STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 225 but champions his work as a whole. "We British cherish an inborn mistrust of all subtlety of mind and of some forms of originality, and a writer who combines these qualities with what we call 'brilliance' is likely to find his very merits a bar to the ready acceptance of his message. If Verrall had written in France for French scholars, their only hesitation, I fancy, would have been as to which to do first — ^kiss him on both cheeks or lay wreaths on their copies of Euripides." But "no man has taken up Verrall's gage," he adds, and expresses without reserve "the conviction that before this generation has passed away, Verrall's view of the work of Euripides will be the accepted view, and that mere murmurs of disapproval will cease to command attention." Whether the reader agrees with this or not, he wUl gladly acknowledge Verrall's genius for criticism, admire his character, and enjoy the activities of a mind that so thoroughly enjoyed its own activities. Ghant Showerman UNrvBRSiTY OP Wisconsin W. S. Teuffels Geschichte der romischen Literatur. Sechste Auflage unter Mitwirkung von Erich Klostermann, Rudolf Leon- hard, und Paul Wessner, neu bearbeitet von Wilhelm Kroll und Franz Skutsch. Dritter Band, Die Literatur von 96 nach Chr. bis zum Ausgange des Altertums. Leipzig und Berlin: Teubner, 1913. Pp. viii+579. M. 10. The third volume of Teuffel covers the period from Juvenal to Aldhelm and Baeda. The field has been divided among several collaborators. Skutsch, who was to have done the poets, had finished only the earUer ones (Juvenal to Ausonius and the Qwrolm), about 31 pages in all. Kroll has done the profane prose writers and the poets from Claudian on, almost the half of the entire volume. Klostermann revised the Christian writers, Leonhard the jurists, and Wessner the grammarians. The volume has increased from 493 pages (436 in the English edition) to 554 pages, not including the index, which is fuller than in the old edition. The section numbers of the old edition have been retained; in some instances (e.g., 320, 342, 402) the paragraph consists entirely of cross- references, the authors now being assigned to different periods. The sub- section numbers have been retained for the most part; even where the paragraphs have been shifted to other sections or where new paragraphs have been inserted, an effort seems to have been made to disturb the old numbering as little as possible. The revision has been confined chiefly to the subsections; few changes have been made in the main paragraphs, except in the general introductory 226 Book Reviews ones. The dates are of course corrected, misstatements eliminated, and here and there a happy characterization inserted. A large nmnber of changes are purely stylistic. Both in the main paragraphs and in the subsections condensation has been aimed at. In this respect Kroll has been especially successful. In spite of many additions to the bibliography he has reduced the number of pages by nearly 15; this has been accomplished in part by excision, e.g., of the bibliography under the head of "Textkritik" (334, 335, 336, 337, 338) and " Ausgaben " (444) , etc. It is at this point that the new edition will have to meet the most serious criticism. The Uterature has increased to such an extent that it is practically impossible to make a satisfactory selection with- out greatly increasing the bulk of the volume. A comparison with Schanz is inevitable. Even in the case of the enlarged articles the discrepancy is still very great; e.g., Cyprian has increased from less than 3 to more than 9 pages but still falls far short of Schanz (40 pp.) ; the article on Hieronymus has increased from 5J to 151 pages as against 69 pages in Schanz. This discrep- ancy is more apparent than real, however, since so large a part of Schanz is devoted to discussion, the absence of which in Teuffel has won for it so large a following among scholars who want in a history of literature a "first aid" for quick orientation. For such scholars these cheap and handy volumes will still serve the purpose admirably. The weakest part of the old edition was the treatment of the Christian writers; these articles Klostermann has subjected to a thorough overhauling. The space devoted to them has been increased by a half (that given to the more important writers being more than doubled) and they occupy a little less than a third of the whole volume. It is needless to say that this work has been well done. Scarcely less antiquated were the chapters deaUng with the gramma- rians. The paragraphs have been rearranged, rewritten, and enlarged. We now have an adequate treatment of the subject by a scholar who is thor- oughly acquainted with its complicated problems and the literature. Leonhard's revision of the jurists consists chiefly in bringing the literature down to date. The index should be corrected before further impressions are made. I note the following errors in the first three pages: Ps.-Acron, read 365 a, 2 for 365, 2; AemiUanus' Leben von Braulio, read 495, 5 for 494, 5; Aetherianus, read 387, 3 for 386, 3; Alfenius, read Alfenus; Ammianus Marcellinus, read 470, 9E for 470, 4E; Antiochenus, read 423, 2M for 422, 2M; Appendix Probi, read 385, SgEjfor 385; Apuleius, read Fulgentius 366, 8 for Fulgentius 480, 3; Aquila Romanus, read Sacerdos 394, IgE for 344, IgE; Arehaisten, read 400, 5 for 417, 5; Astyanax, read 387, ifor 387, 3; Aufidius, read 414, 5 for 414, 9; the Menander referred to in 453, IE is the Greek poet, not Arrius Menander the jurist. Book Reviews 227 In 379 the praenomen of Caerellius should be Q., not A. ; in 476, 1 Jenkin- son's edition of Hisperica Famina should be referred to; in 480, 12 Traube's Regula Benedidi should be cited in the second edition. Chaelbs H. Beeson University of Chicago Die Lebensalter: Ein Beitrag zur antiken Ethnologic und zur Geschichte der Zahlen, mit einem Anhang uher die Schrift von der Siebenzahl. Mit zwei Tafeln. By Fbanz Boll. Leipzig: B. G. Teubner, 1913. Pp.58. M. 2.40. This is an off-print from Vol. XXXI (pp. 89-145) of the Neue Jahr- bucher fur das klassische Altertum, issued with new pagination, while noting the old in the inner margin, as a separate pubUcation. Every student of the classics will derive profit and delectation from the reading of Professor Boll's interesting and well-written essay, which treats of a subject pecuUarly fasci- nating to old and yoimg alike. Others also besides classical philologists will find it profitable reading because of the wide diffusion in modem literatures of the conceptions the history of which Professor Boll sketches. Naturally his illustrations from modem literatures other than German are few, and every reader can add points which will inevitably occur to him. I confess that I was quite as much interested in the Appendix as in the essay itself. This consists of a critique of Roscher's views touching Hip- pocrates IIcpi e;88o/xa8a)v, and is undoubtedly the most important contribution so far made to the discussion. There are some points on which BoU is unques- tionably right as against Roscher, who has since repUed to his criticisms in Die hippokratische Schrift von der Siebenzahl, Paderbom, 1913, pp. 154-61; but there are others at which both are in error or in the dark. In so brief a notice as this space cannot be spared for many details, but I may refer to one. Boll (pp. 50ff.=pp. 138 ff.) calls attention to the comparison of the earth to a human body in Ilept ifiSo/jui^v and its similarity to a passage in the hermetic tractate Kopi; koc/xou, Stobaeus i. 411. 3ff. Wachsm. Appar- ently BoUs, as well as Roscher, failed to note that the latter passage does not stand alone but reproduces a view which Aristotle presents in opposition to that of the Pythagoreans touching the directions up and down, right and left in the cosmos. Unfortunately neither Aristotle nor his commentators give us a hint as to the origin of the view which he advances, though it agrees pre- cisely with that which occurs in Kopr; Koa/iov and which Boll pronounces genuinely Egyptian. Arist. De caelo B 2 makes the South Pole the upper, the North Pole the nether point of the cosmos: S^Xov tolwv oti o d<^v^s jroXos €(TTi TO avuy. Kai oi ftkv 6k« oi/covvres ev TcS avii> Aaxv ■^fuo'fjxupio) kou, wpos ToTs ocfioTs, ■q/xiti S' iv ts ot Hvdayopeioi Xeyovcnv' eKeivoi yap rjfjMi avio TroioSo-t Kal ev Tia Septal p,€pa, toiis S' e/cei Kara) Kal iv TiS dpi.a-Tep