existence. If it is considered of no great importance, as being probably in great part a copy of the Bambergensis, it may be replied that the latter is itself a copy of the Bernensis. All three are practically contemporary, and some examination of the Harleianus might have shed light on the added parts of the Bamberg MS (G) as well as the readings of the second-hand (6). Alongside of H, the readings of such codies as the Florentinus (F) and the Turicensis (T) become more or less super- fluous. That Radermacher will do well to take account of H for the 346 Book Reviews 347 later books, especially where the Ambrosianus fails, will appear from the following jottings which I have culled from my notes. The read- ing given is in each case that found in the Harleianus. VI Prooem. §4: nisi quod (for quam quod). This should be restored to the text, especially as I am able to report that it is also the reading of the Bambergensis (G), as well as of V and S : ibid. § 7 quam for quod (A G). At i, §43, H is the only MS that shows inquit, hitherto credited to the ed. Campana : cf . § 47 ita neque (with P V) itaque we. V Prooem. § 1 gratia (with A) for vel ira. Here the second hand in Bg. has vel gratia. At 4, § 1, we have another remarkable instance of reversion to A: altera quaestionem vel falsa A H, where Bg. shows quaestionem written over the words of the text etiam causam. Cf. i. 4, §24: computabo (with A) ioxputabo: 7, §33 agentibus (with A P) for agendi (B). Moreover, for the early part of the first book, where the Bambergensis almost entirely fails, H should be quoted in its stead: e.g., Pr. §5 fieri oratorem non posse, §14 sapientiae studiosi, §25 demonstraturi. Again in the Prooemium §4 H shows summ (a i) neloquentie; the archetype probably had summam eloquentiae, for the passage relied on at x. 1. 97 to support summam in eloquentia is not exactly parallel. At i. 1. 19 H supports the vulgate per singulos annos prorogatum ; and gives at i. 2. 4 : nam et potest turpis esse domesticus tile praeceptor. At i. 3. 14 it has discipulis for discentis. Kadermacher makes generous reference to the labors of his prede- cessors. He holds fast (Praef., p. vi) to the established division of the MSS into three main families, and gives reasons (p. xi) why A should not always be preferred to B. Moreover, his careful selection of authori- ties has enabled him very considerably to simplify the critical apparatus. In particular, references to the edd. vett. are now in the main superfluous, as their readings in important places have been traced to one or other of the numerous MSS by which our knowledge of Quintilian's text has become enlarged. W. Peterson McGill University, Montreal November 1, 1907 Rerikemds Observationes criticae et exegeticae ad C. Valerii Flacci Argonautica. Traiecti ad Rhenum, 1906. Pp. 63. M. 3. This pamphlet on Valerius Flaccus' epic comes not inopportunely at no great distance of time from the publication of Giarratano's epoch- making edition of the text (1904). Renkema adds several new emenda- tions to the already large collection recorded by Giarratano. I cannot