STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 235 Apollonius, of whose family and affairs it has now become possible to form a somewhat definite picture. There are good introductions, notes, occa- sional translations, and indices covering the whole volume. The Hamburg papyri of Heft 2 are docxmients ranging in date from 222 B.C. to the sijrth or seventh century. Five are Ptolemaic, and one Byzantine. The rest range from the time of Domitian to 241 a.d. They come from the most part from the Faytlm, but one of them was written in Alexandria. It is the receipt book of an ofBcer, L. Julius Serenus, who in 179 A.D. was stationed at Nicopolis-Alexandria as summus curator, and, some years later retiring to his estates in the Faytoi, took with him his old military receipt book. The receipts are from cavalrymen of the Ala veterana Gallica for the hay-money each of them was accustomed to receive every four months for the support of his mount. There are good introductions and copious notes. The Lille papyri found by Jouguet and Lefebvre in the mummy carton- nages at Medinet-en-Nahas in the Faydm come from the ancient Magdola and have already been widely published and discussed. The present publica- tion is therefore the resultant of the labors of several scholars, British, French, and German, upon these difficult pieces. They were originally reckoned at 42, but Wilcken showed that Nos. 37 and 11 were parts of the same text, and since the appearance of the present volume von Druffel has pointed out that Nos. 38 and 6 fit together {Philologus, LXXI, 272). The number is thus reduced to 40. These range in date from the twenty-fifth year of Euergetes I to the fourth year of Philopator. They are for the most part complaints addressed to the king by residents of FayAm towns. An especially curious one is the appeal, from a person scalded in a bath through the carelessness of the attendant. The texts are accompanied with intro- ductions, translations, and notes, and are fully indexed. The volume is handsomely and, except for a few misprints (i/'iXos, -ou, -ov, pp. 151, 153, 159, 219; cTKeuos, p. 218; Sovtos, pp. 164, 165; ■n-apovTos, p. 11), carefully printed. EdGAB J. GOODSPBED University op Chicago Homer. Von Georg Finsleb. Erster Teil, "Der Dichter und seine Welt." Zweite Auflage. Leipzig: Teubner, 1914. Pp. xvi-f460. M. 5. In this revised and greatly enlarged edition the author has found it wise to reserve for a second volimie an analysis of the Iliad and the Odyssey and to treat the general problems in this first part under four heads: I, "Vorfragen," 1-71. Here the author discusses with ability and judgment the home of the Homeric heroes, the material and the background of the poetry, also the early sagas, the name and personaUty of Homer, as 236 Book Reviews well as early writing, the assumed recension of Peisistratus, and other related matters. He rejects the theory of a recension under Peisistratus and is most severe on the pretensions and methods of Wolf. II, "Die Homerische Welt," 72-303. This contains the bulk of the book and covers the same ground as that covered by Professor Seymour in his Life in the Homeric Age, which seems to have escaped the notice of the author, as it is never mentioned. Professor Finsler has the most intimate and accurate knowledge of every phase of Homeric life, so that I find nothing to change or to criticize in these 240 pages. III, "Homerische Poesie," 304-40. The characteristics and merits of the Iliad and Odyssey are stated with unusual learning and felicity. IV, "Die Homerkritik," 341-443. A discussion of the problem of Homeric composition and the solution given from earliest times down to the present year, a brief, fair, and reliable presentation of all sides of the con- troversy. Professor Finsler belongs among the leaders in Homeric scholarship, he knows Homer and he knows the literature, he is modest, honest, and has a feeling for the beauties of poetry; only when he touches the subject of Homeric authorship does he lose that clear vision with which he beholds other matters. Except for the inevitable contradictions and false statements which accompany his arguments for diverse authorship I see nothing to condemn. He places the composition of the Iliad a little before 700, of the Odyssey about a century later, and argues that until well in the fifth century Homer was known only as the poet of the Iliad. He makes this argxunent (p. 66) : "Zum Schluss moge noch ein Zeugnis daftir Raiun finden, dass auch spater unter Homer nur der Dichter der Ilias verstanden wurde. Xenophanes von Kolophon polemisiert urn 500 gegen die unwiirdigen Vorstellimgen Homers von den Gottem. Das trifft aber vorztigUch auf die Ilias zu"; and again (p. 68): "Xenophanes meint den Dichter der Ilias, wenn er sagt. Homer hatte den Gottem alles angehangt, was bei den Menschen Schimpf und Schande sei." However, in the Odyssey the hero cannot reach home because of the wrath of Poseidon, a most unworthy wrath, due to the hero's self-defense against the god's cannibal son. The Phaeacians meet with vengeance from the gods and their harbor is closed because they gave safe conduct to lost wanderers. Achilles regarded falsehood as unworthy a Greek leader, yet Athena comes to Ithaca with a false tale and does not scruple to tell any falsehood which may serve her purpose. Calypso unfolds to Hermes a catalogue of divine intrigues and divine jealousies, while the song of Demod- ocus pictures some of the gods as most lustful and ridiculous. The gods of the Iliad may be more prone to blood, but they are at war. Men as well as gods take on a more savage nature in time of war, but the moral character of the divine actors is not a whit loftier in the Odyssey than in the Iliad, and the criticism of Xenophanes applies to both alike. Book Reviews 237 On p. 342 Finsler assumes that in Herodotus Homer was not regarded as the poet of the Odyssey, but of the Iliad alone. This inference is false, as these quotations will show: Her. ii. 116 quotes 8227-29 as found in the Odyssey of Homer, ii. 116 quotes S351, expressly saying that these verses are in the Odyssey of Homer. He paraphrases ^ 258 ff. in ii. 119, saying they are the words of Homer, and again, iv. 29, he says: juaprvpea 8e /m>i ry ■yvoJ/ig Kol '0/i^po« Ittos iv '08v